登陆注册
4705400000007

第7章

If, indeed, all men reasoned in the same manner on the same data, and always did what they thought it their duty to do, this mode of dispensing punishment might be extremely judicious. But as people who agree about premises often disagree about conclusions, and as no man in the world acts up to his own standard of right, there are two enormous gaps in the logic by which alone penalties for opinions can be defended. The doctrine of reprobation, in the judgment of many very able men, follows by syllogistic necessity from the doctrine of election. Others conceive that the Antinomian heresy directly follows from the doctrine of reprobation; and it is very generally thought that licentiousness and cruelty of the worst description are likely to be the fruits, as they often have been the fruits, of Antinomian opinions. This chain of reasoning, we think, is as perfect in all its parts as that which makes out a Papist to be necessarily a traitor. Yet it would be rather a strong measure to hang all the Calvinists, on the ground that if they were spared, they would infallibly commit all the atrocities of Matthias and Knipperdoling. For, reason the matter as we may, experience shows us that a man may believe in election without believing in reprobation, that he may believe in reprobation without being an Antinomian, and that he may be an Antinomian without being a bad citizen. Man, in short, is so inconsistent a creature that it is impossible to reason from his belief to his conduct, or from one part of his belief to another.

We do not believe that every Englishman who was reconciled to the Catholic Church would, as a necessary consequence, have thought himself justified in deposing or assassinating Elizabeth. It is not sufficient to say that the convert must have acknowledged the authority of the Pope, and that the Pope had issued a bull against the Queen. We know through what strange loopholes the human mind contrives to escape, when it wishes to avoid a disagreeable inference from an admitted proposition. We know how long the Jansenists contrived to believe the Pope infallible in matters of doctrine, and at the same time to believe doctrines which he pronounced to be heretical. Let it pass, however, that every Catholic in the kingdom thought that Elizabeth might he lawfully murdered. Still the old maxim, that what is the business of everybody is the business of nobody, is particularly likely to hold good in a case in which a cruel death is the almost inevitable consequence of making any attempt.

Of the ten thousand clergymen of the Church of England, there is scarcely one who would not say that a man who should leave his country and friends to preach the Gospel among savages, and who should, after labouring indefatigably without any hope of reward, terminate his life by martyrdom, would deserve the warmest admiration. Yet we can doubt whether ten of the ten thousand ever thought of going on such an expedition. Why should we suppose that conscientious motives, feeble as they are constantly found to be in a good cause, should be omnipotent for evil? Doubtless there was many a jolly Popish priest in the old manor-houses of the northern counties, who would have admitted, in theory, the deposing power of the Pope, but who would not have been ambitious to be stretched on the rack, even though it were to be used, according to the benevolent proviso of Lord Burleigh, "as charitably as such a thing can be," or to be hanged, drawn, and quartered, even though, by that rare indulgence which the Queen, of her special grace, certain knowledge, and mere motion, sometimes extended to very mitigated cases, he were allowed a fair time to choke before the hangman began to grabble in his entrails.

But the laws passed against the Puritans had not even the wretched excuse which we have been considering. In this case, the cruelty was equal, the danger, infinitely less. In fact, the danger was created solely by the cruelty. But it is superfluous to press the argument. By no artifice of ingenuity can the stigma of persecution, the worst blemish of the English Church, be effaced or patched over. Her doctrines, we well know, do not tend to intolerance. She admits the possibility of salvation out of her own pale. But this circumstance, in itself honourable to her, aggravates the sin and the shame of those who persecuted in her name. Dominic and De Montfort did not, at least, murder and torture for differences of opinion which they considered as trifling. It was to stop an infection which, as they believed, hurried to certain perdition every soul which it seized, that they employed their fire and steel. The measures of the English government with respect to the Papists and Puritans sprang from a widely different principle. If those who deny that the founders of the Church were guilty of religious persecution mean only that the founders of the Church were not influenced by any religious motive, we perfectly agree with them. Neither the penal code of Elizabeth, nor the more hateful system by which Charles the Second attempted to force Episcopacy on the Scotch, had an origin so noble. The cause is to be sought in some circumstances which attended the Reformation in England, circumstances of which the effects long continued to be felt, and may in some degree be traced even at the present day.

