登陆注册
5589700000053

第53章 PHILOSOPHY(7)

He really approximates most closely to Hutcheson,who takes a similar view of Utilitarianism,but he professes the warmest admiration of Butler.He explicitly accepts Butler's doctrine of the 'supremacy of the conscience'--a doctrine which as he says,the bishop,'has placed in the strongest and happiest light.'(45)He endeavours,again,to approximate to the 'intellectual school,'of which Richard Price (1723-1791)was the chief English representative at the time.Like Kant,Price deduces the moral law from principles of pure reason.The truth of the moral law.'Thou shalt do to others as you wish that they should do to you,'is as evident as the truth of the law in geometry,'things which are equal to the same thing are equal to each other.'Stewart so far approves that he wishes to give to the moral law what is now called all possible 'objectivity,'while the 'moral sense'of Hutcheson apparently introduced a 'subjective'element.He holds,however,that our moral perceptions 'involve a feeling of the heart,'as well as a 'judgment of the understanding,'(46)and ascribes the same view to Butler.But then,by using the word 'reason'so as to include the whole nature of a rational being,we may ascribe to it the 'origin of those simple ideas which are not excited in the mind by the operation of the senses,but which arise in consequence of the operation of the intellectual powers among the various objects.'(47)Hutcheson,he says,made his 'moral sense'unsatisfactory by taking his illustrations from the 'secondary'instead of the 'primary qualities,'(48)and thus with the help of intuitive first principles,Stewart succeeds in believing that it would be as hard for a man to believe that he ought to sacrifice another man's happiness to his own as to believe that three angles of a triangle are equal to one right angle.(49)It is true that a feeling and a judgment are both involved;but the 'intellectual judgment'is the groundwork of the feeling,not the feeling of the judgment.(50)In spite,however,of this attempt to assimilate his principles to those of the intellectual school,the substance of Stewart's ethics is essentially psychological.It rests,in fact,upon his view that philosophy depends upon inductive psychology,and,therefore,essentially upon experience subject to the cropping up of convenient 'intuitions.'

This appears from the nature of his argument against the Utilitarians.

In his time,this doctrine was associated with the names of Hartley,Tucker,Godwin,and especially Paley.He scarcely refers to Bentham.(51)Paley is the recognised anvil for the opposite school.Now he agrees,as I have said,with Paley's view of natural theology and entirely accepts therefore the theory of 'final causes.'The same theory becomes prominent in his ethical teaching.We may perhaps say that Stewart's view is in substance an inverted Utilitarianism.It may be best illustrated by an argument familiar in another application.Paley and his opponents might agree that the various instincts of an animal are so constituted that in point of fact they contribute to his preservation and his happiness.But from one point of view this appears to be simply to say that the conditions of existence necessitate a certain harmony,and that the harmony is therefore to be a consequence of his self-preservation.

From the opposite point of view,which Stewart accepts,it appears that the self-preservation is the consequence of a pre-established harmony,which has been divinely appointed in order that he may live.Stewart,in short,is a 'teleologist'of the Paley variety.Psychology proves the existence of design in the moral world,as anatomy or physiology proves it in the physical.

Stewart therefore fully agrees that virtue generally produces happiness.

lf it be true (a doctrine,he thinks,beyond our competence to decide)that 'the sole principle of action in the Deity'is benevolence,it may be that he has commanded us to be virtuous because he sees virtue to be useful.In this case utility may be the final cause of morality;and the fact that virtue has this tendency gives the plausibility to utilitarian systems.(52)But the key to the difficulty is the distinction between 'final'and 'efficient'causes;for the efficient cause of morality is not the desire for happiness,but a primitive and simple instinct,namely,the moral faculty.

Thus he rejects Paley's notorious doctrine that virtue differs from prudence only in regarding the consequences in another world instead of consequences in this.(53)Reward and punishment 'presuppose the notions of right and wrong'and cannot be the source of those notions.The favourite doctrine of association,by which the Utilitarians explained unselfishness,is only admissible as accounting for modifications,such as are due to education and example,but 'presupposes the existence of certain principles which are common to all mankind.'The evidence of such principles is established by a long and discursive psychological discussion.It is enough to say that he admits two rational principles,'self-love'and the 'moral faculty,'the coincidence of which is learned only by experience.The moral faculty reveals simple 'ideas'of right and wrong,which are incapable of any further analysis.

But besides these,there is a hierarchy of other instincts or desires,which he calls 'implanted'because 'for aught we know'they may be of 'arbitrary appointment.'(54)Resentment,for example,is an implanted instinct,of which the 'final cause'is to defend us against 'sudden violence.'(55)Stewart's analysis is easygoing and suggests more problems than it solves.The general position,however,is clear enough,and not,I think,without much real force as against the Paley form of utilitarianism.

