登陆注册
5589700000081

第81章 BENTHAM'S DOCTRINE(3)

Science,according to him,must rest upon facts.It must apply to real things,and to things which have definite relations and a common measure.Now,if anything be real,pains and pleasures are real.The expectation of pain or pleasure determines conduct;and,if so,it must be the sole determinant of conduct.The attempt to conceal or evade this truth is the fatal source of all equivocation and confusion.Try the experiment.Introduce a 'moral sense.'What is its relation to the desire for happiness?If the dictates of the moral sense be treated as ultimate,an absolutely arbitrary element is introduced;and we have One of the 'innate ideas'exploded by Locke,a belief summarily intruded into the system without definite relations to any other beliefs:a dogmatic assertion which refuses to be tested or to be correlated with other dogmas;a reduction therefore of the whole system to chaos.It is at best an instinctive belief which requires to be justified and corrected by reference to some other criterion.Or resolve morality into 'reason,'that is,into some purely logical truth,and it then remains in the air --a mere nonentity until experience has supplied some material upon which it can work.Deny the principle of utility,in short,as he says in a vigorous passage,(10)and you are involved in a hopeless circle.Sooner or later you appeal to an arbitrary and despotic principle and find that you have substituted words for thoughts.

The only escape from this circle is the frank admission that happiness is,in fact,the sole aim of man.There are,of course,different kinds of happiness as there are different kinds of physical forces.But the motives to action are,like the physical forces,commensurable.Two courses of conduct can always be compared in respect of the happiness produced,as two motions of a body can be compared in respect of the energy expended.If,then,we take the moral judgment to be simply a judgment of amounts of happiness,the whole theory can be systematised,and its various theorems ranged under a single axiom or consistent set of axioms.Pain and pleasure give the real value of actions;they are the currency with a definite standard into which every general rule may be translated.There is always a common measure applicable in every formula for the estimation of conduct.If you admit your Moral Sense,you profess to settle values by some standard which has no definite relation to the standard which in fact governs the normal transactions.But any such double standard,in which the two measures are absolutely incommensurable,leads straight to chaos.Or,if again you appeal to reason in the abstract,you are attempting to settle an account by pure arithmetic without reference to the units upon which your operation is performed.Two pounds and two pounds will make four pounds whatever a pound may be;but till I know what it is,the result is nugatory.Somewhere I must come upon a basis of fact,if my whole construction is to stand.

This is the fundamental position implied in Bentham's doctrine.The moral judgment is simply one case of the judgment of happiness.Bentham is so much convinced of this that to him there appeared to be in reality no other theory.

What passed for theories were mere combinations of words.Having said this,we know where to lay the foundations of the new science.It deals with a vast complicity of facts:it requires 'investigations as severe as mathematical ones,but beyond all comparison more intricate and extensive.'(11)Still it deals with facts,and with facts which have a common measure,and can,therefore,be presented as a coherent system.To present this system,or so much of it as is required for purposes of legislation,is therefore his next task.The partial execution is the chief substance of the Introduction.

Right and wrong conduct,we may now take for granted,mean simply those classes of conduct which are conducive to or opposed to happiness;or,in the sacred formula,to act rightly means to promote the greatest happiness of the greatest number.The legislator,like every one else,acts rightly in so far is he is guided by the principle (to use one of the phrases joined by Bentham)of 'maximising'happiness.He seeks to affect conduct;and conduct can be affected only by annexing pains or pleasures to given classes of actions.

Hence we have a vitally important part of his doctrine --the theory of 'sanctions.'

Pains and pleasures as annexed to action are called 'sanctions.'There are 'physical or natural,''political,''moral or popular,'and 'religious'sanctions.

The 'physical'sanctions are such pleasures and pains as follow a given course of conduct independently of the interference of any other human or supernatural being;the 'political'those which are annexed by the action of the legislator.

The 'moral or popular'those which are annexed by other individuals not acting in a corporate capacity;and the 'religious'those which are annexed by a 'superior invisible being,'or,as he says elsewhere,(12)'such as are capable of being expected at the lands of an invisible Ruler of the Universe.'the three last sanctions,he remarks,'operate through the first.'The 'magistrate'or 'men at large'can only operate,and God is supposed only to operate,'through the powers of nature,'that is,by applying some of the pains and pleasures which may also be natural sanctions.A man is burnt:if by his own imprudence,that is a 'physical'sanction;if by the magistrate,it is a 'political'sanction;if by some neglect of his neighbours,due to their dislike of his 'moral character,'a 'moral'sanction;if by the immediate act of God or by distraction caused by dread of God's displeasure,it is a 'religious'sanction.Of these,as Bentham characteristically observes(13)in later writing the political is much stronger than the 'moral'or 'religious.'

