登陆注册
5451400000061

第61章

It is moreover a fact, which no one has explained better than Adam Smith, in his account of the growth in every individual of the virtue of self-command, that though our moral estimate of our own conduct begins by reference to the sympathy of particular individuals, our parents, schoolfellows, or others, we yet end by judging ourselves, not by reference to any one in particular so much as from an abstract idea of general approbation or the contrary, derived from our experience of particular judgments in the course of our life. This is all that is meant by "the abstract spectator," reference to whom is simply the same as reference to the supposed verdict of public opinion. If we have done anything wrong, told a lie, for example, the self-condemnation we pass on ourselves is the condemnation of public opinion, with which we identify ourselves by long force of habit; and had we never heard a lie condemned, nor known it punished, we should feel no self-condemnation whatever in telling one. We condemn it, not by reference, as Jouffroy puts it, to the feelings of John or Peter, but by reference to the feelings of the general world, which we know to be made up of people like John and Peter. There is nothing inconsistent therefore in the notion of an abstract spectator, "who has neither the prejudices of the one nor the weaknesses of the other, and who sees correctly and soundly precisely because he is abstract." The identification of this abstract spectator with conscience, is so far from being, as Jouffroy says it is, a departure from, and an abandonment of the rule of sympathy, that it is its logical and most satisfactory development. There is no reason to repeat the process by which the perception of particular approving sympathies passes into identification with the highest rules of morality and the most sacred dictates of religion. By reference to his own experience, every reader may easily test for himself the truth or falsity of Adam Smith's argument upon this subject.

It is said with truth, that to make the judgment of an impartial or abstract spectator the standard of morality is to make no security against fallibility of judgment; and that such a judgment is only efficacious where there is tolerable unanimity, but that it fails in the face of possible differences of opinion. But this objection is equally true of any ethical standard ever yet propounded in the world, whether self- interest, the greatest possible happiness, the will of the sovereign, the fitness of things, or any other principle is suggested as the ultimate test of rectitude of conduct. This part of the theory may claim, therefore, not only to be as good as any other theory, but to be in strict keeping with the vast amount of variable moral sentiment which actually exists in the world.

In further disproof of Adam Smith's theory, Jouffroy appeals to consciousness.

We are not conscious, he says, in judging of the acts of others, that we measure them by reference to our ability to sympathize with them. So far are we from doing this, that we consider it our first duty to stifle our emotions of sympathy or antipathy, in order to arrive at an impartial judgment.

As regards our own emotions, also, there is no such recourse to the sympathies of others; and even when there is, we often prefer our own judgment after all to that which we know to be the judgment of others. Consciousness therefore attests the falsity of the theory that we seek in our own sensibility the judgments we pass upon others, or that we seek in the opinions of others the principle of estimation for our own sentiments and conduct.

The truth of the fact stated in this objection may evidently be conceded, and yet the validity of the main theory be left untouched. The latter is a theory mainly of the origin of moral feelings, and of their growth; and emotions of sympathy which originally give rise to moral feelings may well disappear and be absent when long habit has once fixed them in the mind.

It is quite conceivable, for instance, that if we originally derived our moral notions of our own conduct from constant observation of the conduct of others, we might yet come to judge ourselves by a standard apparently unconnected with any reference to other people, and yet really made up of a number of forgotten judgments passed by us upon them. Children are always taught to judge them- selves by appeals to the sentiments of their parents or other relations about their conduct; and though the standard of morality, thus external at first, may in time come to be internal, and even to be more potent than when it was external, it none the more follows that recourse to such sympathy never took place because it ceases to take place or to be noticed when the moral sentiments are fully formed. In learning to read and write, an exactly analogous process may be traced. The letters which so painfully affected our consciousness at first, when we had to make constant reference to the alphabet, cease at last to affect it at all; yet the process of spelling really goes on in the mind in every word we read or write, however unconscious we may be of its operation. Habit and experience, says Adam Smith, teach us so easily and so readily to view our own interests and those of others from the standpoint of a third person, that "we are scarce sensible" of such a process at all.

Then again, the question has been raised, Is it true that sympathy with an agent or with the object of his action is a necessary antecedent to all moral approbation or the contrary?

同类推荐
  • 大方广普贤所说经

    大方广普贤所说经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 注十疑论

    注十疑论

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • Glaucus or The Wonders of the Shore

