登陆注册
5237300000189

第189章 Lectures XVI and XVII(18)

They open out the possibility of other orders of truth, in which, so far as anything in us vitally responds to them, we may freely continue to have faith.

I will take up these points one by one.

1.

As a matter of psychological fact, mystical states of a well-pronounced and emphatic sort ARE usually authoritative over those who have them.[281] They have been "there," and know. It is vain for rationalism to grumble about this. If the mystical truth that comes to a man proves to be a force that he can live by, what mandate have we of the majority to order him to live in another way? We can throw him into a prison or a madhouse, but we cannot change his mind--we commonly attach it only the more stubbornly to its beliefs.[282] It mocks our utmost efforts, as a matter of fact, and in point of logic it absolutely escapes our jurisdiction. Our own more "rational" beliefs are based on evidence exactly similar in nature to that which mystics quote for theirs. Our senses, namely, have assured us of certain states of fact; but mystical experiences are as direct perceptions of fact for those who have them as any sensations ever were for us. The records show that even though the five senses be in abeyance in them, they are absolutely sensational in their epistemological quality, if I may be pardoned the barbarous expression--that is, they are face to face presentations of what seems immediately to exist. [281] I abstract from weaker states, and from those cases of which the books are full, where the director (but usually not the subject) remains in doubt whether the experience may not have proceeded from the demon.

[282] Example: Mr. John Nelson writes of his imprisonment for preaching Methodism: "My soul was as a watered garden, and I could sing praises to God all day long; for he turned my captivity into joy, and gave me to rest as well on the boards, as if I had been on a bed of down. Now could I say, 'God's service is perfect freedom,' and I was carried out much in prayer that my enemies might drink of the same river of peace which my God gave so largely to me." Journal, London, no date, p. 172.

The mystic is, in short, INVULNERABLE, and must be left, whether we relish it or not, in undisturbed enjoyment of his creed.

Faith, says Tolstoy, is that by which men live. And faith-state and mystic state are practically convertible terms.

2.

But I now proceed to add that mystics have no right to claim that we ought to accept the deliverance of their peculiar experiences, if we are ourselves outsiders and feel no private call thereto.

The utmost they can ever ask of us in this life is to admit that they establish a presumption. They form a consensus and have an unequivocal outcome; and it would be odd, mystics might say, if such a unanimous type of experience should prove to be altogether wrong. At bottom, however, this would only be an appeal to numbers, like the appeal of rationalism the other way; and the appeal to numbers has no logical force. If we acknowledge it, it is for "suggestive," not for logical reasons: we follow the majority because to do so suits our life.

But even this presumption from the unanimity of mystics is far from being strong. In characterizing mystic states an pantheistic, optimistic, etc., I am afraid I over-simplified the truth. I did so for expository reasons, and to keep the closer to the classic mystical tradition. The classic religious mysticism, it now must be confessed, is only a "privileged case."

It is an EXTRACT, kept true to type by the selection of the fittest specimens and their preservation in "schools." It is carved out from a much larger mass; and if we take the larger mass as seriously as religious mysticism has historically taken itself, we find that the supposed unanimity largely disappears.

To begin with, even religious mysticism itself, the kind that accumulates traditions and makes schools, is much less unanimous than I have allowed. It has been both ascetic and antinomianly self-indulgent within the Christian church.[283] It is dualistic in Sankhya, and monistic in Vedanta philosophy. I called it pantheistic; but the great Spanish mystics are anything but pantheists. They are with few exceptions non-metaphysical minds, for whom "the category of personality" is absolute. The "union" of man with God is for them much more like an occasional miracle than like an original identity.[284] How different again, apart from the happiness common to all, is the mysticism of Walt Whitman, Edward Carpenter, Richard Jefferies, and other naturalistic pantheists, from the more distinctively Christian sort.[285] The fact is that the mystical feeling of enlargement, union, and emancipation has no specific intellectual content whatever of its own. It is capable of forming matrimonial alliances with material furnished by the most diverse philosophies and theologies, provided only they can find a place in their framework for its peculiar emotional mood. We have no right, therefore, to invoke its prestige as distinctively in favor of any special belief, such as that in absolute idealism, or in the absolute monistic identity, or in the absolute goodness, of the world. It is only relatively in favor of all these things--it passes out of common human consciousness in the direction in which they lie.

[283] Ruysbroeck, in the work which Maeterlinck has translated, has a chapter against the antinomianism of disciples. H.