同类推荐
  • 唐摭言

    唐摭言

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 天一悦禅师语录

    天一悦禅师语录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 佛说大普贤陀罗尼经

    佛说大普贤陀罗尼经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 四教义

    四教义

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 尊瓠室诗话

    尊瓠室诗话

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 毒药

    毒药

    西默农笔下的人物很多都被写死了,其中极少数是寿终正寝。在所有的死亡方式中,中毒是他描写得最精彩的一种。《星期天》的悲剧发生在戛纳海滨,旅馆老板忍无可忍,萌生用自己的拿手菜毒死妻子的念头。在《铁楼梯》中,砒霜再度成为秘密武器。主人公饱受胃痛折磨,越来越怀疑他深爱的妻子可能正在故伎重施……在第三部小说《麦格雷不择手段》中,麦格雷当机立断,迅速弄清事情真相。
  • 幻宗

    幻宗

    一个骄横嚣张,从少爷沦落为乞丐的少年。一只获得异能,快如闪电的左手。一把神石所铸,出鞘便寒气奔涌的奇异宝刀。一只来历不明,戴在手上便力道千均的神秘手套。一头日进斗金,速度如风的毛驴。一个蕴藏秘密,等待被层层揭开的深山岩洞。一种凌驾法术,参破造物法门的幻术。这一切如何演绎?打开《幻宗》的卷章吧……
  • 查理九世之蝴蝶吻

    查理九世之蝴蝶吻

    【私设如山】【预警:唐晓翼ooc,人物严重崩坏】【谢绝谈人生、考据党,爽文,女票男人就完事儿了。】*建议BGM:一笑倾城-汪苏泷-“如果要用一个词形容我第一次见到你时的心情,那肯定是——‘一见钟情’。”“?你拿错剧本了?”-一篇非常正经的恶役女配逆袭上位(bushi)的同人文。一部非常正经的拉郎配组cp的红娘奋斗史。当然主要出发点还是苏爽文。
  • 符元战尊

    符元战尊

    符咒之术震裂天地,符战体镇压万古苍穹,熔炼己身,凌登绝顶尊位,俯视天下。
  • 武道小医仙

    武道小医仙

    少年夏天自古武界而来,初入世俗界寻找自己的大师姐宋语嫣,凭借一身的古武绝学和妙手回春的绝世医术,在世俗界掀起了血雨腥风。年仅十八岁的他,不喜欢小萝莉,却是一个御姐控。一路走来,步步杀机,魑魅魍魉,妖魔鬼怪,通通被他踩在脚下。
  • 重生之城市修仙

    重生之城市修仙

    在这浩瀚的都市,金钱,权利,皆为浮云,唯有至强实力,方可掌控一切,制霸天下!
  • 罗马全面战争之异世帝国

    罗马全面战争之异世帝国

    生活本就艰难,小说何必复杂。这是一个剑与魔法的异世大陆,也是一个任白峰驰骋纵横的崭新世界。到底是这个世界的势力更胜一筹呢?还是执掌罗马系统的白峰称霸世界呢?世界难免尔虞我诈,但兄弟情义和红颜知己又怎么会少呢?不是所有的家族都充满明争暗斗,也不是所有的家人都是冷漠相向,世界终有其充满阳光的一面。纵然战争无情、上苍冷酷,白峰依旧有家人相伴红颜相陪;当黑色的百战雄狮遍布世界之时,属于罗马的时代才刚刚降临而已!
  • 天命欧皇游诸天

    天命欧皇游诸天

    天命在己,气运无敌。因为自己不断膨胀的运气而最终离开了原本世界的男人,却也得(de)益(zui)于(le)运气,第一个穿越的世界便危机四伏!“这里全是杀手!”“我运气好!”“这里到处都是想毁灭世界的疯子!”“我运气好!”这是一个运气冲天的男人,裸奔到处浪,丝血也超神的故事。(PS:全是综合世界。)(第一个世界:杀手特工电影混合:王牌特工,极速追杀,暗杀教室,007,通缉令...(已经完结))(第二个世界,综武世界:笑傲,绝代,陆小凤,天下第一,三少爷的剑...(正在进行中))Q群:829232595欢迎大家来灌水,提意见!
  • 默默于心

    默默于心

    日子一天一天就这样过去那些荒诞的时光都已经忘记想起那些慢慢变得陌生的朋友一回头青春都喂了狗喝醉的时候我又想起你想起陪你度过的每一个夜晚你走的时候我都没有留你选择和谁一起度过余生是你的权利
  • 我年轻时候的女朋友

    我年轻时候的女朋友

    这是一场疯狂而离奇的情感之旅,小饭以“背叛”的视角审视他的初恋时光,残忍地将美好的爱情和友情一一打碎——他遭受了爱情和友情的双重背叛……看似平淡无奇的开始,结尾却如此出人意料。