登陆注册
5419400000210

第210章

By the polemic of pure reason I mean the defence of its propositions made by reason, in opposition to the dogmatical counter-propositions advanced by other parties.The question here is not whether its own statements may not also be false; it merely regards the fact that reason proves that the opposite cannot be established with demonstrative certainty, nor even asserted with a higher degree of probability.Reason does not hold her possessions upon sufferance;for, although she cannot show a perfectly satisfactory title to them, no one can prove that she is not the rightful possessor.

It is a melancholy reflection that reason, in its highest exercise, falls into an antithetic; and that the supreme tribunal for the settlement of differences should not be at union with itself.It is true that we had to discuss the question of an apparent antithetic, but we found that it was based upon a misconception.In conformity with the common prejudice, phenomena were regarded as things in themselves, and thus an absolute completeness in their synthesis was required in the one mode or in the other (it was shown to be impossible in both); a demand entirely out of place in regard to phenomena.There was, then, no real self-contradiction of reason in the propositions: The series of phenomena given in themselves has an absolutely first beginning; and: This series is absolutely and in itself without beginning.The two propositions are perfectly consistent with each other, because phenomena as phenomena are in themselves nothing, and consequently the hypothesis that they are things in themselves must lead to self-contradictory inferences.

But there are cases in which a similar misunderstanding cannot be provided against, and the dispute must remain unsettled.Take, for example, the theistic proposition: There is a Supreme Being; and on the other hand, the atheistic counter-statement: There exists no Supreme Being; or, in psychology: Everything that thinks possesses the attribute of absolute and permanent unity, which is utterly different from the transitory unity of material phenomena; and the counter-proposition: The soul is not an immaterial unity, and its nature is transitory, like that of phenomena.The objects of these questions contain no heterogeneous or contradictory elements, for they relate to things in themselves, and not to phenomena.There would arise, indeed, a real contradiction, if reason came forward with a statement on the negative side of these questions alone.As regards the criticism to which the grounds of proof on the affirmative side must be subjected, it may be freely admitted, without necessitating the surrender of the affirmative propositions, which have, at least, the interest of reason in their favour- an advantage which the opposite party cannot lay claim to.

I cannot agree with the opinion of several admirable thinkers-Sulzer among the rest- that, in spite of the weakness of the arguments hitherto in use, we may hope, one day, to see sufficient demonstrations of the two cardinal propositions of pure reason- the existence of a Supreme Being, and the immortality of the soul.I am certain, on the contrary, that this will never be the case.For on what ground can reason base such synthetical propositions, which do not relate to the objects of experience and their internal possibility? But it is also demonstratively certain that no one will ever be able to maintain the contrary with the least show of probability.For, as he can attempt such a proof solely upon the basis of pure reason, he is bound to prove that a Supreme Being, and a thinking subject in the character of a pure intelligence, are impossible.But where will he find the knowledge which can enable him to enounce synthetical judgements in regard to things which transcend the region of experience? We may, therefore, rest assured that the opposite never will be demonstrated.We need not, then, have recourse to scholastic arguments; we may always admit the truth of those propositions which are consistent with the speculative interests of reason in the sphere of experience, and form, moreover, the only means of uniting the speculative with the practical interest.

Our opponent, who must not be considered here as a critic solely, we can be ready to meet with a non liquet which cannot fail to disconcert him; while we cannot deny his right to a similar retort, as we have on our side the advantage of the support of the subjective maxim of reason, and can therefore look upon all his sophistical arguments with calm indifference.

From this point of view, there is properly no antithetic of pure reason.For the only arena for such a struggle would be upon the field of pure theology and psychology; but on this ground there can appear no combatant whom we need to fear.Ridicule and boasting can be his only weapons; and these may be laughed at, as mere child's play.

This consideration restores to Reason her courage; for what source of confidence could be found, if she, whose vocation it is to destroy error, were at variance with herself and without any reasonable hope of ever reaching a state of permanent repose?

