登陆注册
5589700000053

第53章 PHILOSOPHY(7)

He really approximates most closely to Hutcheson,who takes a similar view of Utilitarianism,but he professes the warmest admiration of Butler.He explicitly accepts Butler's doctrine of the 'supremacy of the conscience'--a doctrine which as he says,the bishop,'has placed in the strongest and happiest light.'(45)He endeavours,again,to approximate to the 'intellectual school,'of which Richard Price (1723-1791)was the chief English representative at the time.Like Kant,Price deduces the moral law from principles of pure reason.The truth of the moral law.'Thou shalt do to others as you wish that they should do to you,'is as evident as the truth of the law in geometry,'things which are equal to the same thing are equal to each other.'Stewart so far approves that he wishes to give to the moral law what is now called all possible 'objectivity,'while the 'moral sense'of Hutcheson apparently introduced a 'subjective'element.He holds,however,that our moral perceptions 'involve a feeling of the heart,'as well as a 'judgment of the understanding,'(46)and ascribes the same view to Butler.But then,by using the word 'reason'so as to include the whole nature of a rational being,we may ascribe to it the 'origin of those simple ideas which are not excited in the mind by the operation of the senses,but which arise in consequence of the operation of the intellectual powers among the various objects.'(47)Hutcheson,he says,made his 'moral sense'unsatisfactory by taking his illustrations from the 'secondary'instead of the 'primary qualities,'(48)and thus with the help of intuitive first principles,Stewart succeeds in believing that it would be as hard for a man to believe that he ought to sacrifice another man's happiness to his own as to believe that three angles of a triangle are equal to one right angle.(49)It is true that a feeling and a judgment are both involved;but the 'intellectual judgment'is the groundwork of the feeling,not the feeling of the judgment.(50)In spite,however,of this attempt to assimilate his principles to those of the intellectual school,the substance of Stewart's ethics is essentially psychological.It rests,in fact,upon his view that philosophy depends upon inductive psychology,and,therefore,essentially upon experience subject to the cropping up of convenient 'intuitions.'

This appears from the nature of his argument against the Utilitarians.

In his time,this doctrine was associated with the names of Hartley,Tucker,Godwin,and especially Paley.He scarcely refers to Bentham.(51)Paley is the recognised anvil for the opposite school.Now he agrees,as I have said,with Paley's view of natural theology and entirely accepts therefore the theory of 'final causes.'The same theory becomes prominent in his ethical teaching.We may perhaps say that Stewart's view is in substance an inverted Utilitarianism.It may be best illustrated by an argument familiar in another application.Paley and his opponents might agree that the various instincts of an animal are so constituted that in point of fact they contribute to his preservation and his happiness.But from one point of view this appears to be simply to say that the conditions of existence necessitate a certain harmony,and that the harmony is therefore to be a consequence of his self-preservation.

From the opposite point of view,which Stewart accepts,it appears that the self-preservation is the consequence of a pre-established harmony,which has been divinely appointed in order that he may live.Stewart,in short,is a 'teleologist'of the Paley variety.Psychology proves the existence of design in the moral world,as anatomy or physiology proves it in the physical.

Stewart therefore fully agrees that virtue generally produces happiness.

lf it be true (a doctrine,he thinks,beyond our competence to decide)that 'the sole principle of action in the Deity'is benevolence,it may be that he has commanded us to be virtuous because he sees virtue to be useful.In this case utility may be the final cause of morality;and the fact that virtue has this tendency gives the plausibility to utilitarian systems.(52)But the key to the difficulty is the distinction between 'final'and 'efficient'causes;for the efficient cause of morality is not the desire for happiness,but a primitive and simple instinct,namely,the moral faculty.

Thus he rejects Paley's notorious doctrine that virtue differs from prudence only in regarding the consequences in another world instead of consequences in this.(53)Reward and punishment 'presuppose the notions of right and wrong'and cannot be the source of those notions.The favourite doctrine of association,by which the Utilitarians explained unselfishness,is only admissible as accounting for modifications,such as are due to education and example,but 'presupposes the existence of certain principles which are common to all mankind.'The evidence of such principles is established by a long and discursive psychological discussion.It is enough to say that he admits two rational principles,'self-love'and the 'moral faculty,'the coincidence of which is learned only by experience.The moral faculty reveals simple 'ideas'of right and wrong,which are incapable of any further analysis.

But besides these,there is a hierarchy of other instincts or desires,which he calls 'implanted'because 'for aught we know'they may be of 'arbitrary appointment.'(54)Resentment,for example,is an implanted instinct,of which the 'final cause'is to defend us against 'sudden violence.'(55)Stewart's analysis is easygoing and suggests more problems than it solves.The general position,however,is clear enough,and not,I think,without much real force as against the Paley form of utilitarianism.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 豪门残情

