登陆注册
5273300000040

第40章 THE UNION A FEDERATIVE AND NOT A NATIONAL GOVERNME

Cases arising under treaties,made under the authority of the United States,and those "affecting ambassadors and other public ministers end consuls,"could not properly be entrusted to any other than the federal tribunals.Treaties are made under the common authority of the States,and all,alike,are bound for the faithful observance of them.Ambassadors and other public ministers and consuls are received under the common authority of all the States,and their duties relate only to matters involving alike the interests of all.The peace of the country,and the harmony of its relations with foreign powers,depend,in a peculiar degree,on the good faith with which its duties in reference to these subjects are discharged.

Hence it would be unsafe to entrust them to any other than their own control;

and even if this were not so,it would be altogether incongruous to appeal to a State tribunal,to enforce the rights,the obligations or the duties of the United States.For like reasons,cases of admiralty and maritime jurisdiction are properly entrusted to the federal tribunals.

Controversies to which the United States shall be a party should,upon general principles,belong only to her own courts.There would be neither propriety nor justice in permitting any one State to decide a case in which all the States are parties.In like manner,those between two or more States ?between a State and citizens of another State,where the State is plaintiff ?(it cannot be sued)?and between citizens of different States,could not be entrusted to the tribunals of any particular State interested,or whose citizens are interested therein,without danger of injustice and partiality.Jurisdiction is given to the federal courts,in these cases,simply because they are equally interested for all the parties,are the common courts of all the parties,and therefore are presumed to form the only fair and impartial tribunal between them.The same reasoning applies to cases between citizens of the same State,claiming lands under grants of different States.Cases of this sort involve questions of the sovereign power of the States,and could not,with any show of propriety,be entrusted to the decision of either of them,interested as it would be to sustain its own acts,against those of the sister State.The jurisdiction in this case is given upon the same principles which give it in cases between two or more States.

Controversies between a State or the citizens thereof,and foreign States,citizens or subjects,depend on a different principle,but one equally affecting the common rights and interests of all the States.A foreign State cannot,of course,be sued;she can appear in our courts only as plaintiff.Yet,in whatever form such controversies,or those affecting the citizens of a foreign State,may arise,all the States have a deep interest that an impartial tribunal,satisfactory to the foreign party,should be provided.The denial of justice is a legitimate,and not an unfruitful cause of war.As no State can be involved in war without involving all the rest,they all have a common interest to withdraw from the State tribunals a jurisdiction which may bring them within the danger of that result.All the States are alike bound to render justice to foreign States and their people;and this common responsibility gives them a right to demand that every question involving it shall be decided by their common judicatory.

This brief review of the judicial power of the United States,as given in the Constitution,is not offered as a full analysis of the subject;

for the question before us does not render any such analysis necessary.

By design has been only to show with what extreme reserve judicial power has been conferred,and with what caution it has been restricted to those cases,only,which the new relation between the States established by the Constitution rendered absolutely necessary.In all the cases above supposed,the jurisdiction of the federal courts is clear and undoubted;and as the States have,in the frame of the Constitution,agreed to submit to the exercise of this jurisdiction,they are bound to do so,and to compel their people to like submission.But it is to be remarked,that they are bound only by their agreement,and not beyond it.They are under no obligation to submit to the decisions of the Supreme Court,on subject matter not properly cognizable before it,nor to those between parties not responsible to its jurisdiction.23Who,then,is to decide this point?Shall the Supreme Court decide for itself,and against all the world?It is admitted that every court must necessarily determine every question of jurisdiction which arises before it,and,so far,it must of course be the judge of its own powers.If it be a court of the last resort,its decision is necessarily final,so far as those authorities are concerned,which belong to the same system of government with itself.

There is,in fact,no absolute and certain limitation,in any constitutional government,to the powers of its own judiciary;for,as those powers are derived from the Constitution and as the judges are the interpreters of the Constitution,there is nothing to prevent them from interpreting in favor of any power which they may claim.The Supreme Court,therefore,may assume jurisdiction over subjects and between parties,not allowed by the Constitution,and there is no power in the Federal Government to gainsay it.Even the impeachment and removal of the judges,for ignorance or corruption,would not invalidate their decisions already pronounced.

Is there,then,no redress?The Constitution itself will answer this question in the most satisfactory manner.