同类推荐
  • Mary Stuart

    Mary Stuart

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 四分比丘尼羯磨法

    四分比丘尼羯磨法

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 周易本义

    周易本义

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 衍极

    衍极

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 淇园编

    淇园编

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 我怎么这么难

    我怎么这么难

    “救救我!”“你怎么了?”“有人要杀我!”“是谁?”“是……是我自己!”……当王岩在梦中成功杀掉自己的那一刻开始。融合时代……到来了。这是一个融合的世界,所有的人都通过融合平行世界中的自己获得能力。不过,为什么每一次融合都要被吓的半死?我怎么这么难?
  • 开心学国学(科教卷)

    开心学国学(科教卷)

    本册从科学发明、数学成就、天文历法、农业科技、中医科学、纺织科技、教育科举、古代学校等几个方面入手,详细地阐述了中国的科教知识,多角度地展示了科教的精华,语言简练,通俗易懂,是入门级的科普读物。
  • 仙师惊情

    仙师惊情

    望断天涯觅海角,回首地老顾天荒。不管你是人是仙还是妖,都是我心中所爱。如果你是天地不容,那我就为你与天地为敌。假如爱是一条不归路,就让我陪你走到最后一步。妖魔鬼怪,天打雷劈,就算还剩一口气,也要用这一息之念想着你。
  • 这个婚我不离了

    这个婚我不离了

    唐心家族破产之后,为了不让许庭业有机会找自己离婚,发誓一定要让自己再次挤进白富美的行列中。理想很丰满,现实却很骨感!就在唐心心灰意冷,准备放弃之际,许庭业不淡定了……自强自立女主VS腹黑傲娇男主
  • 人际交往的艺术(畅销珍藏版)

    人际交往的艺术(畅销珍藏版)

    卡耐基说过:“人的成功15%取决于专业知识,而85%取决于人际关系。”可见,人际关系是一个人通往成功之路的门票。只有经营并维护好自己的人际关系资源,才能左右逢源,平步青云。《人际交往的艺术》集合了全球成功人士都在运用的人际交往法则,告诉你与人交往的秘诀,让你拥有良好的交往心态,逐步打通人际交往的穴道,快速拓展你的人际交往圈。这样,你在不知不觉中就会赢得交际的主动权,进而坐拥成功与幸福的人生。否则,你将永远只是孤军奋战,身陷“孤掌难鸣”的尴尬境地。
  • 月夜孤舟:庐隐作品精选

    月夜孤舟:庐隐作品精选

    本书是感悟文学大师经典,本套丛书选文广泛、丰富,且把阅读文学与掌握知识结合起来,既能增进广大读者阅读经典文学的乐趣,又能使我们体悟人生的智慧和生活哲理。本套图书格调高雅,知识丰富,具有极强的可读性、权威性和系统性,非常适合广大读者阅读和收藏,也非常适合各级图书馆装备陈列。
  • 来到综漫搞事情

    来到综漫搞事情

    一场意外事故,王小萌获得了一个系统,只有完成系统给出的任务才能复活?什么!还附带变身!搞没搞错啊!王小萌:那现在我们要去哪儿?系统:刀剑神域,登陆!(PS:不只是一个动漫世界。) 粉丝群:705933463(新群)
  • 无敌萌主绝宠天下

    无敌萌主绝宠天下

    她是玉瓷公主,太子爹早逝,寄人篱下,他是承佑世子,六岁曾随姐姐远赴沙场,少年威名远扬,谁是谁的劫?谁又是谁的惊鸿一瞥?(欢脱版)情节一:她躲在门后偷看他不小心被抓包,她假装擦汗,“今夜的月光好晒呀!”情节二:她大言不惭道,“你第一将军又如何?她第一美人又如何?我还是大盛的第一公主呐!”他闷哼,“我的名气论的是实力,她论的是美貌,而你的第一公主论的是——年纪!”(小虐版)上房揭瓦、独闯御书房、逃离皇宫……她总是小错不断,从来活得热闹,似乎总会惹他不高兴。远赴燕都、独有迟连、误闯贡绣……最后他逼自己喝下最毒的情思媚,她终于心死,“我放手,你解脱。”殊不知他以从所未有的坚定告诉她,“小白,我对你,从未放弃过!”原来,他一直为她挡下一身杀戮,宠她至深。这世上再无一个男子能为她做到如此,她又该如何如何生死相依……
  • 故事会(2015年8月下)

    故事会(2015年8月下)

    《故事会》所说的故事,不仅高雅、高尚,而且贴近老百姓的生活,并能始终以老百姓喜闻乐见的形式表达出来,尤为关键的是,其绝大多数故事,基本上都相当准确地切合着社会审美心理中三个最为关键的部位,即情感性、幽默性、传奇性。因此,尽管我们所处的是一个信息爆炸的资讯时代,或各种各样文化快餐层出不穷的娱乐时代,其所提供的故事仍能从一片喧嚣的声浪中脱颖而出。其二是由《故事会》编辑部所营造的“《故事会》编辑部文化”。
  • 白房子

    白房子

    本书包括:我的心在跳,全世界都能听到;28年前河西走廊刻骨铭心的一幕;我的兵团兄弟;这一次的路途等内容。