登陆注册
5589700000101

第101章 BENTHAM'S DOCTRINE(23)

VII.INDIVIDUALISM

'Individualism'in the first place is generally mentioned in a different connection.The 'ready-made'man of whom I have spoken becomes the 'economic man.'Bentham himself contributed little to economic theory.His most important writing was the Defence of Usury,and in this,as we have seen,he was simply adding a corollary to the Wealth of Nations.The Wealth of Nations itself represented the spirit of business;the revolt of men who were building up a vast industrial system against the fetters imposed by traditional legislation and by rulers who regarded industry in general,as Telford is said to have regarded rivers.Rivers were meant to supply canals,and trade to supply tax-gatherers.With this revolt,of course,Bentham was in full sympathy,but here I shall only speak of one doctrine of great interest,which occurs both in his political treatises and his few economical remarks.Bentham objected,as we have seen,to the abstract theory of equality.Yet it was to the mode of deduction rather than to the doctrine itself which he objected.He gave,in fact,his own defence;and it is one worth notice.(109)The principle of equality is derivative,not ultimate.Equality is good because equality increases the sum of happiness.Thus,as he says,(110)if two men have £1000,and you transfer £500from one to the other,you increase the recipient's wealth by one-third,and diminish the loser's wealth by one-half.You therefore add less pleasure than you subtract.The principle is given less mathematically(111)by the more significant argument that 'felicity'depends not simply on the 'matter of felicity'or the stimulus,but also on the sensibility to felicity which is necessarily limited.Therefore by adding wealth --taking,for example,from a thousand labourers to give to one king --you are supersaturating a sensibility already glutted by taking away from others a great amount of real happiness.With this argument,which has of late years become conspicuous in economics,he connects another of primary importance.The first condition of happiness,he says,is not 'equality'but 'security.'Now you can only equalise at the expense of security.If I am to have my property taken away whenever it is greater than my neighbour's,I can have no security.(112)Hence,if the two principles conflict,equality should give way.Security is the primary,which must override the secondary,aim.Must the two principles,then,always conflict?No;but 'time is the only mediator.'(113)The law may help to accumulate inequalities;but in a prosperous state there is a 'continual progress towards equality.'The law has to stand aside;not to maintain monopolies;not to restrain trade;not to permit entails;and then property will diffuse itself by a natural process,already exemplified in the growth of Europe.The 'pyramids'heaped up in feudal times have been lowered,and their 'débris spread abroad'among the industrious.Here again we see how Bentham virtually diverges from the a priori school.Their absolute tendencies would introduce 'equality'by force;he would leave it to the spontaneous progress of security.Hence Bentham is in the main an adherent of what he calls (114)the 'laissez-nous faire'principle.He advocates it most explicitly in the so-called Manual of Political Economy --a short essay first printed in 1798.(115)The tract,however,such as it is,is less upon political economy proper than upon economic legislation;and its chief conclusion is that almost all legislation is improper.His main principle is 'Be quiet'(the equivalent of the French phrase,which surely should have been excluded from so English a theory).Security and freedom are all that industry requires;and industry should say to government only what Diogenes said to Alexander,'Stand out of my sunshine.'(116)Once more,however,Bentham will not lay down the 'let alone'principle absolutely.His adherence to the empirical method is too decided.The doctrine 'be quiet,'though generally true,rests upon utility,and may,therefore,always be qualified by proving that in a particular case the balance of utility is the other way.In fact,some of Bentham's favourite projects would be condemned by an absolute adherent of the doctrine.The Panopticon,for example,though a 'mill to grind rogues honest'could be applied to others than rogues,and Bentham hoped to make his machinery equally effective in the case of pauperism.A system of national education is also included in his ideal constitution.

It is,in fact,important to remember that the 'individualism'of Benthamism does not necessarily coincide with an absolute restriction of government interference.The general tendency was in that direction;and in purely economical questions,scarcely any exception was admitted to the rule.Men are the best judges,it was said,of their own interest;and the interference of rulers in a commercial transaction is the interference of people inferior in knowledge of the facts,and whose interests are 'sinister'or inconsistent with those of the persons really concerned.Utility,therefore,will,as a rule,forbid the action of government:but,as utility is always the ultimate principle,and there may be cases in which it does not coincide with the 'let alone'principle,we must always admit the possibility that in special cases government can interfere usefully,and,in that case,approve the interference.

