登陆注册
5419400000179

第179章

This arrangement of means and ends is entirely foreign to the things existing in the world- it belongs to them merely as a contingent attribute; in other words, the nature of different things could not of itself, whatever means were employed, harmoniously tend towards certain purposes, were they not chosen and directed for these purposes by a rational and disposing principle, in accordance with certain fundamental ideas.3.There exists, therefore, a sublime and wise cause (or several), which is not merely a blind, all-powerful nature, producing the beings and events which fill the world in unconscious fecundity, but a free and intelligent cause of the world.4.The unity of this cause may be inferred from the unity of the reciprocal relation existing between the parts of the world, as portions of an artistic edifice- an inference which all our observation favours, and all principles of analogy support.

In the above argument, it is inferred from the analogy of certain products of nature with those of human art, when it compels Nature to bend herself to its purposes, as in the case of a house, a ship, or a watch, that the same kind of causality- namely, understanding and will- resides in nature.It is also declared that the internal possibility of this freely-acting nature (which is the source of all art, and perhaps also of human reason) is derivable from another and superhuman art- a conclusion which would perhaps be found incapable of standing the test of subtle transcendental criticism.But to neither of these opinions shall we at present object.We shall only remark that it must be confessed that, if we are to discuss the subject of cause at all, we cannot proceed more securely than with the guidance of the analogy subsisting between nature and such products of design- these being the only products whose causes and modes of organization are completely known to us.Reason would be unable to satisfy her own requirements, if she passed from a causality which she does know, to obscure and indemonstrable principles of explanation which she does not know.

According to the physico-theological argument, the connection and harmony existing in the world evidence the contingency of the form merely, but not of the matter, that is, of the substance of the world.

To establish the truth of the latter opinion, it would be necessary to prove that all things would be in themselves incapable of this harmony and order, unless they were, even as regards their substance, the product of a supreme wisdom.But this would require very different grounds of proof from those presented by the analogy with human art.

This proof can at most, therefore, demonstrate the existence of an architect of the world, whose efforts are limited by the capabilities of the material with which he works, but not of a creator of the world, to whom all things are subject.Thus this argument is utterly insufficient for the task before us- a demonstration of the existence of an all-sufficient being.If we wish to prove the contingency of matter, we must have recourse to a transcendental argument, which the physicotheological was constructed expressly to avoid.

We infer, from the order and design visible in the universe, as a disposition of a thoroughly contingent character, the existence of a cause proportionate thereto.The conception of this cause must contain certain determinate qualities, and it must therefore be regarded as the conception of a being which possesses all power, wisdom, and so on, in one word, all perfection- the conception, that is, of an all-sufficient being.For the predicates of very great, astonishing, or immeasurable power and excellence, give us no determinate conception of the thing, nor do they inform us what the thing may be in itself.They merely indicate the relation existing between the magnitude of the object and the observer, who compares it with himself and with his own power of comprehension, and are mere expressions of praise and reverence, by which the object is either magnified, or the observing subject depreciated in relation to the object.Where we have to do with the magnitude (of the perfection) of a thing, we can discover no determinate conception, except that which comprehends all possible perfection or completeness, and it is only the total (omnitudo) of reality which is completely determined in and through its conception alone.

Now it cannot be expected that any one will be bold enough to declare that he has a perfect insight into the relation which the magnitude of the world he contemplates bears (in its extent as well as in its content) to omnipotence, into that of the order and design in the world to the highest wisdom, and that of the unity of the world to the absolute unity of a Supreme Being.Physico-theology is therefore incapable of presenting a determinate conception of a supreme cause of the world, and is therefore insufficient as a principle of theology- a theology which is itself to be the basis of religion.

The attainment of absolute totality is completely impossible on the path of empiricism.And yet this is the path pursued in the physicotheological argument.What means shall we employ to bridge the abyss?

After elevating ourselves to admiration of the magnitude of the power, wisdom, and other attributes of the author of the world, and finding we can advance no further, we leave the argument on empirical grounds, and proceed to infer the contingency of the world from the order and conformity to aims that are observable in it.

