登陆注册
4699300000010

第10章

COMMON IDEAS REGARDING THE HISTORY OF PHILOSOPHY.

At this point appear these ordinary superficial ideas regarding the history of Philosophy which have to be referred to and corrected. As regards these very current views, which are doubtless known to you, gentlemen, for indeed they are the reflections most likely to occur in one's first crude thoughts on a history of Philosophy, I will shortly explain what requires explanation, and the explanation of the differences in philosophies will lead us further into the matter itself.

a. The History of Philosophy as an accumulation of Opinions.

History, at the first glance, includes in its aim the narration of the accidental circumstances of times, of races, and of individuals, treated impartially partly as regards their relation in time, and partly as to their content. The appearance of contingency in time-succession is to be dealt with later on. It is contingency of content which is the idea with which we have first to deal-the idea of contingent actions. But thoughts and not external actions, or griefs, or joys, form the content of Philosophy.

Contingent thoughts, however, are nothing but opinions, and philosophical opinions are opinions relating to the more special content of Philosophy, regarding God, Nature and Spirit.

Thus we now meet the view very usually taken of the history of Philosophy which ascribes to it the narration of a number of philosophical opinions as they have arisen and manifested themselves in time. This kind of matter is in courtesy called opinions; those who think themselves more capable of judging rightly, call such a history a display of senseless follies, or at least of errors made by men engrossed in thought and in mere ideas. This view is not only held by those who recognize their ignorance of Philosophy. Those who do this, acknowledge it, because that ignorance is, in common estimation, held to be no obstacle to giving judgment upon what has to do with the subject; for it is thought that anybody can form a judgment on its character and value without any comprehension of it whatever. But the same view is even held by those who write or have written on the history of Philosophy. This history, considered only as the enumeration of various opinions, thus becomes an idle tale, or, if you will, an erudite investigation. For erudition is, in the main, acquaintance with a number of useless things, that is to say, with that which has no intrinsic interest or value further than being known. Yet it is thought that profit is to be derived from learning the various opinions and reflections of other men. It stimulates the powers of thought and also leads to many excellent reflections; this signifies that now and then it occasions an idea and its art thus consists in the spinning one opinion out of the other.

If the history of Philosophy merely represented various opinions in array, whether they be of God or of natural and spiritual things existent, it would be a most superfluous and tiresome science, no matter what advantage might be brought forward as derived from such thought-activity and learning. What can be more useless than to learn a string of bald opinions, and what more unimportant? Literary works, being histories of Philosophy in the sense that they produce and treat the ideas of Philosophy as if they were opinions, need be only superficially glanced at to find how dry and destitute of interest everything about them is.

An opinion is a subjective conception, an uncontrolled thought, an idea which may occur to me in one direction or in another: an opinion is mine, (3) it is in itself a universal thought which is existent in and for itself. But Philosophy possesses no opinions, for there is no such thing as philosophical opinions. When we hear a man speaking of philosophical opinions, even though he be an historian of philosophy itself, we detect at once this want of fundamental education. Philosophy is the objective science of truth, it is science of necessity, conceiving knowledge, and neither opinion nor the spinning out of opinions.

The more precise significance of this idea is that we get to know opinions only, thus laying emphasis upon the word Opinion. Now the direct opposite of opinion is the Truth; it is Truth before which mere opinion pales. Those who in the history of Philosophy seek mere theories, or who suppose that on the whole only such are to be found within it, also turn aside when that word Truth confronts them. Philosophy here encounters opposition from two different sides. On the one hand piety openly declares Reason or Thought to be incapable of apprehending what is true, and to lead only to the abyss of doubt; it declares that independent thought must be renounced, and reason held in bounds by faith in blind authority, if Truth is to be reached. Of the relation existing between Religion and Philosophy and of its history, we shall deal later on. On the other hand, it is known just as well, that so-called reason has maintained its rights, abandoning faith in mere authority, and has endeavoured to make Christianity rational, so that throughout it is only my personal insight and conviction which obliges me to make any admissions. But this affirmation of the right of reason is turned round in an astonishing manner, so that it results in making knowledge of the truth through reason an impossibility. This so-called reason on the one hand has combated religious faith in the name and power of thinking reason, and at the same time it has itself turned against reason and is true reason's adversary. Instinct and feeling are maintained by it against the true reason, thus making the measure of true value the merely subjective-that is a particular conviction such as each can form in and for himself in his subjective capacity. A personal conviction such as this is no more than the particular opinion that has become final for men.