    Glaucus or The Wonders of the Shore

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • Driven From Home

    Driven From Home

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • THE BLUE FAIRY BOOK

    THE BLUE FAIRY BOOK

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 嫡女三嫁鬼王爷

    嫡女三嫁鬼王爷

    一对一洛紫风知道自己现在唯一的解药就是‘男人’,虽然眼前这个男人可恶了点、阴险了点、还有那么一点点让自己害怕,可是此刻也管不了那么多了。“那个谁——,你过来!”某女开始上下齐手。某男很淡定的看着这双在自己身上游弋的小手:“你不是打探过我吗,整个京城的人都知道我——‘不能行人事’,你不知道吗?”“这你就不用操心了!”银针在某个穴道上一扎.吃干抹净——,某女要走人前抛下一句:“估计你也是个‘处’,咱俩算是扯平了,以后别说认识我!”某男看着远去的背影——“你想的美——!”【片段一】洛紫风看着脚下中了‘媚毒’的女子,冷笑一声:“还想给我下毒?仗着和我那‘夫君’是青梅竹马,又有公公婆婆当你是亲闺女,就处处和我作对,企图‘亲近’我那夫君,好——!我成全你!”候在一旁的九月一愣,什么时候自家小姐这么——好说话了!“去——,等她媚毒发作,就送到我‘公公’书房去,‘母子关系’,够亲近了吧!不——用——谢——我!”看着九月背着那个女子一跃而去。洛紫风不禁期待明天的太阳快点升起,想着明个一早的靖王府——,该是个如何‘振奋人心’的早晨呀——!【片段二】“这个给你!”如花郡主将手中的《仇人录》低了过去:“所有曾欺负过我的人,我都记录在上面了,你既然已经决定冒充我的身份了,就得替我讨回来!”“不是吧?洒你身上一杯茶水——你也记!”“你看清楚了!那是101杯,她丫的——是间歇性‘帕金森综合症’,见到我就犯病!”一群男子自‘如花郡主’身后讥笑的嚷嚷道:“‘花痴’郡主——!灵王世子在这呢!”正在熟读《仇人录》的某女回头。众男子诧异,原来那一直涂的五彩缤纷,看不出眉眼的脸下,竟然也是一副如花美貌!某女冷眼相对,朱唇轻启:“皇上已经解除了我与灵王世子的婚约,我的目的已经达到了!今儿个起——,本郡主不陪你们玩了!谢谢各位前些日子的配合!”看着某女远去的背影,众男子齐呆!某男一愣!【片段三】某男暴怒:“我该叫你什么?洛紫风、还是如花郡主、还是其他什么我不知道的,你究竟是谁?是不是我娘子?”“我是谁关你什么事?”“好!好!好!”某男怒极反笑,片刻功夫将某女绑在了床上:“你什么时候确定我们有关系了,我什么时候放你下床!”随后,某男开始解开自己的衣结.无论你嫁几次人,新郎只能是我!
  • 进化——空武之具

    进化——空武之具

    远古遗迹里的科技,带出的究竟是进步还是毁灭呢?
  • 末世晴天

    末世晴天

    穿越成为末世的路人甲,携带店铺系统,独善自身,本文女主冷清淡漠,秉承着独善其身,银货两讫的做法,在末世中成长。女主不圣母,不小白,随心所欲。保持初心。
  • 如果东京不快乐

    如果东京不快乐

    晋江大神级作家纯白经典短篇集。她最美是在十几岁,在那少年的眼中。他想要看顾她,收藏她,请动诸天神佛来护佑她。走在校园里,悄悄地拉着她的手。眼角眉梢都是笑,根本藏不住。少年情怀总是诗,纯白用清新隽永的文字生动演绎残酷而美妙的青春。夹杂着甜蜜与遗憾的故事,让人遥遥想起,记忆深处那场年华如歌,岁月如刻。
  • 南宗抉秘

    南宗抉秘

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 无限之机械大师

    无限之机械大师

    一个普通的大学生,穿越到了变形金刚的世界,还和主角山姆成了同学,他更是具有了控制机械,与智能科技沟通的能力,从此成为了无限世界冒险者中的一员,看他是怎么在这些世界与任务中生存下来的。
  • 闪婚夫人她超甜

    闪婚夫人她超甜

    “不许穿暴露的衣服。”“不许彻夜不归。”“不许和任何明星传绯闻,女的也不行。”“每天早晚安吻不能少,就算去外地出差也一样。”“各种节日必须和我一起过,包括三八节和儿童节。”误惹萧氏太子爷,换来一份结婚契约书。除了要配合他在媒体面前花样秀恩爱,还要满足他霸道的占有欲。她试图反抗,想要争取一点自己的民主权利。萧言宠溺一笑:“我就是民主。”
  • 末世重生之进化者

    末世重生之进化者

    前世被友情所背叛,重生后的熊梓玲决定不再相信友情,想要再见一面家人的熊梓玲重生了,没有想过去复仇,只要这一世不再和那个杀死她的人为友就好。但有什么和前世是不同的,得知真相的同时,熊梓玲也得知了前世的自己是因何而死。比起前世的绝望,这一世,总还是有点希望的。
  • 百逆

    百逆

    百逆转仙道,无上混元功。以我季长明之名,逆转成神,证无上大道!
  • 重生我不是影后

    重生我不是影后

    她演技精湛,却坚定道:我不做影后!重来一次,凌蔚坚决不要再做风光无限好的影后,世人只看到她台上的风光,看不到为了这风光她付出的努力。这一次她要低调演戏,安心过自己的小日子!