登陆注册
5589700000054

第54章 PHILOSOPHY(8)

The acceptance of the doctrine of 'final causes'was the inevitable course for a philosopher who wishes to retain the old creeds and yet to appeal unequivocally to experience.It suits the amiable optimism for which Stewart is noticeable.

To prove the existence of a perfect deity from the evidence afforded by the world,you must of course take a favourable view of the observable order.

Stewart shows the same tendency in his Political Economy,where he is Adam Smith's disciple,and fully shares Smith's beliefs that the harmony between the interests of the individual and the interests of the society is an evidence of design in the Creator of mankind.In this respect Stewart differs notably from Butler,to whose reasonings he otherwise owed a good deal.With Butler the conscience implies a dread of divine wrath and justifies the conception of a world alienated from its maker.Stewart's 'moral faculty'simply recognises or reveals the moral law;but carries no suggestion of supernatural penalties.

The doctrines by which Butler attracted some readers and revolted others throw no shadow over his writings.He is a placid enlightened professor,whose real good feeling and frequent shrewdness should not be overlooked in consequence of the rather desultory and often superficial mode of reasoning.

This,however,suggests a final remark upon Stewart's position.

In the preface(56)to his Active and Moral Powers (1828)Stewart apologises for the large space given to the treatment of Natural Religion.The lectures,he says,which form the substance of the book,were given at a time when 'enlightened zeal for liberty'was associated with the 'reckless boldness of the uncompromising freethinker.'He wished,therefore,to show that a man could be a liberal without being an atheist.This gives the position characteristic of Stewart and his friends.The group of eminent men who made Edinburgh a philosophical centre was thoroughly in sympathy with the rationalist movement of the eighteenth century.The old dogmatic system of belief could be held very lightly even by the more educated clergy.Hume's position is significant.He could lay down the most unqualified scepticism in his writings;but he always regarded his theories as intended for the enlightened;he had no wish to disturb popular beliefs in theology,and was a strong Tory in politics.His friends were quite ready to take him upon that footing.The politeness with which 'Mr Hume's'speculations are noticed by men like Stewart and Reid is in characteristic contrast to the reception generally accorded to more popular sceptics.They were intellectual curiosities not meant for immediate application.The real opinion of such men as Adam Smith and Stewart was probably a rather vague and optimistic theism.In the professor's chair they could talk to lads intended for the ministry without insulting such old Scottish prejudice (there was a good deal of it)as survived:and could cover rationalising opinions under language which perhaps might have a different meaning for their hearers.The position was necessarily one of tacit compromise.

Stewart considers himself to be an inductive philosopher appealing frankly to experience and reason;and was in practice a man of thoroughly liberal and generous feelings.He was heartily in favour of progress as he understood it.Only he will not sacrifice common sense;that is to say,the beliefs which are in fact prevalent and congenial to existing institutions.Common sense,of course,condemns extremes:and if logic seems to be pushing a man towards scepticism in philosophy or revolution in practice,he can always protest by the convenient device of intuitions.

I have gone so far in order to illustrate the nature of the system which the Utilitarians took to be the antithesis of their own.It may be finally remarked that at present both sides were equally ignorant of contemporary developments of German thought.When Stewart became aware that there was such a thing as Kant's philosophy,he tried to read it in a Latin version.

Parr,I may observe,apparently did not know of this version,and gave up the task of reading German.Stewart's example was not encouraging.He had abandoned the 'undertaking in despair'partly from the scholastic barbarism of the style,partly 'my utter inability to comprehend the author's meaning.'

He recognises similarity between Kant and Reid,but thinks Reid's simple statement of the fact that space cannot be derived from the senses more philosophical than Kant's 'superstructure of technical mystery.'(57)I have dwelt upon the side in which Stewart's philosophy approximates to the empirical school,because the Utilitarians were apt to misconceive the position.They took Stewart to be the adequate representative of all who accepted one branch of an inevitable dilemma.The acceptance of 'intuitions,'that is,was the only alternative to thorough-going acceptance of 'experience.'

They supposed,too,that persons vaguely described as 'Kant and the Germans'taught simply a modification of the 'intuitionist'view.I have noticed how emphatically Stewart claimed to rely upon experience and to base his philosophy upon inductive psychology,and was so far admitting the first principles and the general methods of his opponents.The Scottish philosophy,however,naturally presented itself as an antagonistic force to the Utilitarians.

