登陆注册
5270400000023

第23章

Moreover, it is well to alter a term into one more familiar, e.g. to substitute 'clear' for 'exact' in describing a conception, and 'being fussy' for 'being busy': for when the expression is made more familiar, the thesis becomes easier to attack. This commonplace rule also is available for both purposes alike, both for establishing and for overthrowing a view.

In order to show that contrary attributes belong to the same thing, look at its genus; e.g. if we want to show that rightness and wrongness are possible in regard to perception, and to perceive is to judge, while it is possible to judge rightly or wrongly, then in regard to perception as well rightness and wrongness must be possible.

In the present instance the proof proceeds from the genus and relates to the species: for 'to judge' is the genus of 'to -perceive'; for the man who perceives judges in a certain way. But per contra it may proceed from the species to the genus: for all the attributes that belong to the species belong to the genus as well; e.g. if there is a bad and a good knowledge there is also a bad and a good disposition: for 'disposition' is the genus of knowledge. Now the former commonplace argument is fallacious for purposes of establishing a view, while the second is true. For there is no necessity that all the attributes that belong to the genus should belong also to the species; for 'animal' is flying and quadruped, but not so 'man'. All the attributes, on the other hand, that belong to the species must of necessity belong also to the genus; for if 'man' is good, then animal also is good. On the other hand, for purposes of overthrowing a view, the former argument is true while the latter is fallacious; for all the attributes which do not belong to the genus do not belong to the species either; whereas all those that are wanting to the species are not of necessity wanting to the genus.

Since those things of which the genus is predicated must also of necessity have one of its species predicated of them, and since those things that are possessed of the genus in question, or are described by terms derived from that genus, must also of necessity be possessed of one of its species or be described by terms derived from one of its species (e.g. if to anything the term 'scientific knowledge' be applied, then also there will be applied to it the term 'grammatical' or 'musical' knowledge, or knowledge of one of the other sciences; and if any one possesses scientific knowledge or is described by a term derived from 'science', then he will also possess grammatical or musical knowledge or knowledge of one of the other sciences, or will be described by a term derived from one of them, e.g. as a 'grammarian' or a 'musician')-therefore if any expression be asserted that is in any way derived from the genus (e.g. that the soul is in motion), look and see whether it be possible for the soul to be moved with any of the species of motion; whether (e.g.) it can grow or be destroyed or come to be, and so forth with all the other species of motion. For if it be not moved in any of these ways, clearly it does not move at all. This commonplace rule is common for both purposes, both for overthrowing and for establishing a view: for if the soul moves with one of the species of motion, clearly it does move; while if it does not move with any of the species of motion, clearly it does not move.

If you are not well equipped with an argument against the assertion, look among the definitions, real or apparent, of the thing before you, and if one is not enough, draw upon several. For it will be easier to attack people when committed to a definition: for an attack is always more easily made on definitions.

Moreover, look and see in regard to the thing in question, what it is whose reality conditions the reality of the thing in question, or what it is whose reality necessarily follows if the thing in question be real: if you wish to establish a view inquire what there is on whose reality the reality of the thing in question will follow (for if the former be shown to be real, then the thing in question will also have been shown to be real); while if you want to overthrow a view, ask what it is that is real if the thing in question be real, for if we show that what follows from the thing in question is unreal, we shall have demolished the thing in question.

Moreover, look at the time involved, to see if there be any discrepancy anywhere: e.g. suppose a man to have stated that what is being nourished of necessity grows: for animals are always of necessity being nourished, but they do not always grow. Likewise, also, if he has said that knowing is remembering: for the one is concerned with past time, whereas the other has to do also with the present and the future. For we are said to know things present and future (e.g. that there will be an eclipse), whereas it is impossible to remember anything save what is in the past.

同类推荐
  • 洞真太微金虎真符

    洞真太微金虎真符

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • The Historical Nights' Entertainment

    The Historical Nights' Entertainment

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 续子不语

    续子不语

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 天仙道戒忌须知

    天仙道戒忌须知

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 撼龙经

    撼龙经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 赢在管理:别把企业做垮

    赢在管理:别把企业做垮

    本书撷取了世界500强企业在经营过程中的一些有典型意义的例子并加以分析,按照由易到难、由简单到复杂的顺序,将企业经营管理过程中容易出现的错误展现给读者,从一个个鲜活的具体案例给企业的管理者们以警示,引出认识问题和解决问题的正确方法,在授人以鱼的基础上授人以渔。
  • 冠心病实用自我疗法(实用自我疗法系列)

    冠心病实用自我疗法(实用自我疗法系列)

