登陆注册
5589700000053

第53章 PHILOSOPHY(7)

He really approximates most closely to Hutcheson,who takes a similar view of Utilitarianism,but he professes the warmest admiration of Butler.He explicitly accepts Butler's doctrine of the 'supremacy of the conscience'--a doctrine which as he says,the bishop,'has placed in the strongest and happiest light.'(45)He endeavours,again,to approximate to the 'intellectual school,'of which Richard Price (1723-1791)was the chief English representative at the time.Like Kant,Price deduces the moral law from principles of pure reason.The truth of the moral law.'Thou shalt do to others as you wish that they should do to you,'is as evident as the truth of the law in geometry,'things which are equal to the same thing are equal to each other.'Stewart so far approves that he wishes to give to the moral law what is now called all possible 'objectivity,'while the 'moral sense'of Hutcheson apparently introduced a 'subjective'element.He holds,however,that our moral perceptions 'involve a feeling of the heart,'as well as a 'judgment of the understanding,'(46)and ascribes the same view to Butler.But then,by using the word 'reason'so as to include the whole nature of a rational being,we may ascribe to it the 'origin of those simple ideas which are not excited in the mind by the operation of the senses,but which arise in consequence of the operation of the intellectual powers among the various objects.'(47)Hutcheson,he says,made his 'moral sense'unsatisfactory by taking his illustrations from the 'secondary'instead of the 'primary qualities,'(48)and thus with the help of intuitive first principles,Stewart succeeds in believing that it would be as hard for a man to believe that he ought to sacrifice another man's happiness to his own as to believe that three angles of a triangle are equal to one right angle.(49)It is true that a feeling and a judgment are both involved;but the 'intellectual judgment'is the groundwork of the feeling,not the feeling of the judgment.(50)In spite,however,of this attempt to assimilate his principles to those of the intellectual school,the substance of Stewart's ethics is essentially psychological.It rests,in fact,upon his view that philosophy depends upon inductive psychology,and,therefore,essentially upon experience subject to the cropping up of convenient 'intuitions.'

This appears from the nature of his argument against the Utilitarians.

In his time,this doctrine was associated with the names of Hartley,Tucker,Godwin,and especially Paley.He scarcely refers to Bentham.(51)Paley is the recognised anvil for the opposite school.Now he agrees,as I have said,with Paley's view of natural theology and entirely accepts therefore the theory of 'final causes.'The same theory becomes prominent in his ethical teaching.We may perhaps say that Stewart's view is in substance an inverted Utilitarianism.It may be best illustrated by an argument familiar in another application.Paley and his opponents might agree that the various instincts of an animal are so constituted that in point of fact they contribute to his preservation and his happiness.But from one point of view this appears to be simply to say that the conditions of existence necessitate a certain harmony,and that the harmony is therefore to be a consequence of his self-preservation.

From the opposite point of view,which Stewart accepts,it appears that the self-preservation is the consequence of a pre-established harmony,which has been divinely appointed in order that he may live.Stewart,in short,is a 'teleologist'of the Paley variety.Psychology proves the existence of design in the moral world,as anatomy or physiology proves it in the physical.

Stewart therefore fully agrees that virtue generally produces happiness.

lf it be true (a doctrine,he thinks,beyond our competence to decide)that 'the sole principle of action in the Deity'is benevolence,it may be that he has commanded us to be virtuous because he sees virtue to be useful.In this case utility may be the final cause of morality;and the fact that virtue has this tendency gives the plausibility to utilitarian systems.(52)But the key to the difficulty is the distinction between 'final'and 'efficient'causes;for the efficient cause of morality is not the desire for happiness,but a primitive and simple instinct,namely,the moral faculty.

Thus he rejects Paley's notorious doctrine that virtue differs from prudence only in regarding the consequences in another world instead of consequences in this.(53)Reward and punishment 'presuppose the notions of right and wrong'and cannot be the source of those notions.The favourite doctrine of association,by which the Utilitarians explained unselfishness,is only admissible as accounting for modifications,such as are due to education and example,but 'presupposes the existence of certain principles which are common to all mankind.'The evidence of such principles is established by a long and discursive psychological discussion.It is enough to say that he admits two rational principles,'self-love'and the 'moral faculty,'the coincidence of which is learned only by experience.The moral faculty reveals simple 'ideas'of right and wrong,which are incapable of any further analysis.

