登陆注册
5225600000010

第10章 SOME QUESTIONS RELATING TO FRIENDSHIP.(8)

That may be assumed to be certain.

And does not this seem to put us in the right way? Just remark, that the body which is in health requires neither medical nor any other aid, but is well enough; and the healthy man has no love of the physician, because he is in health.

He has none.

But the sick loves him, because he is sick?

Certainly.

And sickness is an evil, and the art of medicine a good and useful thing?

Yes.

But the human body, regarded as a body, is neither good nor evil?

True.

And the body is compelled by reason of disease to court and make friends of the art of medicine?

Yes.

Then that which is neither good nor evil becomes the friend of good, by reason of the presence of evil?

So we may infer.

And clearly this must have happened before that which was neither good nor evil had become altogether corrupted with the element of evil--if itself had become evil it would not still desire and love the good; for, as we were saying, the evil cannot be the friend of the good.

Impossible.

Further, I must observe that some substances are assimilated when others are present with them; and there are some which are not assimilated: take, for example, the case of an ointment or colour which is put on another substance.

Very good.

In such a case, is the substance which is anointed the same as the colour or ointment?

What do you mean? he said.

This is what I mean: Suppose that I were to cover your auburn locks with white lead, would they be really white, or would they only appear to be white?

They would only appear to be white, he replied.

And yet whiteness would be present in them?

True.

But that would not make them at all the more white, notwithstanding the presence of white in them--they would not be white any more than black?

No.

But when old age infuses whiteness into them, then they become assimilated, and are white by the presence of white.

Certainly.

Now I want to know whether in all cases a substance is assimilated by the presence of another substance; or must the presence be after a peculiar sort?

The latter, he said.

Then that which is neither good nor evil may be in the presence of evil, but not as yet evil, and that has happened before now?

Yes.

And when anything is in the presence of evil, not being as yet evil, the presence of good arouses the desire of good in that thing; but the presence of evil, which makes a thing evil, takes away the desire and friendship of the good; for that which was once both good and evil has now become evil only, and the good was supposed to have no friendship with the evil?

None.

And therefore we say that those who are already wise, whether Gods or men, are no longer lovers of wisdom; nor can they be lovers of wisdom who are ignorant to the extent of being evil, for no evil or ignorant person is a lover of wisdom. There remain those who have the misfortune to be ignorant, but are not yet hardened in their ignorance, or void of understanding, and do not as yet fancy that they know what they do not know: and therefore those who are the lovers of wisdom are as yet neither good nor bad. But the bad do not love wisdom any more than the good; for, as we have already seen, neither is unlike the friend of unlike, nor like of like. You remember that?

Yes, they both said.

And so, Lysis and Menexenus, we have discovered the nature of friendship-- there can be no doubt of it: Friendship is the love which by reason of the presence of evil the neither good nor evil has of the good, either in the soul, or in the body, or anywhere.

They both agreed and entirely assented, and for a moment I rejoiced and was satisfied like a huntsman just holding fast his prey. But then a most unaccountable suspicion came across me, and I felt that the conclusion was untrue. I was pained, and said, Alas! Lysis and Menexenus, I am afraid that we have been grasping at a shadow only.

Why do you say so? said Menexenus.

I am afraid, I said, that the argument about friendship is false: arguments, like men, are often pretenders.

How do you mean? he asked.

Well, I said; look at the matter in this way: a friend is the friend of some one; is he not?

Certainly he is.

And has he a motive and object in being a friend, or has he no motive and object?

He has a motive and object.

And is the object which makes him a friend, dear to him, or neither dear nor hateful to him?

I do not quite follow you, he said.

I do not wonder at that, I said. But perhaps, if I put the matter in another way, you will be able to follow me, and my own meaning will be clearer to myself. The sick man, as I was just now saying, is the friend of the physician--is he not?

Yes.

And he is the friend of the physician because of disease, and for the sake of health?

Yes.

And disease is an evil?

Certainly.

And what of health? I said. Is that good or evil, or neither?

Good, he replied.

And we were saying, I believe, that the body being neither good nor evil, because of disease, that is to say because of evil, is the friend of medicine, and medicine is a good: and medicine has entered into this friendship for the sake of health, and health is a good.

True.

And is health a friend, or not a friend?

A friend.

And disease is an enemy?

Yes.

Then that which is neither good nor evil is the friend of the good because of the evil and hateful, and for the sake of the good and the friend?

Clearly.

Then the friend is a friend for the sake of the friend, and because of the enemy?

That is to be inferred.

Then at this point, my boys, let us take heed, and be on our guard against deceptions. I will not again repeat that the friend is the friend of the friend, and the like of the like, which has been declared by us to be an impossibility; but, in order that this new statement may not delude us, let us attentively examine another point, which I will proceed to explain:

Medicine, as we were saying, is a friend, or dear to us for the sake of health?

Yes.

And health is also dear?

Certainly.

And if dear, then dear for the sake of something?

Yes.

