登陆注册
5166700000034

第34章

Let us go over them again, for fear of mistake, for equivocation here might be attended with dangerous results.Killing is a matter which requires to be well-timed, and to be backed with a good probable opinion.You have assured me, then, that by giving a proper turn to the intention, it is lawful, according to your fathers, for the preservation of one's honour, or even property, to accept a challenge to a duel, to give one sometimes, to kill in a private way a false accuser, and his witnesses along with him, and even the judge who has been bribed to favour them; and you have also told me that he who has got a blow may, without avenging himself, retaliate with the sword.But you have not told me, father, to what length he may go." "He can hardly mistake there," replied the father, "for he may go all the length of killing his man.This is satisfactorily proved by the learned Henriquez, and others of our fathers quoted by Escobar, as follows: 'It is perfectly right to kill a person who has given us a box on the ear, although he should run away, provided it is not done through hatred or revenge, and there is no danger of giving occasion thereby to murders of a gross kind and hurtful to society.And the reason is that it is as lawful to pursue the thief that has stolen our honour, as him that has run away with our property.For, although your honour cannot be said to be in the hands of your enemy in the same sense as your goods and chattels are in the hands of the thief, still it may be recovered in the same way- by showing proofs of greatness and authority, and thus acquiring the esteem of men.And, in point of fact, is it not certain that the man who has received a buffet on the ear is held to be under disgrace, until he has wiped off the insult with the blood of his enemy?'" I was so shocked on hearing this that it was with great difficulty I could contain myself;but, in my anxiety to hear the rest, I allowed him to proceed."Nay," he continued, "it is allowable to prevent a buffet, by killing him that meant to give it, if there be no other way to escape the insult.This opinion is quite common with our fathers.For example, Azor, one of the four-and-twenty elders, proposing the question, 'Is it lawful for a man of honour to kill another who threatens to give him a slap on the face, or strike him with a stick?' replies, 'Some say he may not; alleging that the life of our neighbour is more precious than our honour, and that it would be an act of cruelty to kill a man merely to avoid a blow.Others, however, think that it is allowable; and I certainly consider it probable, when there is no other way of warding off the insult; for, otherwise, the honour of the innocent would be constantly exposed to the malice of the insolent.'

The same opinion is given by our great Filiutius; by Father Hereau, in his Treatise on Homicide, by Hurtado de Mendoza, in his Disputations, by Becan, in his Summary; by our Fathers Flahaut and Lecourt, in those writings which the University, in their third petition, quoted at length, in order to bring them into disgrace (though in this they failed); and by Escobar.

In short, this opinion is so general that Lessius lays it down as a point which no casuist has contested; he quotes a great many that uphold, and none that deny it; and particularly Peter Navarre, who, speaking of affronts in general (and there is none more provoking than a box on the ear), declares that 'by the universal consent of the casuists, it is lawful to kill the calumniator, if there be no other way of averting the affront- ex sententia omnium, licet contumeliosum occidere, si aliter ea injuria arceri nequit.'

Do you wish any more authorities?" asked the monk.I declared I was much obliged to him; I had heard rather more than enough of them already.But, just to see how far this damnable doctrine would go, I said, "But, father, may not one be allowed to kill for something still less? Might not a person so direct his intention as lawfully to kill another for telling a lie, for example?" "He may," returned the monk; "and according to Father Baldelle, quoted by Escobar, 'you may lawfully take the life of another for saying, "You have told a lie"; if there is no other way of shutting his mouth.'

The same thing may be done in the case of slanders.Our Fathers Lessius and Hereau agree in the following sentiments: 'If you attempt to ruin my character by telling stories against me in the presence of men of honour, and I have no other way of preventing this than by putting you to death, may I be permitted to do so? According to the modern authors, I may, and that even though I have been really guilty of the crime which you divulge, provided it is a secret one, which you could not establish by legal evidence.

And I prove it thus: If you mean to rob me of my honour by giving me a box on the ear, I may prevent it by force of arms; and the same mode of defence is lawful when you would do me the same injury with the tongue.

Besides, we may lawfully obviate affronts and, therefore, slanders.In fine, honour is dearer than life; and as it is lawful to kill in defence of life, it must be so to kill in defence of honour.' There, you see, are arguments in due form; this is demonstration, sir- not mere discussion.

And, to conclude, this great man Lessius shows, in the same place, that it is lawful to kill even for a simple gesture, or a sign of contempt.

