登陆注册
5589700000082

第82章 BENTHAM'S DOCTRINE(4)

Many men fear the loss of character or the 'wrath of Heaven,'but all men fear the scourge and the gallows.(14)He admits,however,that the religious sanction and the additional sanction of 'benevolence'have the advantage of not requiring that the offender should be found out.(15)But in any case,the 'natural'and religious sanctions are beyond the legislator's power.

His problem,therefore,is simply this:what sanctions ought he to annex to conduct,or remembering that 'ought'means simply 'conducive to happiness,'what political sanctions will increase happiness?

To answer this fully will be to give a complete system of legislation;but in order to answer it we require a whole logical and psychological apparatus.

Bentham shows this apparatus at work,but does not expound its origin in any separate treatise.Enough information,however,is given as to his method in the curious collection of the fragments connected with the Chrestomathia.

A logical method upon which he constantly insisted is that of 'bipartition,'(16)called also the 'dichotomous'or 'bifurcate'method,and exemplified by the stalled 'Porphyrian Tree.'The principle is,of course,simple.Take any genus:divide it into two classes,one of which has and the other has not a certain mark.The two classes must be mutually exclusive and together exhaustive.

Repeat the operation upon each of the classes and continue the process as long as desired.(17)At every step you thus have a complete enumeration of all the species,varieties,and so on,each of which excludes all the others.No mere logic,indeed,can secure the accuracy and still less the utility of the procedure.The differences may be in themselves ambiguous or irrelevant.If I classify plants as 'trees'and 'not trees,'the logical form is satisfied:but I have still to ask whether 'tree'conveys a determinate meaning,and whether the distinction corresponds to a difference of any importance.

A perfect classification,however,could always be stated in this form.Each species,that is,can be marked by the presence or absence of a given difference,whether we are dealing with classes of plants or actions:and Bentham aims at that consummation though he admits that centuries may be required for the construction of an accurate classification in ethical speculations.(18)He exaggerates the efficiency of his method,and overlooks the tendency of tacit assumptions to smuggle themselves into what affects to be a mere enumeration of classes.But in any case,no one could labour more industriously to get every object of his thought arranged and labelled and put into the right pigeon-hole of his mental museum.To codify(19)is to classify,and Bentham might be defined as a codifying animal.

Things thus present themselves to Bentham's mind as already prepared to fit into pigeon-holes.This is a characteristic point,and it appears in what we must call his metaphysical system.'Metaphysics,'indeed,according to him,is simply 'a sprig,'and that a small one,of the 'branch termed Logic.'(20)It is merely the explanation of certain general terms such as 'existence,''necessity,'and so forth.(21)Under this would apparently fall the explanation of 'reality'which leads to a doctrine upon which he often insists,and which is most implicitly given in the fragment called Ontology.He there distinguishes 'real'from 'fictitious entities,'a distinction which,as he tells us,(22)he first learned from d'Alembert's phrase êtres fictifs,and which he applies in his Morals and Legislation.'Real entities,'according to him,(23)are 'individual perceptions,''impressions,'and 'ideas.'

In this,of course,he is following Hume,though he applies the Johnsonian argument to Berkeley's immaterialism.(24)A 'fictitious entity'is a name which does not 'raise up in the mind any correspondent images.'(25)Such names owe their existence to the necessities of language.Without employing such fictions,however,'the language of man could not have risen above the language of brutes';(26)and he emphatically distinguishes them from 'unreal'or 'fabulous entities.'A 'fictitious entity'is not a 'nonentity.'(27)He includes among such entities all Aristotle's 'predicaments'except the first:'substance.'(28)Quantity,quality,relation,time,place are all 'physical fictitious entities.'This is apparently equivalent to saying that the only 'physical entities'are concrete things --sticks,stones,bodies,and so forth --the 'reality'of which he takes for granted in the ordinary common-sense meaning.It is also perfectly true that things are really related,have quantity and quality,and are in time and space.But we cannot really conceive the quality or relation apart from the concrete things so qualified and related.We are forced by language to use substantives which in their nature have only the sense of adjectives.He does not suppose that a body is not really square or round;but he thinks it a fiction to speak of squareness or roundness or space in general as something existing apart from matter and,in some sense,alongside of matter.

This doctrine,which brings us within sight of metaphysical problems beyond our immediate purpose,becomes important to his moral speculation.His special example of a 'fictitious entity'in politics is 'obligation.'(29)Obligations,rights,and similar words are 'fictitious entities.'Obligation in particular implies a metaphor.The statement that a man is 'obliged'to perform an act means simply that he will suffer pain if he does not perform it.The use of the word obligation,as a noun substantive,introduces the 'fictitious entity'which represents nothing really separable from the pain or pleasure.