同类推荐
  • American Hand Book of the Daguerreotype

    American Hand Book of the Daguerreotype

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • Bentham

    Bentham

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 普庵印肃禅师语录

    普庵印肃禅师语录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 尊胜佛顶修瑜伽法轨仪

    尊胜佛顶修瑜伽法轨仪

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 全唐诗话

    全唐诗话

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 九州荒唐国

    九州荒唐国

    俗套的故事,总是以美人开头。可是故事的结局,也必然是美人失去头颅。
  • 复仇四公主的冷血计划

    复仇四公主的冷血计划

    [本书纯属虚构]她们,用冰冷,用温柔,用调皮可爱来来伪装自己,在别人眼里是这样,可在她们眼里她们有一颗童心,但却偏偏有一些人想要毁了它,她们恨,可曾有几个人知道她们所承担的痛苦,童年别人在玩耍可她们却在训练,经过一次次的生死,她们回归;他们,从小和她们的婚约,他们没有彼此见过对方,自从她们失踪后,他们恨女人,恨为什么就这样走了,让自己没有颜面;他,本是将死之人,可是她救了他,他走的那一天,他说“我会去找你的,等我!”可是长大后彼此不认得彼此,就这样擦肩而过,她流泪了,她不敢相认,她怕11年后,她们回归,她们还记得她,她也起得她们,只是她们的仇人恐怕早在11年前忘记她们了!如今她们回归复仇!
  • 四季养生智慧

    四季养生智慧

    为了帮助人们更好地进行身体保健,作者编写了《四季养生智慧》一书。本书以四季为主线,紧扣春夏秋冬时序的更迭,温热凉寒四季气候的变化,比较系统地介绍各个季节的起居、饮食、运动、疾病、心理保健五个内容,全面指导人们养生。该书注重科学性、实用性,内容丰富、语言精练、通俗易懂,是人们的必备读物。
  • 霸道宋少,有点坏

    霸道宋少,有点坏

    宋词第一次见到唐诗是在江南的水镇上。众人都赞叹着眼前的旗袍做工多么精致,刺绣多么栩栩如生,而宋词脑中只有一个想法——撕碎碍眼的旗袍,这个女孩的每一寸肌肤都要属于自己。
  • 游戏侵略者

    游戏侵略者

    在战场上,我能猜测到敌人会做什么,可以提前准备,让敌人失败绝望。另外我还有三十六计,令敌人防不胜防。可是在主角林峰这里,我还第一计还没用出来就被弄死了。
  • 雁门集

    雁门集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 销售就要做得狠一点

    销售就要做得狠一点

    本书中这套方法为销售人员提供了一份穿行于新领地当中的路线图,并能收获优异的表现与心灵上的满足感。无论是销售业界的前辈级人物,还是初涉销售圈的新人,阅读这本书,都会体验到豁然开朗的感觉。
  • 李嘉诚经商50年

    李嘉诚经商50年

    李嘉诚连续6年荣膺世界华人首富,连续8年雄居港商首席,他是当代最成功、最杰出的商人之一,成为无数渴望成功的商人心目中的偶像。
  • 总裁大人很难追

    总裁大人很难追

    从小父母离异后,林可跟随妈妈再婚,是林氏集团居住在外的千金小姐。虽与林家生活在同一座城市,林……
  • 魔力大餐,你吃了么

    魔力大餐,你吃了么

    不想当首富的厨子不是好猎人。这是一个在现实中失去了味觉嗅觉的厨师进入游戏靠做菜富甲天下的故事。没有叱咤风云没有争霸天下,做做菜钓钓鱼泡泡妞,偶尔打打小怪兽,日子乐悠悠。