But besides these,there is a hierarchy of other instincts or desires,which he calls 'implanted'because 'for aught we know'they may be of 'arbitrary appointment.'(54)Resentment,for example,is an implanted instinct,of which the 'final cause'is to defend us against 'sudden violence.'(55)Stewart's analysis is easygoing and suggests more problems than it solves.The general position,however,is clear enough,and not,I think,without much real force as against the Paley form of utilitarianism.

同类推荐
  • Three Lectures on the Rate of Wages

    Three Lectures on the Rate of Wages

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 太上洞玄灵宝净供妙经

    太上洞玄灵宝净供妙经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 南统大君内丹九章经

    南统大君内丹九章经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 得无垢女经

    得无垢女经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 汉武故事

    汉武故事

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 尘倾天下

    尘倾天下

    生是女儿身,奈何帝王命。几年前的初见到如今还能够记得?千百年来的宫斗何时能够停止?拂轻尘的一身究竟是谁在修改?“我们不过是上天的提线木偶,说什么身不由己,太可笑了!”是谁在最后了无生忘的说着……
  • 心经

    心经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 往生玄云录

    往生玄云录

    看书林隐处,多俊逸儒流。虚名薄利不关愁,裁冰及剪雪,谈笑看吴钩。兴亡如脆柳,身世类虚舟。试看,新月下长川,玄幻有江湖,且覆掌中杯,再听新声曲度。一位渡三生,活三世的少年,横空出世,看!新的神话云录。 是妖王之子,是独狐神话,还是多情魔心;是情深似海,是仇深似海,还是有情之道。 无情,薄情,多情!书写的是九嶷神话!
  • 逆袭

    逆袭

    本书摒弃华而不实的大道理,运用了大量实例来佐证心态、意志、人气等的重要,名人的事例可以给我们带来决心与向往,普通人的成功可以使我们借鉴和复制。本书将告诉你最现实的做人哲学,最实用的避险之道,最直接的成功心法,最有效的处世良方。
  • 俄狄浦斯之泪

    俄狄浦斯之泪

    日影西斜。一台红色的奇瑞QQ开到了L大学的大门外。开车的是一个三十出头的男子,双目如电,神采昂然。他叫霍奇侠,是L市刑警支队的一名刑警。此时他刚把车停下,便有一个女生向他走来。那女生不到二十岁,大眼睛,尖鼻子,美貌绝伦,只是神色有些冰冷。只见女生走到车前,笑问:“霍警官,让我开吧?”“你有驾驶证?”霍奇侠问。女生嫣然一笑:“没有哦。”“那怎么可以?”
  • 从魔禁开始的穿越

    从魔禁开始的穿越

    楚星呆滞的看着面前的场景,忍不住一手指天:怕不是我出门没看黄历,一辈子没拜过天!十辈子坏事做尽的下场吧!!!落入学园都市,还莫名的身负任务,这到底是造了什么孽啊?为了自己能更好的活着,楚星同学开始了一步一步往上爬的路,当他爬出这个世界之后才发现…这一切都只是个开始…
  • 以色列的诞生(全四册)

    以色列的诞生(全四册)

    普利策文学奖获得者“以色列建国史”系列,一部浓缩的生存奋争史,一部令人感佩的卫国战士奋争史。本套书共四册,分别为《以色列的诞生:希望.1》、《以色列的诞生:希望.2》、《以色列的诞生:荣耀.1》、《以色列的诞生:荣耀.2》。
  • 末世晴天

    末世晴天

    穿越成为末世的路人甲,携带店铺系统,独善自身,本文女主冷清淡漠,秉承着独善其身,银货两讫的做法,在末世中成长。女主不圣母,不小白,随心所欲。保持初心。
  • 大学生GE阅读(第3辑)

    大学生GE阅读(第3辑)

    本书是大学“大学生GE阅读”第3辑,书中具体收录了《20世纪西方美学的四个问题》、《人性新说:不要忘记我们是人》、《论苏轼的文学创作与禅宗之关系》、《“自由立兹”的周德伟》、《短语评点51则:中国古典诗词的另类品题》等文章。
  • 重生女王有点狂

    重生女王有点狂

    出生的那一刻,她后背的火凤凰封印伴随着她,母亲难产而死,家族视她为不祥之物。冷凤冥高深莫测:“有兴趣做我女人吗?”玄洛冰妩媚轻扬:“有兴趣当姐男人吗?”