登陆注册
5214200000031

第31章

But if our adversaries do not care how foully and disgracefully the Roman republic be stained by corrupt practices, so long only as it holds together and continues in being, and if they therefore pooh-pooh the testimony of Sallust to its "utterly wicked and profligate" condition, what will they make of Cicero's statement, that even in his time it had become entirely extinct, and that there remained extant no Roman republic at all? He introduces Scipio (the Scipio who had destroyed Carthage) discussing the republic, at a time when already there were presentiments of its speedy ruin by that corruption which Sallust describes.In fact, at the time when the discussion took place, one of the Gracchi, who, according to Sallust, was the first great instigator of seditions, had already been put to death.His death, indeed, is mentioned in the same book.Now Scipio, at the end of the second book, says: "As among the different sounds which proceed from lyres, flutes, and the human voice, there must be maintained a certain harmony which a cultivated ear cannot endure to hear disturbed or jarring, but which may be elicited in full and absolute concord by the modulation even of voices very unlike one another; so, where reason is allowed to modulate the diverse elements of the state, there is obtained a perfect concord from the upper, lower, and middle classes as from various sounds; and what musicians call harmony in singing, is concord in matters of state, which is the strictest bond and best security of any republic, and which by no ingenuity can be retained where justice has become extinct." Then, when he had expatiated somewhat more fully, and had more copiously illustrated the benefits of its presence and the ruinous effects of its absence upon a state, Pilus, one of the company present at the discussion, struck in and demanded that the question should be more thoroughly sifted, and that the subject of justice should be freely discussed for the sake of ascertaining what truth there was in the maxim which was then becoming daily more current, that "the republic cannot be governed without injustice." Scipio expressed his willingness to have this maxim discussed and sifted, and gave it as his opinion that it was baseless, and that no progress could be made in discussing the republic unless it was established, not only that this maxim, that "the republic cannot be governed without injustice," was false, but also that the truth is, that it cannot be governed without the most absolute justice.

And the discussion of this question, being deferred till the next day, is carried on in the third book with great animation.For Pilus himself undertook to defend the position that the republic cannot be governed.without injustice, at the same time being at special pains to clear himself of any real participation in that opinion.

He advocated with great keenness the cause of injustice against justice, and endeavored by plausible reasons and examples to demonstrate that the former is beneficial, the latter useless, to the republic.Then, at the request of the company, Laelius attempted to defend justice, and strained every nerve to prove that nothing is so hurtful to a state as injustice; and that without justice a republic can neither be governed, nor even continue to exist.

When this question has been handled to the satisfaction of the company, Scipio reverts to the original thread of discourse, and repeats with commendation his own brief definition of a republic, that it is the weal of the people."The people" he defines as being not every assemblage or mob, but an assemblage associated by a common acknowledgment of law, and by a community of interests.Then he shows the use of definition in debate; and from these definitions of his own he gathers that a republic, or "weal of the people," then exists only when it is well and justly governed, whether by a monarch, or an aristocracy, or by the whole people.But when the monarch is unjust, or, as the Greeks say, a tyrant; or the aristocrats are unjust, and form a faction;or the people themselves are unjust, and become, as Scipio for want of a better name calls them, themselves the tyrant, then the republic is not only blemished (as had been proved the day before), but by legitimate deduction from those definitions, it altogether ceases to be.For it could not be the people's weal when a tyrant factiously lorded it over the state; neither would the people be any longer a people if it were unjust, since it would no longer answer the definition of a people--" an assemblage associated by a common acknowledgment of law, and by a community of interests."When, therefore, the Roman republic was such as Sallust described it, it was not "utterly wicked and profligate," as he says, but had altogether ceased to exist, if we are to admit the reasoning of that debate maintained on the subject of the republic by its best representatives.Tully himself, too, speaking not in the person of Scipio or any one else, but uttering his own sentiments, uses the following language in the beginning of the fifth book, after quoting a line from the poet Ennius, in which he said, "Rome's severe morality and her citizens are her safeguard." "This verse," says Cicero, "seems to me to have all the sententious truthfulness of an oracle.For neither would the citizens have availed without the morality of the community, nor would the morality of the commons without outstanding men have availed either to establish or so long to maintain in vigor so grand a republic with so wide and just an empire.Accordingly, before our day, the hereditary usages formed our foremost men, and they on their part retained the usages and institutions of their fathers.