Delacroix's book (Essai sur le mysticisme speculatif en Allemagne au XIVme Siecle, Paris, 1900) is full of antinomian material. compare also A. Jundt: Les Amis de Dieu au XIV Siecle, These de Strasbourg, 1879.

[284] Compare Paul Rousselot: Les Mystiques Espagnols, Paris, 1869, ch. xii.

[285] see Carpenter's Towards Democracy, especially the latter parts, and Jefferies's wonderful and splendid mystic rhapsody, The Story of my Heart.

同类推荐
  • 外科十三方考

    外科十三方考

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 答叶溥求论古文书

    答叶溥求论古文书

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 重楼玉钥

    重楼玉钥

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 开天传信记

    开天传信记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 法集要颂经

    法集要颂经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 超有效的滋养面膜

    超有效的滋养面膜

    是不是从来没做过面膜的你,知道很多美美的MM的秘密是天天敷面膜,但自己却从来没动手做过,连从超市里买回来的现成的面膜都没试过呢?那从你拥有这本书的那刻开始,你会看到一个全新的自己,看到一个最勤快的自己。去了解自己的肌肤,知道怎么应对有可能出现的肌肤问题,清洁、滋养你的肌肤,具体的DIY面膜,非常全面。对自己更好一点,让自己更美一些。
  • 戒子孙

    戒子孙

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 中国太阳

    中国太阳

    本书获得了2002年中国科幻银河奖一等奖。谁也不知道中国太阳将飞多远,水娃他们将看到什么样的神奇世界,也许有一天他们对地球发出一声呼唤,要上千年才能得到回音。但水娃始终会牢记母亲行星上的一个叫中国的国度,牢记那个国度西部一片干旱土地上的一个小村庄,牢记村前的那条小路,他就是从那里启程的。
  • 万界跑男

    万界跑男

    司奕夜,一个从地球穿越的倒霉孩子,不幸出现在了第十位面的位面之主沐浴的地方。司奕夜在即将被位面之主抹杀的前一秒,得到了意外援助,得以逃出第十位面,跑到了跟第十位面相邻的第十一位面。不过故事并没有就这样结束,第十位面的位面之主派出了大批精英前往第十一位面追杀司奕夜。万界跑男,就此诞生!
  • 十善业道:洗心禅2

    十善业道:洗心禅2

    佛教中讲究十善业道,而何为十善业道,简单说来即永离杀生、偷盗、邪行、妄语、两舌、恶口、绮语、贪欲、瞋恚、邪见。此观念对于我们平凡人修身养性,把握幸福人生有何启示?本书中,贤宗法师心怀慈悲,娓娓道来,用自身所悟为读者宽解心中疑惑,助其获得快乐人生。
  • 山舍南溪小桃花

    山舍南溪小桃花

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 龙王戒

    龙王戒

    偶然得到一枚可以任意穿越小说世界的龙王戒指,不爽高中生贾里玉就此开启得意人生。纵马水浒三国,谈笑用兵,结交英雄好汉;梦游红楼警幻,增删判词,金陵十二钗命运改变。五百年前,菩提树下,七十二变。五百年后,大圣归来,天外飞仙。
  • 山城袍哥

    山城袍哥

    于是,各种猜测纷至:一种是,赖被两个部下合谋杀害,理由是:赖身上除现金外尚有一支派克金笔、一块劳力士金表;吉普后备厢还放有刚查获未及上缴的五公斤海洛因,这玩意在黑市上可是价格不菲!另一种猜测是:赖奎龙命犯桃花,死于情杀。之所以找不到尸体,可能早已被大卸八块,抛尸荒山,成了野狗腹中美食。然而,蒋委员长却不那么看,他认定:此事必与地方军阀和袍哥有关!
  • 金刚三昧本性清净不坏不灭经

    金刚三昧本性清净不坏不灭经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 海上大洗劫

    海上大洗劫

    1934年6月,一个酷热难耐的中午。天津卫太沽码头人山人海,鼓乐喧天,好不热闹。停泊在码头的一艘崭新的豪华游轮昂首挺立,船上张灯结彩,旗幡飘飘,格外引人注目。这艘英商所属的太沽公司的新型豪华客轮,取了个中国名字———“顺天”号。一连多日,“顺天” 号在太沽码头停靠,供游人参观,风头出尽。说是供游人参观,实际上是一种炫耀。这艘堪称世界一流的“顺天”客轮,可以与闻名世界的泰坦尼克号相媲美。“顺天”轮吨位大,设施先进。特等舱、一等舱、二等舱华丽无比;电影厅、舞厅、中西餐厅金碧辉煌。“顺天”轮简直就是一座海上流动宫殿。