Finance never appealed to him.A wide application may be given to Herndon's remark that "he had no money sense."All the rest of the Republican doctrine finds its best statement in Lincoln.
On the one subject of its economic policy he is silent.
Apparently it is to be classified with the routine side of the law.To neither was he ever able to give more than a perfunctory attention.As an artist in politics he had the defect of his qualities.
What his qualities showed him were two things:the alliance of the plutocratic slave power with the plutocratic money power,and the essential rightness in impulse of the bulk of the Southern people.Hence his conclusion which became his party's conclusion:that,in the South,a political-financial ring was dominating a leaderless people,This was not the truth.
Lincoln's defects in 1860limited his vision.Nevertheless,to the solitary distant thinker,shut in by the near horizon of political Springfield,there was every excuse for the error.
The palpable evidence all confirmed it.What might have contradicted it was a cloud of witnesses,floating,incidental,casual,tacit.Just what a nature like Lincoln's,if only he could have met them,would have perceived and comprehended;what a nature like Douglas's,no matter how plainly they were presented to him,could neither perceive nor comprehend.It was the irony of fate that an opportunity to fathom his time was squandered upon the unseeing Douglas,while to the seeing Lincoln it was denied.In a word,the Southern reaction against the Republicans,like the Republican movement itself,had both a positive and a negative side.It was the positive side that could be seen and judged at long range.And this was what Lincoln saw,which appeared to him to have created the dominant issue in 1860.
The negative side of the Southern movement he did not see.He was too far away to make out the details of the picture.
Though he may have known from the census of 1850that only one-third of the Southern whites were members of slave-holding families,he could scarcely have known that only a small minority of the Southern families owned as many as five slaves;that those who had fortunes in slaves were a mere handful--just as today those who have fortunes in steel or beef are mere handfuls.But still less did he know how entirely this vast majority which had so little,if any,interest in slavery,had grown to fear and distrust the North.They,like him,were suffering from a near horizon.They,too,were applying the principle "Stand with anybody so long as he stands right"But for them,standing right meant preventing a violent revolution in Southern life.Indifferent as they were to slavery,they were willing to go along with the "slave-barons"in the attempt to consolidate the South in a movement of denial--a denial of the right of the North,either through Abolitionism or through tariff,to dominate the South.
If only Lincoln with his subtle mind could have come into touch with the negative side of the Southern agitation!It was the other side,the positive side,that was vocal.With immense shrewdness the profiteers of slavery saw and developed their opportunity.They organized the South.They preached on all occasions,in all connections,the need of all Southerners to stand together,no matter how great their disagreements,in order to prevent the impoverishment of the South by hostile economic legislation.During the late 'fifties their propaganda for an all-Southern policy,made slow but constant headway.But even in 1859these ideas were still far from controlling the South.
And then came John Brown.The dread of slave insurrection was laid deep in Southern recollection.Thirty years before,the Nat Turner Rebellion had filled a portion of Virginia with burned plantation houses amid whose ruins lay the dead bodies of white women.A little earlier,a negro conspiracy at Charleston planned the murder of white men and the parceling out of white women among the conspirators.And John Brown had come into Virginia at the head of a band of strangers calling upon the slaves to rise and arm.
Here was a supreme opportunity.The positive Southern force,the slave profiteers,seized at once the attitude of champions of the South.It was easy enough to enlist the negative force in a shocked and outraged denunciation of everything Northern.
And the Northern extremists did all that was in their power to add fuel to the flame.Emerson called Brown "this new saint who had made the gallows glorious as the cross."The Southerners,hearing that,thought of the conspiracy to parcel out the white women of Charleston.Early in 1860it seemed as if the whole South had but one idea-to part company with the North.
No wonder Lincoln threw all his influence into the scale to discredit the memory of Brown.No wonder the Republicans in their platform carefully repudiated him.They could not undo the impression made on the Southern mind by two facts:the men who lauded Brown as a new saint were voting the Republican ticket;the Republicans had committed themselves to the anti-Southern policy of protection.
And yet,in spite of all the labors of pro-slavery extremists,the movement for a breach with the North lost ground during 1860.When the election came,the vote for President revealed a singular and unforeseen situation.Four candidates were in the field.The Democrats,split into two by the issue of slavery expansion,formed two parties.The slave profiteers secured the nomination by one faction of John C.Breckinridge.