同类推荐
  • 谷音

    谷音

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 守护国界主陀罗尼经

    守护国界主陀罗尼经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 妙法莲华经

    妙法莲华经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 河南志

    河南志

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 唐虞门·再吟

    唐虞门·再吟

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 妖孽王妃二嫁帝王家:绝代宠妃

    妖孽王妃二嫁帝王家:绝代宠妃

    “那一日,你掀起了我的盖头,却非我的夫君;那一夜,我将自己奉献于你,却非你的贤妻。”她是世人眼中的妖孽,身为王妃,却与当朝皇帝发生不伦之恋!流浪江湖,她陷入了前朝太子之子的爱恋。皇帝、王爷、前朝太子之子,三个男人,她又该如何面对?宫廷争斗,婆媳大战,阴谋密布。“谁说红颜祸水,我偏要助你成为万世明君!谁说君王薄幸,你却用江山定情!”以情书史,以史诉情,讲述一代宠妃的情感之路,再现一位伟大君主的成长历程。
  • 重生之月龙

    重生之月龙

    少年含恨重生,几番周折穿梭于各界之中,只有无尽的冷酷与孤独。敌人的强大超乎想象,过去与现在,危机并存,少年并不是救世主,因为少年重生后的最初目的便是毁灭世界。
  • 我只知道人是什么

    我只知道人是什么

    “文学包罗万象,但最重要的是什么?就是人。”《我只知道人是什么》是著名作家余华亲自编选的一本最新杂文集。本书正是他近年来所发表的杂文结集,余华充满睿智又真诚地分享了他的观察和思考,内容包罗万象,从往事到现实,从自我到时代,既漫谈生活体验,也谈及创作心得,他生动回忆了他和福贵、许三观等笔下人物的相遇,也讲述了走访世界时和勇敢的波兰农民、意大利精神病院病友的相遇……有时候他们千千万万,有时候他们就像是同一个人。这些对人性宽广与丰富的探究,展现出一位优秀作家对生活的深刻洞察,而命运无常中凝练出的一个个故事,不仅连接着我们的过去与未来,也最终指向了所有文学和艺术创作中最根本的力量来源。
  • 综合征ABC

    综合征ABC

    本书较全面地收集和描述各类综合症的临床表现、特征、治疗原则以及首次描述时间,通过首字母顺序及系统分类两种方式进行检索,可作为临床工作者解决疑难杂症的工具书。本书内容全面,检索方式多样,查找方便。
  • 神秘殿下:丫头别想逃

    神秘殿下:丫头别想逃

    为了拿回失去的东西,她来到众神学院,第一天,便以彪悍的实力让所有人不敢小瞧。命定的守护者,个个极品,让人眼红,羡慕嫉妒。
  • 应许何年

    应许何年

    纵芳华正茂,然应许何年?三个月后,杜清怡蓬头垢面,衣衫褴褛地走出了那暗无天日的大牢。明媚的阳光晃得她有些睁不开眼,闭了许久,才从一阵锣鼓喧天中缓缓睁开。在拥挤热闹的人群与喜庆的唢呐声中,一支排场而隆重的迎亲队伍很有气势地从此经过,她一眼便看到了那骑在枣红色高头大马上,身着喜服的苏静深。曾经的海誓山盟,曾经的深情不移,曾经的温柔以待,在此刻像一把尖利的锥子一般,狠狠地刺痛了她的心……但,如果真的可以让她再做一次选择,她仍然会义无返顾地选择离开他。尽管,她爱他如命。
  • 魏武霸业

    魏武霸业

    三国似乎是最受穿越大军青睐的地方,大唐也已经人满为患,这一次我们不穿三国,不去唐朝,去一个还没有被穿越者嚯嚯的南北朝。大学生方文涛因为一次意外,他遇上了时空乱流,认识了一个来自未来的系统,系统会化形,会撒娇会卖萌,就是有点不太中用……也有幸或者不幸穿越成为了北魏太武帝拓跋焘。这只小蝴蝶的到来把原本的历史搅得一团糟,完全脱离了轨道。“程咬金,你赶快回来别出去丢人,你那个斧子第四下连只鸡都砍不死”“二营长呢?把你的意大利炮给我拉过来”一个略显呆萌的系统,一个掌握现代科技的大学生皇帝,飞机,航母,坦克,只有你们想不到,没有主角造不出,且看他如何带着自己的娇美未婚妻和呆萌系统一统天下,创立霸业。
  • 人生要耐得住寂寞

    人生要耐得住寂寞

    成功非一蹴而就,高尔基曾说过“凡事皆有终结,因此,耐心是赢得成功的一种手段。”爱情亦如此,宁缺毋滥。我选择用一生独自等待,我的成功……我的爱……
  • 后红楼梦

    后红楼梦

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 最后的江湖之十涯

    最后的江湖之十涯

    解武书院的南江子如何一步步成为替代那个喜穿白衣的西门先生成为面容冷峻的剑榜第一十涯?十涯与皇帝又如何成为挚友?凝气成形如何出现于江湖又被他亲手断送?可供天下江湖中人聚气永生,一世似仙的机缘又为何因他而消失于江湖之中?欲望?自由?归宿?爱?恨?执念?面对这些时,人究竟该怎么做?欢迎阅读最后的江湖之十涯。奈何桥上人奈何?忘忆汤来人易忘。天上地下枯骨多,喜来悲去总遗憾。