    书中介绍了全面认识冠心病、冠心病患者科学用药指南、冠心病患者的常用药物、冠心病及其并发症的推荐药物、冠心病患者的饮食常识、冠心病科学治疗指南、冠心病的穴位按摩疗法、冠心病的拔罐疗法、冠心病的汤药疗法、冠心病的艾灸疗法、冠心病的饮食疗法等方面等内容,有助于人们提高预防与保健意识,减少冠心病的发生和复发,提高生活质量。本书是冠心病调养与防治的大众科普读物,内容翔实,通俗易懂,科学实用,指导性强。
  • 无限重生:老公,我又挂了

    无限重生:老公,我又挂了

    (搞笑+脑洞+反套路文)外星妖艳贱货扑了地星大总裁,从此过上没羞没臊的日子?唐夕夕告诉你,童话很美好,现实很骨感。第一次她是尾随痴汉,跟踪到一半,挂了!于是,她重生再来,步步为营,小心算计,刚表白完,她又挂了!于于是,她继续重生,可是过马路被车撞死是什么鬼?唐夕夕:“骁哥,咱能管好这张乌鸦嘴吗?”叶骁:“……”没遇上叶骁之前,唐夕夕是高管局女流氓,天不怕地不怕。遇到叶骁之后,她是地星精分影后,每天的目标就是睡叶骁。可是真正睡到之后,双腿发软,她又想求饶。唐夕夕:“骁哥,休战可以吗?”叶骁清冷的眸子微微一眯:“大战三百回合,还不够!”唐夕夕:“!!!!”
  • 长安风

    长安风

    开元末,天宝初。唐皇隆基老而未老,几分雄心犹在;宰相林甫口蜜腹剑,渐已权倾朝野;三姐玉瑶年才双十,人比花娇媚;胡儿禄山大奸若忠,已然河北蛰伏;权奸杨钊一事无成,仍在剑南厮混;王妃玉环倾国倾城,犹是李家儿媳。金鳞岂是池中物,一遇风云便化龙。看寿王李瑁如何护娇妻,谋江山!
  • 别以为你会带团队

    别以为你会带团队

    企业团队管理的最新力作,遴选大量的一手案例,详实展现了在商业上已经取得初步成功的人物以及企业。通过这些企业实际积累起来的经验与教训,必定能对于后来者产生非常有益的帮助。公司中高层管理者精选必读!
  • 王妃爱吃肉

    王妃爱吃肉

    金牌吃货简宁一朝穿越,对上古灵精怪九王爷凤九歌。她虽祸水天下,他任流言四起。“小宁子,还不过来替本王尝尝这一桌子菜有没有毒?”“说人话!”“小宁宁,饿了吧,多吃点,胖点,好生养。”“……”“小宁子,你这衣服怎么又瘦了啊?”“说人话!”“小宁宁,你最近吃的好像很少啊?挑剔了不少呢,是不是有了?!”“……”
  • 莹本惊华

    莹本惊华

    九天之上有着一位国色天香的美人,莹九九。生性活泼祸事惹尽。同天地共主渊华帝君有着说不清道不明的关系,亦是需追潮八百年前的一段孽缘。渊华帝君:“莹九九,你再跑一些试试!“莹九上神:”我没有跑,我用走的。“莹九九一直认为自己是一位千杯不醉的神,结果竟着了渊华帝君的道,失了身。莹九上神:“我好像很久以前就见过你。”渊华帝君:“八百年前,你凡尘夫君正是本帝。”莹九九僵了僵,微怒:“你竟骗我这么久,离婚,本上神要和你离婚。”渊华理了理银衣:“孩子怎么办?”
  • 秦汉战争史(下)

    秦汉战争史(下)

    战争是一种特殊的社会现象,它伴随着社会的发展而发展。战争史是记述这一特殊社会现象产生和发展全过程的专史,是人类社会发展史的主体组成部分。我国几千年来,有记载的部落之间、民族之间、诸侯之间、新旧王朝之间、阶级之间、阶级内部及国家之间所发生的战争,数以千记。中国战争史有着丰富的内容,它在人类历史的长河中闪烁着灿烂夺目的光辉。
  • 华夏血脉在异界

    华夏血脉在异界

    血脉之中,藏着远古的力量。在血统至上的异界,灵气法术,神,魔,天使代表着力量。华夏血脉在异界,炎黄子孙,祝融,刑天,伏羲,盘古!将迸发何样的力量。心脏的每一下跳动,都有力量涌现。至高血缘
  • 佛说须真天子经

    佛说须真天子经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。