同类推荐
  • Ballads in Blue China and Verses and Translations

    Ballads in Blue China and Verses and Translations

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 养正遗规

    养正遗规

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 明伦汇编官常典县令部

    明伦汇编官常典县令部

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 胎息经笺疏

    胎息经笺疏

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 诫初心学人文

    诫初心学人文

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 那般孤独

    那般孤独

    我们就像两个习惯孤独却又渴望温暖的患者,在偶然间碰在一起然后互相温暖。你始终清晰我们的关系,而我却忘了这样的我们并不是爱情。
  • 暗夜芳香

    暗夜芳香

    柳江如感觉身体忽然摇晃了一下,想必列车开动了。问母亲是不是回家?母亲跟父亲交换了一下眼神,好似犹豫了半刻,然后答复是肯定的。柳江如背往车厢一靠,眼泪倾盆而下。母亲递给她一张纸巾,她摸了一下扔到了一边。父亲怕她身后的衣帽钩碰了头,拉起她的手想让她摸脑后,柳江如甩开父亲的手,一闪,身体更往后靠,头咚地撞在上下铺的铁架子上。母亲抱过两床被子刚垫在她身后,也被柳江如一把推出很远。父母怕火车上的人不耐烦,开始还试着劝,后来看身边的旅客知道详情后,都抱以理解的态度就不劝了。坐在对面的一位胖胖的中年妇女抹着眼泪说让孩子哭吧,哭完了心情就好了。刚才送她的那个小伙子是她男朋友吧。
  • 超级刷钱红包系统

    超级刷钱红包系统

    挂机刷钱?小KS!咱有一百种刷钱方法!见过天气刷钱么?下一场雨,刷一百万乃至一千万!什么?河水刷钱?只要水在流,每秒都在刷钱。更牛逼的还在后头,情绪刷钱法了解一下!.................
  • 一品农庄,绝品夫

    一品农庄,绝品夫

    诈尸了!安月一觉醒来,成了安家的大丫头,刚从河里被捞上来。一个朦胧觉她竟成了村沟里的草凤凰,长得美却很窝囊的安钩月。钩月就钩月吧,毕竟那安钩月比她年轻,白捡了几年的便宜不要白不要!可没想到…上辈子惨不忍睹,这辈子惨绝人寰。这安钩月的处境真凄凉,睡的是冷草堆,吃的是窝窝头,上头有个后妈鞭挞着,下面还有个妹妹压榨着,还被口口声声叫着“小野种”。小野种?你特么才小野种,全家都是小野种!抡起她的锄头,拿着她的户口,看到山边那间屋没?从今以后那奏是她的家!买了地,种了田,养了…娃…敢情这安钩月花季年龄就珠胎暗结了,真是可怜她这个黄花大闺女跟着变妇人。十月怀胎,牙一咬、劲一使,无声无息出来个带把的:“孩子,我都抽你三巴掌了,你咋还不哭?”几年后。狼狗看家,儿子种田,她监督。村头,近万士兵安营扎寨。“爷?这小村子难道有了逆贼?”甲侍卫满眼崇拜!“爷,要不要属下先去当探情况?”乙侍卫首当其冲!“要我说,爷您直接下令,我们铲平了这村子!”丙侍卫忽略某人越来越黑的神色,不知死活。片刻……“卸甲归田!”某人一声令下,数万士兵踏入田园,拿起自备的锄头,干起了史上最伟大的工程:刨地!
  • 永恒复生者

    永恒复生者

    汤姆在翻越围栏的时候遇到了一些麻烦。铁栏杆勾住了他的裤脚,使他整个人在空中失去平衡,“唔!”湿润的草地重重地撞击鼻子,汤姆蜷缩着身体发出含混的呻吟声。杰瑞停下脚步,回头压低声音喊道:“快爬起来,白痴!我们只剩几分钟时间了,管理员会通知警察的!”汤姆艰难地撑起身体,噗噗擤擤鼻子里的血,“我当然知道……布鲁托呢?”“他拿着探测仪到里面去了,快点!”戴着老鼠杰瑞面具的男孩拽了他一把,两人跌跌撞撞踩过一片积水的草地,向墓地深处跑去。深夜的圣克里斯托弗墓园有种令人厌恶的潮湿味道,雨后的月光非常明亮。
  • The Spy's Son
  • 墨少请留步

    墨少请留步

    三世轮回,只为遇到你。乖,然然。不怕,我在。墨渊然:“我喜欢你”封君:“……”小傻瓜,我爱你封君一直是撩天撩地、无法无天的小霸王,直到遇见了他墨渊然一直是冷静自持、正气凛然的墨家二少,直到遇见了“他”
  • 王熙凤办事有一手

    王熙凤办事有一手

    王熙凤的管理来得直接有效,具有以下几个鲜明的特点:不承诺,只不断指出“这是你该做的”;不示范,只不断指出“我说的你应该懂,你应该会”;不交流,只不断指出“你只需要照我说的去做就行了”;不讨论,以独裁的方式实现民主,而不幻想以民主的方式实现民主;不原谅,手不错一次就将被永久开除。
  • 修仙废柴逆袭记

    修仙废柴逆袭记

    在修真底层默默挣扎的沈秋一朝重生到了几千年前,天材地宝,仙法秘籍,仙器灵丹,前人遗府,大好的机缘在等着她。前世被人否定,沈秋发誓,今世她要直登仙道,为仙为上!
  • 内经评文

    内经评文

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。