    豪门残情

    此文原名为—伤情未婚妻,亲别走错了哈呼呼。。。文名终于给改了,所谓一波三折啊。。。。一入豪门深似海,半只脚跨入豪门,那会苦不堪言!倾心相爱怎么样?父母命,兄弟残,情敌阻,还有路人甲时不时搞乱,有情人也被拆散!一月,她认识了高贵的他,于是相爱,见父母,于是麻烦也渐渐出现,而这一切还只是不咸不淡的开始,真正的痛苦,还在日积月累,越来越大,沉重到她不能承受。。。。。“孩子留下,你走!”未来婆家说,“你脏了,配不上我大哥了,可以滚了!”未来小叔子说,“能够嫁入韩家,嫁给韩勋的就只有我,你不过成了他的生育工具而已,一个两个还是更多,我都乐于接受,因为这是他爱我的表现,他不忍我受生育之苦啊!”嚣张情敌说,三年后,她忘记了一切,身边有了英俊的丈夫,淘气的孩子,她很幸福,可有一天。。。。。。“妈妈,妈妈,外面有个漂亮的叔叔说他是我的爸爸,可我明明有了一个爸爸呀!”小男孩歪着头脑,疑惑道。“可妈妈也就一个老公啊!”美丽的女人同样也疑惑不解,她咬牙,“现在世道混乱,会不会是人贩子啊,儿子,你要小心点!”小男孩连连点头,甩也不甩慈爱的看着他的男人,第二天“儿子儿子,外面有个登徒子,抱着我只亲,他说你是我和他生的,现在仔细看看你,你们是挺像的,可我不记得了呀,唉,头都想晕了!”美丽的女人眼巴巴的看着儿子,苦恼道。“那就不要想啊,老爸说了,你肚子里有小宝宝,你的烦恼多多,他就会笨笨!”小男孩教训女人。女人乖乖的点了点头,第三天美丽的女人和漂亮的儿子躲在房子里,儿子瞪了眼女人,“都是你!”“怎么啦?”女人很无辜的问道。“都是你不让老爸进房间,他生气了就出差了,害得我现在都不能出去玩,外面那个叔叔看见我就抱,你儿子都吓坏了!”“嗯嗯,好可怕......”女人应和。女人和儿子祈祷着老公和老爸快快回来,第四天“老公,你终于回来了,我好想你哦。”美丽的女人奔向风尘仆仆的俊美男人,男人深情索吻。“老爸,再不回来,我和妈就要闷死了!”小男孩抱怨道。男人温和的笑笑,抱起他,宠溺的问:“我的宝贝儿子是怎么了?”“轩,你回来了!”气质非凡的男人走了进来,男人抱着儿子的手僵了僵,扯出了勉强的笑容,“你还是来了啊......”入v亲们就不看文了么,呜,伤心啊。。。。文文后面精彩呢,怎么就没什么亲支持支持呢。。。。
  • 绝命香魂

    绝命香魂

    我们村子旁边有一条阴水河,冬天不结冰,底下葬有无数尸骨,连鱼儿也是冤魂化的。但是那一天,我在船上遇见了一个绝美的女人,她对我做了那种事……
  • 宠冠天下:漓王,来接驾

    宠冠天下:漓王,来接驾

    重生一世,某男变得主动了怎么办?前世她入敌国当奸细,遇见了他;沙场再见,他却为她杀死了自己。本想好好补偿,没想到最后却补偿到被吃抹干净。她是戚叶国隐世家族继承人,他是云辰国皇族皇子。人前,某男清冷高贵;人后,霸道的把她圈在怀里。“风墨漓,我们是敌人关系!”男人凤眸微微眯起,一字一句:“那又如何?你、是、我、的。”【甜宠文,男女双洁。放心入坑,么么哒~】
  • 不朽之路

    不朽之路

    亿万星辰、浩瀚宇宙、无穷生灵,万界之巅所求为何?不朽之路!!
  • 原始之王

    原始之王

    夏穿越到了石器时代。作者:没有系统,没有超能力,你给我建个房子看看。夏眼眸微开:呵呵。作者:没有窑没有煤你烧个砖烧个陶看看。夏眼眸再开:呵呵。作者:没有粮食作物,你建个国家看看。夏眼眸再开:呵呵。作者:鉴于你的态度,你开局连狗都没有了,自己打去吧。夏眼眸大开:那就试试看。
  • 指导学生心理健康的经典故事:帮你揭秘身体奥秘

    指导学生心理健康的经典故事:帮你揭秘身体奥秘

    每个人都在梦想着成功,但每个人心中的成功都不一样,是鲜花和掌声,是众人羡慕的眼神,还是存折上不断累积的财富?其实,无论是哪一种成功,真正需要的都是一种健康的心理。有了健康的心理才是成功的前提与保证,在人的一生中,中学是极其重要的一个阶段,心理健康对以后的健康成长非常重要。
  • 悦读MOOK(第七卷)

    悦读MOOK(第七卷)

    本书将带你走进茫茫书海,我们将请一些学者和专家帮你指津,请一些书界人士为你剖析书坛风云,使你从中获得大量的图书信息,还能饱览各类书籍的精彩片段,一册在手,尽情享受读书的乐趣。
  • 背着将军上战场

    背着将军上战场

    齐国丞相独女常素素,能徒手捉匪、剑斩野兽,性格彪悍。大将军独子虞柏舟却生性文弱,成天捧着一本书,恨不得当只书虫。这两人青梅竹马,虞柏舟被父亲拎上战场,弃文从武,常素素也跟着他女扮男装混进了军营……
  • 青梅竹马:总裁老公的私宠

    青梅竹马:总裁老公的私宠

    一场大火葬送了她的青春,三年的牢狱之灾使得她脱胎换骨,母亲的病逝,父亲正大光明迎娶小三接私生女过门,连她深爱的男人也对她恨之入骨……
  • 上清丹景道精隐地八术经

    上清丹景道精隐地八术经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。