And surely this object must also be dear, as is implied in our previous admissions?

Yes.

And that something dear involves something else dear?

Yes.

同类推荐
  • The Rhythm of Life

    The Rhythm of Life

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 伤寒补例

    伤寒补例

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 诗品

    诗品

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 传授经戒仪注诀

    传授经戒仪注诀

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 修行本起经

    修行本起经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 我要做贤臣

    我要做贤臣

    “国主,臣带着一整套风云系统、十八年的专业知识而来,为的是造福天下黎民百姓。”“爱卿,想要当一个位高权重的大臣,可还得有些别的品质。”“国主,臣忠心不二、心系百姓、廉洁奉公,不拿百姓一根针、一根线,但凡是为人臣子的要有的高洁之德,臣都奉为毕生追求——”“除此之外呢?”“请国主示下。”“爱卿,为人臣子该讨喜些的。”“还请国主明示。”“且只说两句:可萌可贱可风骚、可攻可受会撒娇……”……“国主,臣想当贤臣——”
  • 最强泷影

    最强泷影

    新书《关东冠军的精灵直播间》重生在火影世界,五大忍村有六个不是常识吗?!五影会谈?对不起,现在是六影会谈!木叶最大?泷隐才是爸爸!水无月冰淇淋,鬼灯勘探队,伊布里无烟烧烤...漩涡能源中心,血之池幻术影院,蜘蛛黏金电缆....辉夜牌壮骨粉你值得拥有!飞雷神准备,雷神快递,使命必达!无限月读实现全球联网!战舰开启忍界大航海时代,星舰探索星辰大海!总之,这是一个基建狂魔的影带着村子发家致富的种田故事~书友群:819330723
  • 逃出仙界

    逃出仙界

    这是一个愈发残酷的仙界,资源日趋紧张,你争我夺,尔虞我诈,阴谋诡计甚嚣尘上。在这里,炼丹、制器、画符、布阵的都被称为杂修,地位低下,死气沉沉。丁广,以凡人之躯“被穿越”到此,历经磨难,只能以凡人资质“被杂修”。被搅进多方势力争斗的他,该如何以凡人心智破局?又如何以凡人手段回家?
  • 无限回档

    无限回档

    有的人活着,他转眼就死了。而有的人死了,他却能回档。本书又名《论主角在末世的各种扑街姿势》。
  • 百合开在月亮湖里

    百合开在月亮湖里

    在人类生活中,爱的出现,或爱的信仰的出现,带来的不一定都是绚丽的色彩和悦耳的声音。在很多时候,爱情会不可避免地成为忧伤、孤单、仇恨,甚至毁灭的前夜。
  • 贵族校园之我的王牌会长

    贵族校园之我的王牌会长

    冷冀宇,贵族学校学生会会长,学校里的风云人物,却冷漠高傲。韩一诺,拥有绝世身手的女生,被众多学校退学,性格泼辣。篮球场上初遇,互留好感;校门口再遇,他主动帮忙。因收养孤儿,他和她被迫同居!从冤家到恋人,最后双双深陷感情之中!
  • 优美的校园散文

    优美的校园散文

    散文是美的,它能给人以美的享受,然而什么样的散文才是最美的散文呢?秦牧曾说:“精粹警辟的、谈笑风生的、亲切感人的、玲珑剔透的,使你读时入了神、读后印象久久不会消失的好散文,还是不多。”他还说:“一篇好的散文,应该通过各种各样的内容给人以思想的启发、美的感受、情操的陶冶。”品读精美的散文,宛如清风般涤荡沐浴;让散文的清扬与美丽永远地伴随你。
  • 太虚圣祖

    太虚圣祖

    【火爆玄幻】大道仙宗太上宗主,陨落重生回少年时代。这一世,他还是皇城中一个纨绔少爷,才刚刚做了坏事,贪污了国库……看他如何重补前世遗憾,以惊天之姿崛起!
  • 西方的没落

    西方的没落

    《西方的没落》是一部深刻、丰富的书,它不仅包含着对历史深刻的洞见,而且在社会学、人类学和政治思想上也做出了非常卓越的贡献,在现代西方产生了复杂、广泛的影响。
  • 毒姬傲世:别惹五小姐

    毒姬傲世:别惹五小姐

    她本是公爵贵女,却因出生卑微,又是天生不能习武的废人,背负着“妖女”的恶名,受父亲冷落,庶母陷害,姐妹欺凌,最终被赶出国公府,在普天同庆的日子里惨死在雪地里,惨遭抛尸荒野。她是现代顶尖特工,精明睿智,才华绝世,在执行任务时发现对手的首领就是自己最信任的上司,在对决中和敌人双双横死!当现代顶级特工穿越到柔弱孤女的身上,怯弱纯良的眼神不再!善良无助被刚毅狠绝代替,天真无邪转化为城府深沉!命运开始逆向,大陆开始掀起波澜。请看一代绝世女枭雄,如何在异时空谱写属于自己的史诗!