同类推荐
  • 巩氏族谱

    巩氏族谱

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 东家杂记

    东家杂记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 温热经纬

    温热经纬

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 汉学师承记

    汉学师承记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 节士

    节士

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 国宾摩托车护卫队始末

    国宾摩托车护卫队始末

    有时,一件很美好的事物突然消失了,让人伤感,让人怀念,比如出于简化迎宾礼仪、缓解道路交通而取消的国宾车队摩托车护卫队。中国迎宾礼仪的门面、有着“中华第一骑”美誉的国宾车队摩托车护卫队的存在轰轰烈烈,它的消失无声无息。一个民族,一个国家,需要一种仪式来表示自己的尊严和热诚。国宾车队摩托车护卫队就是国家的一种迎宾仪式。
  • 小秘心计

    小秘心计

    虽说近水楼台,却也忍辱负重。小秘翻身站起来;什么红粉佳人,通通滚蛋。且看小秘潜伏职场,如何收服风流老板…*******新文一枚,多多捧场,写的不好,勿怪无怪!
  • 不抱怨的世界2:关系决定命运

    不抱怨的世界2:关系决定命运

    终此一生,我们都处在各种各样的关系中,与父母之间、与朋友、与兄弟姐妹、与爱人、与同事或者与某位萍水相逢之人……你决定着关系的路线。是你——不是上帝,不是其他人,不是你的命相,不是命运,不是职业、年龄、种族、教养,也不是你有多少钱——决定了你的关系走向何方。关系现在是,而且将来会一直是,人生的一部分。它是人类最大的难题,本书将告诉你如何在各种关系中,实现爱、平和、喜乐,使人生变得美好而圆满。
  • 乐紫

    乐紫

    现代网游竞技故事。宅女乐紫巧遇网游战队老板苏南,走入职业战队的故事。宅女乐紫和暴躁网游公司老板的故事。
  • 私生女的非正常生活

    私生女的非正常生活

    4——我一定是一个没有过去的人。——为什么没有过去?——因为过去已经万劫不复。
  • 武域灵主

    武域灵主

    上古大战,万域奔溃,众神陨落!苏家支族子弟苏牧,立志追求漫漫武道,奈何天赋平凡,受尽冷眼。一次意外,少年偶得积木造化,觉醒至强法相,手握铭纹传承,强势崛起,步步生莲,从此展开了逆袭之路!且看苏牧一人一剑,舞风云,灭苍穹,斗乾坤,战诸天强者,铸就万古第一人的不朽之路!巅峰传奇,一切从这里开始……
  • 苏霍多尔

    苏霍多尔

    《苏霍多尔》是一部俄罗斯中篇小说,讲述一个庄园的兴衰,居住其中的人们的生活和他们的爱恨情仇。在小说中,作者以第一人称回忆了苏霍多尔,从头至尾以一种追寻家族踪迹的姿态出现。但是其真正的主人公是娜达莉娅,她的回忆构成了小说的主体。加上其他人物的零碎而片段的记忆构建了一个完整的关于苏霍多尔的记忆。
  • 一品仙劫

    一品仙劫

    他风流无比,却深情的对她说:“我此生唯你一个。”最后他手执长剑刺入她胸膛。她执着于仙位,却身在仙劫中无处可走。最后才发现她这一生就是她最大的仙劫。---------------------------------------------走过路过,帮忙点个收藏点个推荐吧~
  • 中医的保健之道

    中医的保健之道

    疾病是人类的大敌。它不仅损害人体的健康,还能消磨人的意志。本书分别根据相应的疾病配以相应的秘方。本书所列的药膳秘方,既有古方,又有创新,内容翔实,知识性与实用性并重,重点突出,深入浅出,通俗易懂,全书既有传统医学内涵,又是一本推广药膳秘方的科学读物。
  • 管理的10大真相

    管理的10大真相

    本书作者曾在哈佛大学师从管理大师迈克尔·波特学习,熟悉西方的管理思想和企业案例;又长期在中国从事管理传播和教育工作,访谈过张瑞敏等众多经理人和企业,了解本土的企业实践和实际需求。在本书中,作者针对中国企业管理的实际问题,从自我管理、团队管理、管人、职场、领导力、企业的目的、顾客、企业文化、中国制造、大师等十个角度,参照并融会贯通东西方的管理理论、企业案例和经理人经验,提供了一份高瞻远瞩崦又脚踏实地的准确的“管理地图”。