Hence we have the ethical application of these theories.The individualist position naturally tends to take the form of egoism.The moral sentiments,whatever they may be,are clearly an intrinsic part of the organic social instincts.They are intimately involved in the whole process of social evolution.

But this view corresponds precisely to the conditions which Bentham overlooks.

同类推荐
  • Pollyanna

    Pollyanna

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 联缀体

    联缀体

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 南宋元明禅林僧宝传

    南宋元明禅林僧宝传

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 大乘二十二问本

    大乘二十二问本

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • Louisa of Prussia and Her Times

    Louisa of Prussia and Her Times

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 太乙仙元志

    太乙仙元志

    无垠的夜幕降临,天地间却是一片血红。少年踏上了寂灭的土地,寻找他内心渴望的光辉。面前是深渊,背后是烈焰,纵然千难万险,他也要打破束缚,渡劫成仙!
  • 绝世懒妃之你可还想逃

    绝世懒妃之你可还想逃

    吾儿谁也别想碰,否则我定拿你们所有人性命陪葬!
  • 世界经典科幻故事全集:远古寻踪的故事

    世界经典科幻故事全集:远古寻踪的故事

    我们编辑的这套《世界经典科幻故事全集》包括《太空环游的故事》、《星球纵览的故事》、《海底探险的故事》、《岛上猎奇的故事》、《科学传奇的故事》、《奇异幻想的故事》、《神秘人类的故事》、《远古寻踪的故事》、《机器大战的故事》和《古堡秘影的故事》等10册内容,精选了包括法国著名科幻作家、科幻小说之父儒勒· 凡尔纳和英国著名科幻作家威尔斯等人的作品近百篇,既有一定的代表性, 又有一定的普遍性,非常适合青少年阅读和学习。
  • 末世重生之女配系统太淡定

    末世重生之女配系统太淡定

    男主版文案:她走的第一年,他希翼万分的想:只要你回来,我不会再让你受丝毫委屈。她离开的第六年,他绝望万分的说:谁若能找到她,我就把这诺大的家产给谁。她消失的第十二年,他午夜梦回时,让人为她打造了一把坚固的锁链。她不见的第十八年,末世来了,他······疯了。凌依,莫让我再找到你。女主版文案:当她知道自己痛苦一生只因为自己是一个恶毒女配时,她想要哭泣,却发现自己早已失去了哭泣的本能。一场机遇······当一切重来,已成为系统一部分的她,人生又会有怎样的变化? 1v1,双洁
  • 山西民间笑话

    山西民间笑话

    这是一套面向农村、供广大农民朋友阅读的文化丛书。它涉及戏曲、曲艺、民间歌舞、民间工艺、民间故事、民间笑话等多个门类,涵括了编织剌绣、建筑装饰、酿酒制醋、剪纸吹塑、冶铁铸造、陶瓷漆艺等林林总总的艺术形式,是老百姓熟悉的艺术,是我们身边的艺术,和我们的日常生活密切相关。
  • 王爷要逼宫,带上你的妃

    王爷要逼宫,带上你的妃

    “你是我喜欢的女人,你说的一切都是对的,即使是错的,我也能做一个不明事理的人,满足你!”本想调戏傲娇正太的学长的杨紫苏却被男朋友抓了个正着,误打误撞穿越到古代,还在她YY着在古代的如鱼得水的幸福生活的时候却被本国太子——轩辕璟,对上眼,就算已经贵为太子妃的她怎能继续放弃狩猎美男的机会呢?各路皇公贵胄纷纷瞧上杨紫苏的美貌,其中示爱最频繁的莫过于魏王轩辕钰。为了爱,去跳崖,做乞丐,始终没有获得美人欢心,她说如果你能做整个天下的王者她便嫁于他;在整个逼宫过程中轩辕钰步步为营,已经拥有了半个天下的轩辕钰却在杨紫苏的请求下停战!王爷要逼宫!轩辕璟,我要你的妃!【情节虚构,请勿模仿】
  • 红楼之水沁黛心