同类推荐
  • 野古集

    野古集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 艺苑雌黄

    艺苑雌黄

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 太上玄一真人说妙通转神入定经

    太上玄一真人说妙通转神入定经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 小江驿送陆侍御归湖

    小江驿送陆侍御归湖

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 灵台经

    灵台经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 竹马少爷太别扭

    竹马少爷太别扭

    顾亦临作为一个合格的竹马,在她尚懵懂时就已用他独有的方式守候着她。有人问:有人追求她你会怎么做,不留余力的在她面前抹黑情敌?顾亦临淡淡一睨:直接将她的烂桃花掐死在摇篮就好了,反正又不是第一次做这种事了!原以为会这样守候下去,燕京的一通电话却打破了这样的生活。
  • 柔石作品集(2)(中国现代文学名家作品集)

    柔石作品集(2)(中国现代文学名家作品集)

    为深沉严肃所管辖着的深夜的西子湖边,一切眠在星光的微笑底下;从冷风的战栗里熟睡去了。
  • 销售要懂心理学

    销售要懂心理学

    本书着重讲述销售员如何掌握客户的心理,进而通过对客户心理的把握,促成交易。书中案例丰富,点评精彩,具有很强的可读性,对销售工作会有很大的帮助,让你在销售道路上走得更顺畅,让你的销售业绩一路飘红!
  • 震撼中国的100位英雄模范人生

    震撼中国的100位英雄模范人生

    虽然生活的年代不同、事迹不同,但他们都为新中国的成立作出了贡献。他们坚定的理想信念、崇高的人生境界和无私奉献的精神永远值得我们学习! 他们是民族的英雄,时代的先锋,祖国的骄傲!他们的名字如璀璨的明星,照亮了后人前行的道路!他们的功绩会永远载入中华人民共和国的史册!他们永远是人们学习的榜样! 八女投江、夏明翰、张学良、杨虎城、白求恩、刘胡兰、狼牙山五壮士、董存瑞……他们的人生都是壮美的。他们的名字令人感动、催人奋进。本书属人物传记类图书。本书以“双百”人物为对象,再现了他们光荣模范的一生事迹,为弘扬爱国精神、社会主义文明提供榜样。
  • 国民歌神之金牌高手

    国民歌神之金牌高手

    第一:情窦初开。第二:年少心喜。第三:往后余生。—耀眼的灯光洒下来,万千束光芒笼罩万千人,舞台上的男人拿着话筒微笑着说,“今天,感谢你们的到来…而我,也想在今天宣布一件事,是关于我喜欢的人。”台下一片安静。她们知道她们的歌神已经有真正专属的金牌高手。这多么值得祝福啊。“你,是我喜欢了十三年的高手,是我懦弱不堪时的念想,是我生命中的阳光。”男人磁性的声音将整个演唱会包绕。“所以,你愿意嫁给我吗?”台下的人早已泣不成声…这城市太大,能保护我的,始终还是来了。“沐先生,有没有人告诉你,我不止这辈子都愿意做你的新娘?”…
  • Appendix to History of Friedrich II of Prussia

    Appendix to History of Friedrich II of Prussia

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 重生之孟洛

    重生之孟洛

    重生在古代,竟然是众所周知的傻郡主!年满三岁,不通人事,不懂人言,满脸痴呆…… 老爹虽是皇帝的儿子,无奈身子病弱,不过胜在对她疼爱有加。便宜娘不得爹心,待她也是不错;再加上有长公主的姑姑疼,三个亲亲表兄一个表姐对她甚好,这样的日子一直过下去那该有多好啊。可是,病弱弱的老爹死了,便宜娘竟然有奸夫,奸夫还是杀害老爹的凶手,还想着斩草除根,要她的命…… 怒起……杀了她的老爹,还要她的命,她偏不死,不仅不死,她还要帮老爹一点一点讨回那些原本属于老爹的东西……谁敢拦她复仇之路,她遇神杀神,遇佛弑佛!
  • 穿越之爱你成瘾

    穿越之爱你成瘾

    她,因父母离世,亲戚抛弃性格变得冷漠淡然。一场意外穿越到星月大陆成为将军府不受宠的四小姐!不受宠又如何,学武经商,偶尔虐虐小姐妹,玩得不亦乐乎!明明看起来温软和善,实则却掌控着天下第一的杀手组织。更是天下文人心中的神明!本以为可以低调安稳的过完一生。哪知皇帝陛下的一道圣旨竟从天而降!幸亏遇见的是他!那个宠她如命,爱她入骨的男子。既然爱上了,就要护他一世周全。可为何总有不长眼的人出现?杀了!斩了!却发现一切都是一个人的阴谋……本文一对一宠文,男强女强。随着文章的发展,会揭示一场巨大的阴谋,万事又因既有果,与世界有关、与命运有关、与人有关
  • 怂货宿主别黑化

    怂货宿主别黑化

    女扮男装,搞笑风,无厘头、不靠谱,为广大书民排忧解闷~就咱这智商,这颜值……喝!顶多做个怂怂的绿茶婊……努力向白莲花靠近!在此之前先自我催眠一下------我是男的我是男的我是男的!!!!!(本菌隔俩天更一章……想要多更就给我砸票票叭!叭!叭……)咳咳咳,正经介绍一下:本文是沙雕女主在系统滴鞭(诱)策(惑)下不断地变强变强变强!并不断地发现世界多么美好、林子大了什么鸟都有但是……憋丧啊啊啊!回娘胎重造不行但是咱可以返璞归真啊!
  • 四明它山水利备览

    四明它山水利备览

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。