登陆注册
5589700000096

第96章 BENTHAM'S DOCTRINE(18)

Therefore it implies that all authority is bad;the authority,for example,of parent over child,or of husband over wife;and moreover,that all laws to the contrary are ipso facto void.That is why it is 'anarchical.'It supposes a 'natural right,'not only as suggesting reasons for proposed alterations of the legal right,but as actually annihilating the right and therefore destroying all government.'Natural rights,'says Bentham,(98)is simple nonsense;natural and impreible rights 'rhetorical nonsense --nonsense upon stilts.'For 'natural right'substitute utility,and you have,of course,a reasonable principle,because an appeal to experience.But lay down 'liberty'as an absolute right and you annihilate law,for every law supposes coercion.

One man gets liberty simply by restricting the liberty of others.(99)What Bentham substantially says,therefore,is that on this version absolute rights of individuals could mean nothing but anarchy;or that no law can be defended except by a reference to facts,and therefore to 'utility.'

One answer might be that the demand is not for absolute liberty,but for as much liberty as is compatible with equal liberty for all.The fourth article of the Declaration says:'Liberty consists in being able to do that which is not hurtful to another,and therefore the exercise of the natural rights of each man has no other bounds than those which ensure to the other members of the society the enjoyment of the same rights.'This formula corresponds to a theory held by Mr Herbert Spencer;and,as he observes,(100)held on different grounds by Kant.Bentham's view,indicated by his criticism of this article in the 'Anarchical Fallacies,'is therefore worth a moment's notice.The formula does not demand the absolute freedom which would condemn all coercion and all government;but it still seems to suggest that liberty,not utility,is the ultimate end.Bentham's formula,therefore,diverges.

All government,he holds,is an evil,because coercion implies pain.We must therefore minimise,though we cannot annihilate,government;but we must keep to utility as the sole test.Government should,of course,give to the individual all such rights as are 'useful';but it does not follow,without a reference to utility,that men should not be restrained even in 'self-regarding'conduct.Some men,women,and children require to be protected against the consequences of their own 'weakness,ignorance,or imprudence.'(101)Bentham adheres,that is,to the strictly empirical ground.The absolute doctrine requires to be qualified by a reference to actual circumstances:and,among those circumstances,as Bentham intimates,we must include the capacity of the persons concerned to govern themselves.Carried out as an absolute principle,it would imply the independence of infants;and must therefore require some reference to 'utility.'

Bentham,then,objects to the Jacobin theory as too absolute and too 'individualist.'

The doctrine begs the question;it takes for granted what can only be proved by experience;and therefore lays down as absolute theories which are only true under certain conditions or with reference to the special circumstances to which they are applied.That is inconsistent with Bentham's thoroughgoing empiricism.But he had antagonists to meet upon the other side:and,in meeting them,he was led to a doctrine which has been generally condemned for the very same faults --as absolute and individualist.We have only to ask in what sense Bentham appealed to 'experience'to see how he actually reached his conclusions.The adherents of the old tradition appealed to experience in their own way.The English people,they said,is the freest,richest,happiest in the world;it has grown up under the British Constitution:therefore the British Constitution is the best in the world,as Burke tells you,and the British common law,as Blackstone tells you,is the 'perfection of wisdom.'

Bentham's reply was virtually that although he,like Burke,appealed to experience,he appealed to experience scientifically organised,whereas Burke appealed to mere blind tradition.Bentham is to be the founder of a new science,founded like chemistry on experiment,and his methods are to be as superior to those of Burke as those of modern chemists to those of the alchemists who also invoked experience.The true plan was not to throw experience aside because it was alleged by the ignorant and the prejudiced,but to interrogate experience systematically,and so to become the Bacon or the Newton of legislation,instead of wandering off into the a priori constructions of a Descartes or a Leibniz.

Bentham thus professes to use an 'inductive'instead of the deductive method of the Jacobins;but reaches the same practical conclusions from the other end.The process is instructive.He objected to the existing inequalities,not as inequalities simply,but as mischievous inequalities.He,as well as the Jacobins,would admit that inequality required justification;and he agreed with them that,in this case,there was no justification.The existing privileges did not promote the 'greatest happiness of the greatest number.'

The attack upon the 'Anarchical Fallacies'must be taken with the Book of Fallacies,and the Book of Fallacies is a sustained and vigorous,though a curiously cumbrous,assault upon the Conservative arguments.Its pith may be found in Sydney Smith's Noodle's Oration;but it is itself well worth reading by any one who can recognise really admirable dialectical power,and forgive a little crabbedness of style in consideration of genuine intellectual vigour.I only notice Bentham's assault upon the 'wisdom of our ancestors.'

