登陆注册
5590800000028

第28章 Political Theory(6)

This deserves notice because the position is characteristic of the Utilitarians'method.Their appeals to experience always end by absolute assertions,We shall find the same difficulty in their economic inquiries,When accused,for example,of laying down absolute principles in such cases,they reply that they are only speaking of 'tendencies,'and recognise the existence of 'checks,'they treat of what would be,if certain forces acted without limit,as a necessary step towards discovering what is when the limits exist.They appear to their opponents to forget the limits in their practical conclusions.This political argument is an instance of the same method.The genesis of his theory is plain.Mill's 'government,'like Bentham's,is simply the conception of legal 'sovereignty'transferred to the sphere of politics.Mill's exposition is only distinguished from his master's by the clearness with which he brings out the underlying assumptions.The legal sovereign is omnipotent,for what he declares to be the law is therefore the law.The law is his commands enforced by 'sanctions,'and therefore by organised force,the motives for obedience are the fear of the gallows on one side,and,on the other,the desire of protection for life and property.Law,again,is the ultimate social bond,and can be made at will by the sovereign.

He thus becomes so omnipotent that it is virtually assumed that he can even create himself.Not only can the sovereign,once constituted,give commands enforced by coercive sanctions upon any kind of conduct,but he can determine his own constitution.He can at once,for example,create a representative system in practice,when it has been discovered in theory,and can by judicious regulations so distribute 'self-interest'as to produce philanthropy and public spirit.Macaulay's answer really makes a different assumption.He accepts the purely 'empirical'or 'rule of thumb'position,it is idle,he says,to ask what would happen if there were no 'checks,'it is like leaving out the effect of friction in a problem of mechanics,the logic may be correct,but the conclusions are false in practice.36Now this 'friction'was precisely the favourite expedient of the Utilitarians in political economy.To reason about facts,they say,you must analyse,and therefore provisionally disregard the 'checks,'which must be afterwards introduced in practical applications.Macaulay is really bidding us take 'experience'in the lump,and refrains from the only treatment which can lead to a scientific result.His argument,in fact,agrees with that of his famous essay on Bacon,where we learn that philosophy applied to moral questions is all nonsense,and that science is simply crude common-sense.

He is really saying that all political reasoning is impossible,and that we must trust to unreasoned observation.Macaulay,indeed,has good grounds of criticism.He shows very forcibly the absurdity of transferring the legal to the political sovereignty.Parliament might,as he says,make a law that every gentleman with £2000a year might flog a pauper with a cat-of-nine-tails whenever he pleased.But,as the first exercise of such a power would be the 'last day of the English aristocracy,'their power is strictly limited in fact.37That gives very clearly the difference between legal and political sovereignty.What parliament makes law is law,but is not therefore enforceable.We have to go behind the commands and sanctions before we understand what is the actual power of government.It is very far from omnipotent.Macaulay,seeing this,proceeds to throw aside Mill's argument against the possibility of a permanent division of power.The de facto limitation of the sovereign's power justifies the old theory about 'mixed forms of government.''Mixed governments'are not impossible,for they are real.All governments are,in fact,'mixed.'Louis XIV could not cut off the head of any one whom he happened to dislike.

An oriental despot is strictly bound by the religious prejudices of his subjects.If 'sovereignty'means such power it is a chimera in practice,or only realised approximately when,as in the case of negro slavery,a class is actually ruled by force in the hands of a really external power.

And yet the attack upon 'mixed governments,'which Bentham had expounded in the Fragment,has a real force which Macaulay seems to overlook.Mill's argument against a possible 'balance'of power was,as Macaulay asserted,equally applicable to the case of independent sovereigns;yet France might be stronger at Calais and England at Dover.38Mill might have replied that a state is a state precisely because,and in so far as,there is an agreement to recognise a common authority or sovereign.Government does not imply a 'mixture,'but a fusion of power.There is a unity,though not the abstract unity of the Utilitarian sovereign.The weakness of the Utilitarians is to speak as though the sovereign,being external to each individual,could therefore be regarded as external to the whole society.