同类推荐
  • 内经博议

    内经博议

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 郁离子

    郁离子

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 小五虎演义

    小五虎演义

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 子午流注说难

    子午流注说难

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 投瓮随笔

    投瓮随笔

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 明伦汇编家范典姑侄部

    明伦汇编家范典姑侄部

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 在霍格沃茨淡定地喝红茶

    在霍格沃茨淡定地喝红茶

    这是一个画风经常出问题的霍格沃茨。这是一个奇洛被学生们组团刷了、蛇怪上了庆功宴的餐桌、小天狼星·布莱克差点变狗肉煲、伏地魔不知不觉中一再被坑、教授们坐在一起包饺子就是正义的故事。
  • 婚然心动:总裁老公早上好

    婚然心动:总裁老公早上好

    一年前,她与他契约成婚。宴会镁光灯下,她的礼服嘶啦一声,破碎。银灰色的西装外套从天而降。“以后,我不许你穿给别人看!”她惊惶,对上他深邃的鹰眸,隐隐火光,倏忽跳动。晚宴的醉酒,他厉声质问:“在哪里?”她甚是不情愿:“金醉酒店。”黑色宾利忽的飘移而至。车厢里的阴影,她感觉出他隐隐的怒气,高贵清冷的气场,令人一颤。他鹰眸微眯:“没有什么要告诉我的?嗯?”她弯唇一笑,光华如珠:“那个人不重要。”他瞳孔紧缩:“你,只能是我的!”--情节虚构,请勿模仿
  • The Jimmyjohn Boss and Other Stories

    The Jimmyjohn Boss and Other Stories

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    Enquiry Concerning Political Justice

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 霸情总裁女王妻

    霸情总裁女王妻

    最后,他居然要她拿掉孩子,他跟她说“没有人有资格生下我的孩子,你更加不配”!她的世界骤然崩塌!五年后,“据说远方的白天鹅比不上眼前的红烧肉,但是我宁愿远离你,做那美美的天鹅,也不要做被你珍视的油腻腻的肥肉!”女王如是说。宝宝篇:“我可是小妈咪一生中最爱的男人的诶,她怎么可能不管我,再说我怎么样跟你有什么关系,你又凭什么管我?”小鬼酷酷的对男人挑眉。“就凭我是你爹地!”男人很是狂傲自信。“爹地?”小鬼突然间恶意的笑了“我爹地可不只你一个,而你只不过是排在最末的大烂人爹地罢了!”美人爹地篇:某小鬼黑亮的眼眸中闪动着狡黠的光芒,突然他一把抱住苏澈修长匀称的腿,仰着小脸笑得极其乖巧“美人爹地!”苏澈蹲下身子,薄唇挽起一个优雅迷离的弧度,他伸出干净而好看的手指点了点小鬼的鼻头“你这么叫我我是很高兴,不过一旦叫出口就不能反悔了哦!”“本少爷一言,那个N辆车都拉不回哦!”小鬼皱了皱眉终究憋出这样一句有些怪异的话。此文虐心也虐身!利于身体健康,哇咔咔!先小虐,后大虐!--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------勤劳的罗争取一天一更,不忙的时候会二更,亲们多收藏多给票票吧!罗的碎碎念:罗的群建立了哦!52938629欢迎亲们都过来定居!(敲门砖,咱的任意一部作品的名字!)亲们放心看文,罗绝对不会弃坑,这是对自己负责更对亲们负责,所以亲们多多撒票,伸出你们可爱的小爪子点击放入书架,收藏一下哦!大么么!-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------隆重推荐某罗总裁新坑《强宠贱妻》链接:友情推荐!《祸世狂颜》杜月影
  • 蜜糖娇妻有点甜

    蜜糖娇妻有点甜

    苏甜发现男神喜欢的是男人后出车祸重生了。重回一世,她决定离他越远越好。可是,这个人怎么随处可见?苏甜慌了,发帖求助:喜欢男人的男神开始追我了,我该怎么办?在线等挺急的。后来结了婚有了娃,她才知道,世间最美好的事情就是嫁给爱情。
  • 凤唳九天

    凤唳九天

    她看似痴傻,却遇神杀神,遇佛弑佛,扮猪吃老虎!除了狠毒嫡母,宰了蛇蝎嫡姐,吓傻了无情父亲,气死了腹黑皇帝。终于可以逍遥离开,后面却跟了一堆痴痴追随的人,这么多尾巴,怎么甩掉啊!--情节虚构,请勿模仿
  • 最上乘论

    最上乘论

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 喜欢你我不曾后悔

    喜欢你我不曾后悔

    高中时期,懵懂的我们,还不懂什么是爱,只知道我心中有你,我只喜欢你!