登陆注册
5698300000231

第231章

The consequence of the infinitude of law is its uncertainty. This strikes at the principle upon which law is founded. Laws were made to put an end to ambiguity , and that each man might know what he had to expect. How well have they answered this purpose? Let us instance in the article of property. Two men go to law for a certain estate. They would not go to law if they had not both of them an opinion of the success. But we may suppose them partial in their own case. They would not continue to go to law if they were not both promised success by their lawyers. Law was made that a plain man might know what he had to expect; and yet the most skilful practitioners differ about the event of my suit. It will sometimes happen that the most celebrated pleader in the kingdom, or the first counsel in the service of the crown, shall assure me of infallible success, five minutes before another law-officer, styled the keeper of the king's conscience, by some unexpected juggle decides it against me. Would the issue have been equally uncertain if I had had nothing to trust to but the plain unperverted sense of a jury of my neighbours, founded in the ideas they entertained of general justice? Lawyers have absurdly maintained that the expensiveness of law is necessary to prevent the unbounded multiplication of suits; but the true source of this multiplication is uncertainty. Men do not quarrel about that which is evident, but that which is obscure.

He that would study the laws of a country accustomed to legal security must begin with the volumes of the statutes. He must add a strict enquiry into the common or unwritten law; and he ought to digress into the civil, the ecclesiastical and canon law. To understand the intention of the authors of a law, he must be acquainted with their characters and views, and with the various circumstances to which it owed its rise, and by which it was modified while under deliberation. To understand the weight and interpretation that will be allowed to it in a court of justice, he must have studied the whole collection of records, decisions and precedents. Law was originally devised that ordinary men might know what they had to expect; and there is not, at this day, a lawyer existing in Great Britain vain-glorious enough to pretend that he has mastered the code. Nor must it be forgotten that time and industry, even were they infinite, would not suffice. It is a labyrinth without end ; it is a mass of contradictions that cannot be disentangled.

Study will enable the lawyer to find in it plausible, perhaps unanswerable, arguments for any side of almost any question; but it would argue the utmost folly to suppose that the study of law can lead to knowledge and certainty.

A further consideration that will demonstrate the absurdity of law in its most general acceptation is that it is of the nature of prophecy .

Its task is to describe what will be the actions of mankind, and to dictate decisions respecting them. Its merits, in this respect, have already been decided under the head of promises. The language of such a procedure is 'We are so wise that we can draw no additional knowledge from circumstances as they occur; and we pledge ourselves that, if it be otherwise, the additional knowledge we acquire shall produce no effect upon our conduct.' It is proper to observe that this subject of law may be considered, in some respects, as more properly belonging to the topic of the preceding book. Law tends, no less than creeds, catechisms and tests, to fix the human mind in a stagnant condition, and to substitute a principle of permanence in the room of that unceasing progress which is the only salubrious element of mind. All the arguments therefore which were employed upon that occasion may be applied to the subject now under consideration.

The fable of Procrustes presents us with a faint shadow of the perpetual effort of law. In defiance of the great principle of natural philosophy, that there are not so much as two atoms of matter of the same form through the whole universe, it endeavours to reduce the actions of men, which are composed of a thousand evanescent elements, to one standard. We have already seen the tendency of this endeavour in the article of murder. It was in the contemplation of this system of jurisprudence that the strange maxim was invented that 'strict justice would often prove the highest injustice.'

There is no more real justice in endeavouring to reduce the actions of men into classes than there was in the scheme to which we have just alluded, of reducing all men to the same stature. If, on the contrary, justice be a result flowing from the contemplation of all the circumstances of each individual case, if only the criterion of justice be general utility, the inevitable consequence is that the more we have of justice, the more we shall have of truth, virtue and happiness.

From all these considerations we can scarcely hesitate to conclude universally that law is an institution of the most pernicious tendency.

The subject will receive some additional elucidation if we consider the perniciousness of law in its immediate relation to those who practise it. If there ought to be no such thing as law, the profession of lawyer is no doubt entitled to our disapprobation. A lawyer can scarcely fail to be a dishonest man. This is less a subject for censure than for regret.