He rules as a strong nation may rule a weak dependency.When the sovereign becomes also the society,the power is regarded as equally absolute,though now applied to the desirable end of maximising happiness.The whole argument ignores the simple consideration that the sovereign is himself in all cases the product of the society over which he rules,and his whole action,even in the most despotic governments,determined throughout by organic instincts,explaining and not ultimately explicable by coercion.Macaulay's doctrine partially recognises this by falling back upon the Whig theory of checks and balances,and the mixture of three mysterious entities,monarchy,aristocracy,and democracy.But,as Bentham had sufficiently shown in the Fragment,the theory becomes hopelessly unreal when we try to translate it into facts.

同类推荐
  • 六字神咒经

    六字神咒经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 蜕庵集

    蜕庵集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • Man and Superman

    Man and Superman

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 重阳真人金关玉锁诀

    重阳真人金关玉锁诀

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 三慧经

    三慧经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 若生若木

    若生若木

    女娲封印魔神,以身化作轮回,鬼君受女娲所托,世代看守,昆仑镇守封印。万年后,女娲石不知所踪,幽冥知情不报,封印解除之际,昆仑弟子末世,以身封印,鬼君强行使用禁术嗜魂,留住末世一丝神魂,入轮回之境,命运之轮就此开启……
  • Fennel and Rue

    Fennel and Rue

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 玄符武帝

    玄符武帝

    秦轩出生微末,在卑微中坚守意外之下获得符帝记忆,融合其霸道和见识。自此,秦轩眼界大开,心性大变,欲与天公试比高,坚定超凡信念。以玄虚门为根基,以绝强之势,超凡之资,碾压各方,推尽一切阻碍,成就至尊强者。
  • 沈岩船政文化讲稿精选

    沈岩船政文化讲稿精选

    船政是非常之举,是三千年大变革的历史产物。1866年,清廷在福州马尾设立“总理船政事务衙门”,在中国近代海军史、工业史、教育史、思想文化史上都留下深深的印迹。船政是中华民族觉醒的典范,是社会转型的先行先试者,其历史地位是不可磨灭或替代的。沈葆桢是首任船政大臣,认真研究这位历史人物的生平与事迹,是很有意义的。本书选取船政研究专家沈岩关于船政系列讲座和沈葆桢专题的部分讲稿结集出版,以飨读者。
  • 九州灵域记

    九州灵域记

    人皇南宫槊的离奇失踪,皇城外的起兵叛乱,皇城内的血腥杀戮,九州大陆的危急?……南宫泽携带至宝天书,是否能成长起来,发觉真相,拯救苍生?
  • 战神王后

    战神王后

    一饭之恩,当涌泉相报。她为他披上铠甲,浴血杀敌。狡兔死,走狗烹。哀莫大于心死。她脱下华美宫装,摘下狰狞面具,归隐山林。失去之后,他才发现她的好,他已经习惯了有她的日子。而她,前尘往事,却已经彻底遗忘……
  • 我和上仙那些事

    我和上仙那些事

    那是一个上古的时代。那时的她依偎在他的身旁,看着云卷云舒,看着风云变,看着四季轮回。那时的她是多么的天真灿烂,只要有什么烦心的事都向他说,只要有什么不顺心的事都向他诉说着。也许是上天见不得他们安宁快乐罢,也许是上天跟他们开一个玩笑罢。突然来了一个上仙抱走了磐石,从此就剩紫莲花孤零零的呆在原地。
  • 八大灵塔梵赞

    八大灵塔梵赞

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 伪快穿0a

    伪快穿0a

    人的一生,短短数十载,少年你想获得永生吗?!来吧,签订契约,让我得到你的鲜血,我来帮你完成愿望格里菲斯.梵卓.辛茜莉亚,中文名夜墨幽,在她永无止境的生命里,她渴求刺激的生活,可这万年一成不变的日子她过够了“少年,你想得到永生吗?!”“啊啊啊,魔鬼,魔鬼……”本文不接受批评,啥时候更看作者心情,喜欢接着看下去,不喜欢就拉到,可能不是你最喜欢的类型,但却是你没看过的类型
  • 阅读封神系统

    阅读封神系统

    觉醒阅读成神系统,从此苏牧发现了阅读的好处。读斗破获得净莲妖火、读遮天获得先天圣体道胎、读洪荒获得无上功德。“只有读书才是唯一的出路啊。”苏牧站在世间最顶峰说道。