同类推荐
  • 嵩山太无先生气经

    嵩山太无先生气经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 法海遗珠

    法海遗珠

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 小学诗

    小学诗

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 鹿忠节公集

    鹿忠节公集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 文殊师利菩萨及诸仙所说吉凶时日善恶宿曜经

    文殊师利菩萨及诸仙所说吉凶时日善恶宿曜经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 深宫策·青栀传

    深宫策·青栀传

    她的眼看穿诡术阴谋,却不能彻底看清人心的变化;他的手掌握天下苍生,却只想可以握住寥寥的真心。从一个为帝王所防备的权臣之女,到名留青史的一代贤后,究竟有多远的距离?一入深宫前缘尽,半世浮沉掩栀青。梧桐摇叶金凤翥,史册煌煌载容音。
  • 难儞计湿嚩啰天说支轮经

    难儞计湿嚩啰天说支轮经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 回首月圆否

    回首月圆否

    每个人都有不同于其他人的人生经历,有的人把这些经历看作有意义的事,有些人却觉得很普通,苏兮兮却是一个矛盾的人,以前认为自己是个不同凡响的人总在考虑是上清华还是北大,现在却颓废地在技校呆着混吃等死,她原以为人生就只能如此了,一个男孩却进入了她的世界......
  • 网游之斩魔者

    网游之斩魔者

    有人说他是来自地狱的天使,可更有人说他是来自天堂的魔鬼;有人认为他是一无是处的庸人,可更有人认为他是无所不能的智囊;他看若无钱无势,却又仿佛家财万贯、权倾当世;他貌似柔弱无力,却又好像身怀绝技......
  • 爱在星光之外

    爱在星光之外

    白天,他是闪耀舞台上万人瞩目的超级巨星;夜晚,他是夺权之战中运筹帷幄的集团太子爷。是机缘巧合的偶然,也是逃脱不了的命运,邂逅了他生命中最独一无二的存在。——黎舞子。“牧辰风,你是故意的?你设了这个圈套,逼我就范!”“嗯。”“……”“你的心,我志在必得!”“好,我承认,你赢了。”【1v1双洁】【甜宠暖文,不含虐的成分】【高冷傲娇×古灵精怪】
  • 邪灵阴阳录

    邪灵阴阳录

    我出生后没几天就被邪灵附身了,一位姓唐的先生收服了邪灵救了我,还帮我打开了金蝉天眼。从此,便开启了我与唐先生识鬼神、辨阴阳、除邪灵的神奇之旅……
  • 还珠格格第三部之天上人间(下)

    还珠格格第三部之天上人间(下)

    尔康展死沙场?紫薇决定殉情相随?!小燕子和紫薇婚后,到底发生了一些什么事?大而化之、状况不断的小燕子,能够当五阿哥的贤内助吗?乾隆南巡,又发生了什么事?夏盈盈和乾隆的忘年之爱,掀起了怎样的轩然大波?才华洋溢的知画,怎会进了皇宫,成为五阿哥的新娘?紫薇和尔康有了东儿,是不是就拥有了人生最大的幸福?幸福是什么?谁能抓住幸福,让它长长久久?箫剑和晴儿的苦恋,要面对怎样的风暴?清缅战争,永琪、尔康、箫剑都上了战场,付出怎样惨痛的代价?
  • 我和大圣是兄弟

    我和大圣是兄弟

    王虎穿越了,而且悲催的成了五指山下的一只老虎。“我去,这是要做猴哥虎皮裙的节奏?”王虎表示不服。作为一只21世纪穿越来的新时代老虎,怎么着也要和猴哥拜把子,做兄弟啊!此时此刻齐天大圣孙悟空被压五行山马上就满五百年,再有十年,波澜壮阔,影响三界格局的西天取经之旅就要开始,看王虎如何在其中搅动三界风云,与猴哥一起再掀万妖狂潮。新书《我有无限气运》正在连载中……
  • 太上内丹守一真定经

    太上内丹守一真定经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 言行法则

    言行法则

    歌德说:“名言集和格言集是社会上最大的财宝——只要懂得在适当的场合把前者带进会话里,在适当的时间唤起对后者的记忆。”我们人类社会那些出类拔萃的名家巨人,在推动人类社会向前不断发展的同时,也给我们留下了宝贵的物质财富。他们通过自身的体验和观察研究,还给我们留下了许多有益的经验和感悟,他们将其付诸语言表达出来,被称之为名言或格言,其中蕴含并闪耀着智慧的光芒,成为世人宝贵的精神财富。