    红楼之水沁黛心

    红楼之鬼医寵主:-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------一个是被称为鬼医的降世神医,一个是美貌若仙的世外仙子!九子夺嫡,他是一代降世的神医,她是一抹孤洁傲世的淡雅花魂,一期相遇,彼此的命运和人生便命定的纠结在一起,难解难分!这一世都将相互陪伴着走下去!你的眼泪再不会白流,而是化成我掌心最洁白无价的珍珠!******可叹那红楼大厦呼啦啦倾颓,冷月儿孤葬了一抹花魂!我曾夜畔捧书几多想,雪芹先生披阅十载,增删五次呕心沥血写出的《红楼梦》寄托了先生对红颜知己李香玉的几多相思?如果那锤炼在红楼梦中的不是那个软弱无能的贾宝玉,而是对黛玉相知相惜的江宁织造局未来继承人曹雪芹。。。梦中一切繁华还原它本来模样,曹家连任60余年江宁织造,李家亦为苏州制造局之主,黛玉还原她的模样,贵为李家之珍宝,美玉无瑕在一片污淖俗世中卓然独立、一尘不染,一代神医曹雪芹又将为了心上之人如何奋起反悖世道命运,受任于康熙末年之间,铲除曹府内贼孽祸,肃清家治,又如何游刃于蛟龙九子之间,在混乱残酷的宫廷斗争之中,使曹家免于抄家之祸,为妹妹铸造一段康雍传奇!(该故事可能结局会跟历史不一样,像“胤禛会不会是最后的雍正皇帝啊?”诸如此类的问题请亲亲们不要再在留言中多问,该文中一切历史都为雪芹先生一心给妹妹筑造一个温馨温暖的爱之巢服务,考究历史者请不要在本文中抠字了)(本篇出于爱的写文,保证完结,但不保证每天一更(我不是专门写文的),也可能一周才一更或我也不知道具体时间,外加无线网那个怨念的链接状态,喜欢青色的文又能接受这一点的亲亲们请不要大意地入坑吧,不能接受的亲请不要在下面发抱怨之言的挥一挥衣袖……吧。最后,谢谢!)红楼之水沁黛心-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------七年之前,七岁之时,她遇大风迷失,她与他机缘巧合偶遇在漫天枯谢的荷塘边,小小的他救起不小心扭伤了脚踝的小小的她,归还原主。她与他就此分别,她没有留下给他什么,只留下了一句“先生常教我诗词,我最不喜欢李义山的诗,只喜他这一句:‘留得残荷听雨声’”,离他而去。
  • 因为风就在那里

    因为风就在那里

    他像山一样冷峻,仿佛不懂得爱情。而她微笑的样子,却让人想起了爱情。风马旗飞扬,转经筒滚动,亚丁的客栈遗世而独立。她来寻找大山的秘密,他一样也在寻觅着一个真相。她于他,是不期而遇的惊喜,也是麻烦。他于她,是亟待探索的富矿,也是危险。然而越危险,却越想接近。
  • 金色的房子(中篇小说)

    金色的房子(中篇小说)

    十六年前,我大学毕业,分配到北都市统计局工作。第二年春季,单位派我到北都大学,进修一学期财经理论,所以认识了杨先生。杨先生是中国人,在台湾出生,六十年代中期大学毕业,当过两年兵后,到美国留学,获博士学位,在美国蒙塔那州一个国家实验室做研究员。中国开放以后,他连续四年应聘回国,在各大学客座演讲,介绍美国科技研究的新方法和新成果。杨先生个子不很高,也不健壮,但总是西装革履,器宇轩昂,容光焕发,充满自信。这种样子的人,八十年代初期的中国大陆,还很少见,显得特殊,十分惹眼。
  • 首席的无赖契约(结局)

    首席的无赖契约(结局)

    他对她说:如果你的脾气可以改一改,再倒贴点钱的话,说不定这辈子还能嫁出去。她说:就算我这辈子都嫁不出去,我都不会嫁给你这种男人。”他说:我还真怕你哭着喊着要嫁给我。”她说:做为男人,还是应该有点修养的好,一点修养都没有的话,恐怕这辈子都会娶不到老婆!他说:就算这辈子我都娶不到老婆,我都不会娶你这样的女人做老婆。”老爸滥赌成性,欠下巨额高利贷她回到家里,不料,家被洗劫一空,高利贷扬言,还不清欠款,拿人抵押`奶奶病危,唯一遗憾,未能见到未来的孙媳。只是此时,谈了三年的女友,却离他而去!他决定巨额寻找一女假装自己未婚妻,无奈夜深人稀,医院里全是老弱病残妇女,正百无计策,他遇到了她……