登陆注册
5589700000096

第96章 BENTHAM'S DOCTRINE(18)

Therefore it implies that all authority is bad;the authority,for example,of parent over child,or of husband over wife;and moreover,that all laws to the contrary are ipso facto void.That is why it is 'anarchical.'It supposes a 'natural right,'not only as suggesting reasons for proposed alterations of the legal right,but as actually annihilating the right and therefore destroying all government.'Natural rights,'says Bentham,(98)is simple nonsense;natural and impreible rights 'rhetorical nonsense --nonsense upon stilts.'For 'natural right'substitute utility,and you have,of course,a reasonable principle,because an appeal to experience.But lay down 'liberty'as an absolute right and you annihilate law,for every law supposes coercion.

One man gets liberty simply by restricting the liberty of others.(99)What Bentham substantially says,therefore,is that on this version absolute rights of individuals could mean nothing but anarchy;or that no law can be defended except by a reference to facts,and therefore to 'utility.'

One answer might be that the demand is not for absolute liberty,but for as much liberty as is compatible with equal liberty for all.The fourth article of the Declaration says:'Liberty consists in being able to do that which is not hurtful to another,and therefore the exercise of the natural rights of each man has no other bounds than those which ensure to the other members of the society the enjoyment of the same rights.'This formula corresponds to a theory held by Mr Herbert Spencer;and,as he observes,(100)held on different grounds by Kant.Bentham's view,indicated by his criticism of this article in the 'Anarchical Fallacies,'is therefore worth a moment's notice.The formula does not demand the absolute freedom which would condemn all coercion and all government;but it still seems to suggest that liberty,not utility,is the ultimate end.Bentham's formula,therefore,diverges.

All government,he holds,is an evil,because coercion implies pain.We must therefore minimise,though we cannot annihilate,government;but we must keep to utility as the sole test.Government should,of course,give to the individual all such rights as are 'useful';but it does not follow,without a reference to utility,that men should not be restrained even in 'self-regarding'conduct.Some men,women,and children require to be protected against the consequences of their own 'weakness,ignorance,or imprudence.'(101)Bentham adheres,that is,to the strictly empirical ground.The absolute doctrine requires to be qualified by a reference to actual circumstances:and,among those circumstances,as Bentham intimates,we must include the capacity of the persons concerned to govern themselves.Carried out as an absolute principle,it would imply the independence of infants;and must therefore require some reference to 'utility.'

Bentham,then,objects to the Jacobin theory as too absolute and too 'individualist.'

The doctrine begs the question;it takes for granted what can only be proved by experience;and therefore lays down as absolute theories which are only true under certain conditions or with reference to the special circumstances to which they are applied.That is inconsistent with Bentham's thoroughgoing empiricism.But he had antagonists to meet upon the other side:and,in meeting them,he was led to a doctrine which has been generally condemned for the very same faults --as absolute and individualist.We have only to ask in what sense Bentham appealed to 'experience'to see how he actually reached his conclusions.The adherents of the old tradition appealed to experience in their own way.The English people,they said,is the freest,richest,happiest in the world;it has grown up under the British Constitution:therefore the British Constitution is the best in the world,as Burke tells you,and the British common law,as Blackstone tells you,is the 'perfection of wisdom.'

Bentham's reply was virtually that although he,like Burke,appealed to experience,he appealed to experience scientifically organised,whereas Burke appealed to mere blind tradition.Bentham is to be the founder of a new science,founded like chemistry on experiment,and his methods are to be as superior to those of Burke as those of modern chemists to those of the alchemists who also invoked experience.The true plan was not to throw experience aside because it was alleged by the ignorant and the prejudiced,but to interrogate experience systematically,and so to become the Bacon or the Newton of legislation,instead of wandering off into the a priori constructions of a Descartes or a Leibniz.

Bentham thus professes to use an 'inductive'instead of the deductive method of the Jacobins;but reaches the same practical conclusions from the other end.The process is instructive.He objected to the existing inequalities,not as inequalities simply,but as mischievous inequalities.He,as well as the Jacobins,would admit that inequality required justification;and he agreed with them that,in this case,there was no justification.The existing privileges did not promote the 'greatest happiness of the greatest number.'

The attack upon the 'Anarchical Fallacies'must be taken with the Book of Fallacies,and the Book of Fallacies is a sustained and vigorous,though a curiously cumbrous,assault upon the Conservative arguments.Its pith may be found in Sydney Smith's Noodle's Oration;but it is itself well worth reading by any one who can recognise really admirable dialectical power,and forgive a little crabbedness of style in consideration of genuine intellectual vigour.I only notice Bentham's assault upon the 'wisdom of our ancestors.'