同类推荐
  • 太上灵宝净明天尊说御强经

    太上灵宝净明天尊说御强经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 为政善报事类

    为政善报事类

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 大乘三聚忏悔经

    大乘三聚忏悔经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 农家

    农家

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 佛说虚空藏菩萨陀罗尼

    佛说虚空藏菩萨陀罗尼

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 人生三境界:淡定从容舍得

    人生三境界:淡定从容舍得

    本书共分为三章节,分别从淡定,从容,舍得三种生活态度出发,都会人们对事要学会从容,对各种遭遇要保持淡定,为人处事要学会舍得之道。书中通过许多富有寓意的故事和事例,深刻详细地了一 种豁达的人生之道。
  • 拖拉机汽车底盘构造与维护

    拖拉机汽车底盘构造与维护

    为深入贯彻《国务院关大力推进职业教育改革与发展的决定》以及教育部等六部委《关实施职业院校制造业和现代服务业技能型紧缺人才培养培训工程的通知》精神,宁夏农业学校积极推进课程改革和教材建设,我校农业机械使用与维护专业建设指导委员会及专业教师按照教育部颁布的《中等职业院校农业机械使用与维护专业领域技能型紧缺人才培养培训指导方案》的要求,编写了本书,以供我校农业机械使用与维护专业实训使用。
  • 床前明月光,美男睡得香

    床前明月光,美男睡得香

    叱咤武林的第一蛊师苗老头为了让女儿苗宝贝有一个忠贞的丈夫,特意研制了一种独情蛊,受蛊者一男一女,若有一方与其他异性有肌肤之亲,将会当场暴毙。不幸被苗老头选上的女婿是武林正派颜家三公子颜玉白,然而这位江湖第一神秘冷酷美男子与从小在苗疆长大并把少儿不宜书当做正规学习教材的苗宝贝,怎么看也不像是能好好做夫妻的一对。
  • 快穿之虐文女主不好当

    快穿之虐文女主不好当

    每当看到虐文的时候,唐沐都觉得自己被虐的心肝肺疼,她不理解,为什么女主非要男主不可,咱们自主独立,一脚踹开男主开开心心的生活不好吗?怀着这样的怨念,唐沐穿越到了一个的虐文里面。
  • Cause to Dread (An Avery Black Mystery—Book 6)

    Cause to Dread (An Avery Black Mystery—Book 6)

    "A dynamic story line that grips from the first chapter and doesn't let go."--Midwest Book Review, Diane Donovan (regarding Once Gone)From #1 bestselling author Blake Pierce comes a new masterpiece of psychological suspense—the AVERY BLACK SERIES—which continues here with CAUSE TO DREAD (Book #6), also a standalone novel. The series begins with CAUSE TO KILL (Book #1)—a free download with over 200 five star reviews!
  • 不可不读的最益智的哲理故事

    不可不读的最益智的哲理故事

    在成长的道路上,最快乐的体验是求知;在探索的过程中,最需要的帮助是引导。希望本书能带领小朋友们在知识的海洋里快乐遨游,让它成为你的良师益友!
  • kiss恶魔坏老公

    kiss恶魔坏老公

    哇啊啊!她要抓狂啦!为什么别人的未婚夫又帅又温柔又正常,为什么她的未婚夫帅是帅了,可是一点也不温柔,更不正常,反而还非常的恶魔!什么厚脸皮的话都说的出口,还喜欢捉弄她……总之她就是不要活啦,为什么她偏偏就摊上了这么一个恶魔老公啊!!!
  • 一髻文殊师利童子陀罗尼念诵仪轨

    一髻文殊师利童子陀罗尼念诵仪轨

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 非常家庭关系

    非常家庭关系

    婆媳是永远说不完的话题,婆媳关系里再加上前妻前孩、同父异母秉性各异的兄弟姐妹,还有剪不断理还乱的各种亲友关系,加上本身人在中年的情感动荡,希望能好看。
  • 苍澜志

    苍澜志

    龙王之位空缺,世界纷争,奇遇,战乱,争夺,神秘的圣境,悠长的长生河,科技的咆哮,国家的灭亡,秩序被混沌碾压,人们正盼望着新的龙王,带来新的希望....