同类推荐
  • 佛说栴檀香身陀罗尼经

    佛说栴檀香身陀罗尼经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 佛说须赖经

    佛说须赖经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • WASHINGTON SQUARE

    WASHINGTON SQUARE

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 王常宗集

    王常宗集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 赤松子中诫经

    赤松子中诫经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 霸道逆天

    霸道逆天

    一个背负了沉重仇恨的行者,却是千古第一的龙凤神魔体,他的命运,即使上天都无法注定。一次次地和地狱擦肩,一次次地与天命为敌,最后的胜者者才是天命所归。海枯石烂的儿女情长,霸气外漏的修炼之旅,书写成不朽的逆天传说。
  • 都市之邪火凤凰

    都市之邪火凤凰

    翻手为云,覆手为雨,绝世阴谋,商场沉浮,你,我还不放在眼里。曲高和寡,无敌是多么寂寞…… 人世间沉浮,洗去浮华功名碌,终了一生得唏嘘,与你三生有幸,小生我爱上你了…… 世界有两种,一为世俗,二为云外,宇宙的外面到底是何物,火星上是否有生命?古代中国的传奇传说,嫦娥仙子去了何处?这一切是否能够得到解释呢? 敬请关注落风人作品…… 欢迎加入邂逅仙君,群聊号码:695266504
  • 断桥妙伦禅师语录

    断桥妙伦禅师语录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 黄帝内经养生原理与应用

    黄帝内经养生原理与应用

    中国特色的养生,深深植根于中国传统文化之中,其内容博大精深,古今著述繁多,但完整遵从《黄帝内经》知识体系之作罕见。笔者忠于《内经》的本意,梳理、构建、还原其养生理论,用现代语言构建《原理篇》和《实践篇》,为大众养生提供原理与实践指导。 全书立意在于唤醒世人:现代医学“消灭疾病结果”的思路和把人体当“战场”的野蛮疗法,正在残酷考验人体自身的五行平衡能力。
  • 帝少万安夫人重生了

    帝少万安夫人重生了

    一生平平淡淡的安玖玖竟、然、重、生、了?!玖玖表示“我也很蒙逼,难道是自己人品大爆发了吗?”事实证明并没有,只是以彗星撞地球的几率让玖玖继承了某仙人的空间而已。原本玖玖以为自己会种田发家致富,不想这空间的功能牛逼哄哄,玖玖本想凭着自己的努力走上人生巅峰,不想捡了一个牛掰的师傅不够,又撩了一位腹黑少爷。这是一个女孩子成长为女王的过程。夺得各种奖项,之后宠宠宠超级宠的故事。(1v1,盛世甜宠,女强,男更强的故事,女主可能会心软,但绝不白莲,绝不白莲,绝不白莲。)
  • 星际豪门:外星男神vs超能甜心

    星际豪门:外星男神vs超能甜心

    她,奢靡与美丽汇聚一身的顶级豪门大小姐,男人为之痴狂,女人为之羡嫉的绝世妖物,却有着不为人知的超能惊天秘密。三岁,她的哭声引起火灾。七岁,她和表姐抢东西,能力暴走差点误伤表姐。十二岁误烧家中大别墅。这样的她却和异星的他,有着某种联系……他,全柯特星的皇位继承人,俊美绝伦,冷酷倨傲,是全柯特星的男神,未来的星之帝王。为了寻找遗失在地球的宇宙水晶,而再来地球。却碰上这个火辣刁蛮,且一次次让他无语的名媛大小姐……女人!等我拿到了宇宙水晶,一定把你绑回星球!让你知道我是谁!(本书持续更新中,如果遇到显示完结,或者无法看书,以及其他错误,请将书从书架删除收藏,清除阅读痕迹,重新搜索书名,再继续阅读)
  • 爱情到处流传

    爱情到处流传

    “母亲”和“四婶子”围绕“父亲”有了一场较量,这场较量,表面不动声色,暗里波涛汹涌,这是一种太沉重的平和,作为悲哀的胜利者,“母亲”耗尽一生的力气。“父亲”的文化和“四婶子”的风姿是很协调的,是很靠谱的一种互相吸引。“母亲”“危”中不用费尽心思寻“机”,需要做的只是在游离着的爱情逼迫自己时告知:我们都是被绑缚的女人,女人何苦为难女人。“母亲”和“四婶子”都是刚强,隐忍的,“母亲”继续苦心经营着这份爱情,“四婶子”用终生逃离的方式也在远远守卫着自己的爱情。
  • 语文新课标课外必读第十一辑:冒险追踪记

    语文新课标课外必读第十一辑:冒险追踪记

    国家教育部颁布了最新《语文课程标准》,统称新课标,对中、小学语文教学指定了阅读书目,对阅读的数量、内容、质量以及速度都提出了明确的要求,这对于提高学生的阅读能力,培养语文素养,陶冶情操,促进学生终身学习和终身可持续发展,对于提高广大人民的文学素养具有极大的意义。
  • 双影无暇

    双影无暇

    江湖各有所学,剑若惊鸿?刀法无双?轻功独步?内力纯厚?没关系,我是隔壁玄幻来的!
  • 感悟·感动(自然卷)

    感悟·感动(自然卷)

    《感悟·感动(自然卷)》告诉你,大自然中,存在太多令人类自叹不如的可爱生灵,在它们面前,人类除了被震撼、被感动,还有触及灵魂的感悟和反省。