同类推荐
  • 花月痕

    花月痕

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 禅要经

    禅要经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 俞楼诗记

    俞楼诗记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 宿东岩寺晓起

    宿东岩寺晓起

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 藏海诗话

    藏海诗话

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 伤科大成

    伤科大成

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 大宋超级学霸

    大宋超级学霸

    那一年,大宋甲级足球联赛正热,国民老公苏东坡金榜高中。那一年,京城房价一飞冲天,老干部欧阳修买房不及时被夫人赶出家门。就在那一年,赵官家上元夜偷窥香艳女相扑,被朝阳群众司马光当场抓获。也是那一年,王老虎携女参加非诚勿扰,扬言非进士不嫁,金明池畔四大才子仓惶奔逃。还是那一年,河东狮喜拜婚堂,胭脂虎相亲正忙,全国神童大赛各路少年英才开始隆重登场。
  • 责任:态度与执行力

    责任:态度与执行力

    《责任:态度与执行力》一书,用浅显易懂的语言、富有逻辑的篇章、大量生动的案例向我们阐明了态度的重要性以及执行力的根本,使我们接受了一场现代管理思想的洗礼,从而破解了许多压抑在心头的疑云,看到了自己身上以及周边存在的一些问题,为今后提高工作效率提供了更加科学有效的方式和方法。
  • 救命之恩当以身相许

    救命之恩当以身相许

    姜平然是一个活了很多年的老姑娘,拥有平凡人更多的时间和长久的美貌。在这漫长的时光里,她无波无澜,直到她意外救下一位少年,并和那少年有过一月同在屋檐下的时光。九年后,祁景彦再见到日思夜想的“恩人”,觉得无以为报,只能以身相许。面对祁景彦的甜言蜜语,死缠烂打,不依不饶,死性不改。姜平然咆哮:喂!我这年纪都够当你太太太奶奶了!你怎么下得了口!祁景彦笑:你就算逃到天涯海角我也会追着你!
  • 索尼法则(世界500强企业发展丛书)

    索尼法则(世界500强企业发展丛书)

    在20世纪经济发展史上,崛起了一个实力雄厚的企业群体——“世界500强”跨国公司。据有关资料显示:“世界500强”企业从事和控制着全球生产总值的三分之一,世界贸易的三分之一,国际直接投资的70%。这些跨国企业不仅促进了整个世纪的工业革命与技术创新,推动了全球经济的飞速发展,而且在创造巨大物质财富的同时,创造了卓越的企业文化,成为全球企业的可资借鉴的范例。
  • 我不是教你做“坏”女人

    我不是教你做“坏”女人

    本书从女人的观念、心态、品味形象、爱情、社交、说话、办事、理财、事业九个方面解剖“老实”女人的生活,从中提炼出了“不老实“女人的智慧,这些智慧不仅能够让原本老实的女人在为人处世方面有一个大的转变,而且让她们在人生观和价值观方面也将有一个新的转变。本书对老实不懂圆滑世故的女人来讲是一本不错的人生导航仪。
  • 绝唱

    绝唱

    当晚9点,落魄诗人邱天跌跌撞撞往前走,遭遇到了一根贴满五彩广告的电线杆,抬手抱住摸了摸,嘴里喃喃地自言自语:“布告栏怎么变瘦了?”两个男孩脚下踏着滑板,身穿文化衫和宽牛仔短裤,嘻嘻地笑着大声说:“嘿,快看!他都快醉成烂泥了。”说完像大海里的两条快乐飞鱼,嗖地从邱天身边一跃而过。落魄诗人邱天还不知道是在指他,抬头寻找到底是谁喝醉了。这一抬头不要紧,身体里仅有的血液再也流不进大脑,让他两眼一黑,啪地坐在了地上。适应了好一会儿,邱天终于睁开了眼睛。这一睁开不要紧,他看见了天空。天空黑沉沉的,点缀着一些闪烁的星光,像某个醉汉在天幕上砸碎了。
  • Between Two Ends
  • 胡王妃

    胡王妃

    她曾两次被君王看上,而他穷尽一生只为她谋取自由,远离世俗,跨越族群,披荆斩棘的爱何时到达终点?
  • 一品凰女

    一品凰女

    传言,王爷俊美迷人,不仅智谋超群,而且性格柔善,堪称全城男子膜拜的典范……而她,一朝苏醒,却对上他森冷的凤眸,还没来得及回神,就被强行灌下毒药!她抵死挣扎,却屡次被擒,捏着她的下巴,他嘴角扬起戏谑的笑意:鸾儿,你逃不掉的……【情节虚构,请勿模仿】