同类推荐
  • 三因极一病证方论

    三因极一病证方论

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • The Life and Perambulations of a Mouse

    The Life and Perambulations of a Mouse

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 南史演义

    南史演义

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 巢林笔谈

    巢林笔谈

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 虚舟省禅师语录

    虚舟省禅师语录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 轻轻松松降血脂

    轻轻松松降血脂

    本书在介绍高脂血症基本知识的基础上,着重从饮食、运动及生活方式等方面详细介绍了高脂血症患者的降血脂方法,同时还介绍了一些常用的降血脂食疗方,让大家做到轻轻松松降血脂。本书内容全面丰富,可供广大患者和基层医护人员阅读参考。
  • 重生之巨星暖妻不复婚

    重生之巨星暖妻不复婚

    一觉醒来,她从名媛千金继承人变成了已婚贵妇,接下来还得变成豪门弃妇。秋浅夏觉得自己应该算是所有经历穿越人中最不幸一位,因为别人是穿越,她是被穿越。身体却被所谓的穿越女占用三年,让其用尽心机成为白富美,嫁给高富帅,走上了人生巅峰。可穿越女没有如书上幸福美满大结局,偏偏作的一手好死,游走于向往已久的娱乐圈里,却臭名昭著,最后苦肉计使用过度,身为原主的她又回来了。却发现等待她的是:一个因‘她’变本加厉假怀孕而忍无可忍要离婚的男人,娱乐圈一堆被‘她’的自以为是而得罪的乱摊子,身在异乡没有一个可以信任的人。在以为没有比这个更乱的时候,雪上加霜的发现肚子里还有一个‘后患’!片段一“如果我说,从此以后不会在打扰你工作,不会再任性,不会歇斯底里,走在路上也不会和你打招呼,不会让你进入我的生活……我的所有一切都将与你无关。”秋浅夏看着同为苦主却毫不知情的男人。男人轻轻的瞥了她一眼。“这样的话,你还要离婚吗?”她眨眨眼睛,眸底升起浅浅的水雾,楚楚动人中带着一眼能教人看穿的虚伪和做作。果然……“我会加一条离婚协议,不管发生什么,都没人会去打扰你,签字吧!”男人的厌恶压抑在眼底。虽然有些抱歉了,不过她要的就是这句话!片段二“我们来商量一下婚期吧!”高冷前夫抓准时机十分狂拽的道。“什……么婚期?”某女傻眼。“复婚的日期?”“那个,要慎重啊,要知道你可是刚刚跳出我这个火坑不久,可不能栽倒的那么快。”某人在高冷前夫的阴测测视线下,努力说道。“反正迟早都要跳的。”某前夫一副恩赐的嘴脸让某人手痒的想拍上去。“那个……我觉得我们不合适,当然主要是我配不上你。”“没错。”很不客气的自恋,“我屈尊降贵配得上你就行了。”“……”关键她不稀罕好吧。【本文一对一,女主被人穿越,男女主都是豪门,专情、幸福、无虐。】
  • 毒妃倾天

    毒妃倾天

    全能佣兵女王魂穿废材花痴,医毒双休,天赋禀异,庶姐、后母统统虐死。杀手王爷百般刁难,某王妃:“不好好表现,照样休了你!”【情节虚构,请勿模仿】
  • 异能狂妻:美夫难追

    异能狂妻:美夫难追

    莫名其妙被一个牛皮糖一样的家伙黏上怎么办?扇槿看着尾随其后的某男,万分头疼。“能甩就甩,甩不了就跑呗。”顶着与扇槿一模一样的冰莲悠悠的往嘴里扔了一颗葡萄。“好吃好喝,把他吃穷了就踢走。”秦式眨了眨他漂亮的丹凤眼,朝扇槿抛了个媚眼。“打一顿扔青楼里去。”阿黑立刻支招。可关键问题是,他没有那么好甩的啊!扇槿泪奔……【情节虚构,请勿模仿】
  • 一念焚天

    一念焚天

    弹指间仙神寂灭,生死间岁月轮回。天地容万物,乾坤纳虚无。游尽人间多少客,赤血云霄仍少年!
  • 制度制约下的上市公司高管变更的研究:基于中国上市公司的经验数据

    制度制约下的上市公司高管变更的研究:基于中国上市公司的经验数据

    自从21世纪中国加入WTO以来,中国的经济形势和制度环境发生翻天覆地的变化。作为一系列契约集合体的上市公司在我国的经济当中所具有的影响力日趋变大。上市公司高管作为公司治理的主要参与者,在此当中发挥着重要的作用,这会直接影响公司治理的效果,进而影响公司所处的行业的发展。
  • 无妄轮回志

    无妄轮回志

    车祸后醒来,李鹤发现自己到了一个奇怪的大厅。在这里可以进入各种任务世界里赚取积分。获得积分后又能换成现金返回现实潇洒。于是李鹤开始了不一样的人生:在暗黑平原里获得无限法力的魔法书;在无主之地里研究出法力充能获取大量积分;在英雄城堡前升级了魔法书获得万物进阶的能力;在丧尸狂潮里用聚能镭射枪和粒子功能炮打“号称”头不爆就不死的丧尸;在古代战争里用简易遥控微型运载导弹和小范围毁灭高浓缩热压弹头打“号称”过万不可敌的骑射手。在现实世界里空手接子弹。……用科技碾压武力,又用武力碾压科技。究竟是科技说了算还是武力说了算?李鹤:我说了算。----------书友1群:********(爆满)书友2群:*********(爆爆满)书友3群:**********(爆爆爆满)书友999群:732124243(大量空位)【看简介就知道这是老水哔了】
  • 药房樵唱

    药房樵唱

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 大汉王朝2

    大汉王朝2

    这个帝国人文灿烂,科技发达。它发明了纸,积累了一些基本的化学知识,完成了农具与兵器的铁器化。中国古代传统的医、农、天、算四大学科,均在这个帝国时代形成了自己独特的体系。
  • 宋景文公笔记

    宋景文公笔记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。