同类推荐
  • 元代野史

    元代野史

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 定应大师布袋和尚传

    定应大师布袋和尚传

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • Of Refinement in the Arts

    Of Refinement in the Arts

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • The Scapegoat

    The Scapegoat

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • William the Conqueror

    William the Conqueror

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 浴火凰妃:废材小姐要逆天

    浴火凰妃:废材小姐要逆天

    当慕容家被虐致死的六小姐遇上重生的现代特工慕容薰仪,别人打我一分我比奉还十倍!拒皇子,斗小妹,掌家主!就是要告诉他们出来混迟早是要还的!
  • 穿越之炮灰在九零年代

    穿越之炮灰在九零年代

    想要发财?八十年代摆地摊,九十年代玩股票,二十一世纪搞搞房地产!安容从二十一世纪回到了九十年代,成为一个亲爹妈不爱的女炮灰。她唯一能做的就是努力赚钱,大杀四方!
  • 左相大人的小娇妻

    左相大人的小娇妻

    为图一时方便,龙湘湘女扮男装潜出府邸,却不料误入虎口,遇上中了媚药的左相大人,那左相大人药力发作,不管对方是男是女,强攻而上……醒来后,枕边人已然不见,面对自己可能侵犯了男人这事,左相大人想假装失忆……可真正失忆的却是受害者龙湘湘。她惊慌失措,一脚踩空,直接从楼梯上滚下去了,这下好了,把脑袋给摔懵了,醒来后谁也不认识,更别提被谁夺走初次了。再次重逢时,谁也不认识谁。……“小女龙湘湘,见过左相大人。”盈盈一笑,便是那百花千开,也比不上这一笑。情之一字不动则已,一动则覆水难收。……“湘湘,可愿做我的夫人?”“那,左相大人,可愿做我夫君?”
  • 中学生必知的科学保健常识(上)

    中学生必知的科学保健常识(上)

    健康长寿,几乎是每个人的期盼,而年轻的人们,大多过早离去和被病痛折磨,健康的生命远远少于预期,其中健康至关重要,关系着人的成长,左右着人的生命,没有了健康,就算再有钱,再有权也换不来一个好的身体。本书精选了日常生活中青少年健康保健的奥秘和知识,力图打开那知悉不多的密码,让每个青少年都健康成长。
  • 重生九零年之虐渣攻略

    重生九零年之虐渣攻略

    被丈夫残忍推下高楼的金牌命理师,重返十八岁,意外开启观气之能。
  • 天兆传奇

    天兆传奇

    天道茫茫,自凄凉;难回望,一曲悲歌愁断肠……他身于帝王家,享尽芳华;他成于帝王家,灭亲成帝;他败于帝王家,天谴断魂;他经历了亡国之痛,尝尽了悲苦冷暖,投身在战争杀伐,谋划在尔虞我诈;他凭借胆识坐拥百万军马,他凭借人格集贤纳仕,他走于鬼门关边,与人斗,与鬼斗,书写下一段荡气回肠,可歌可泣的帝王路……
  • 小夜曲:音乐与黄昏五故事集(2017诺奖得主石黑一雄作品)

    小夜曲:音乐与黄昏五故事集(2017诺奖得主石黑一雄作品)

    本书是作者的第一部短篇集,全书以音乐为线索,由五个看似独立却又相互关联的故事组成。故事的主要人物都同音乐情牵相关:郁郁不得志的餐厅乐手,风光不再的过气歌星,孤芳自赏的大提琴手,为求成功被迫整容的萨克斯手等等,多是对音乐一往情深,对生活却满腹牢骚。情节或荒诞不经,或令人唏嘘,借音乐人生这个主题,表现了作者一贯的对现代人生存状态的反思:理想与现实的差距,命运的嘲弄,才华的折磨,以及庞大社会机器控制下被压抑的情感……
  • 卿自佳人

    卿自佳人

    卿自佳人,奈何做贼。她本是一个聪明,美丽,活泼的富家小姐,无奈因为家里连遭变故,被大火毁掉了容颜,经历坎坷,以甚至被恋人“抛弃”,为了查清真相,寻回母亲珍贵的首饰,在险境中被相似遭遇的美男救治,从此两人辗转江湖,变成了“盗贼”,有人说她是侠盗,帮助过很多人,有人说她是传奇,与两个年轻男人纠缠不断,爱恨缠绵,但最终与爱人终成良缘,从江湖全身而退。
  • 福尔摩斯探案全集:回忆录

    福尔摩斯探案全集:回忆录

    《回忆录》为短篇小说集,依出版顺序是系列第四部。《银色白额马》讲述了赌马赛上一匹白宝驹将稳操胜券,但驯马师阴谋割伤其腿腱不料被马踢死,正巧有人来探马被疑凶犯,马则脱逃被另外厩主藏匿。福尔摩斯终得破案,宝驹按时出赛大获全胜。《最后一案》叙述福尔摩斯与强大的恶势力头目莫利亚蒂斗争,屡挫对手,对方疯狂追杀,一路追到瑞士,二人搏斗坠崖同归于尽……每个故事都自成体系,悬念迭起,情节一波三折,步步惊心,引人入胜,充满了作者特有的惊悚、紧张、刺激和恐怖的色彩。
  • 进取心·穿越大海的海鸥

    进取心·穿越大海的海鸥

    本书分为七章,内容包括:不要放弃、专心勤奋的学徒、志在四方、最好的角度、自我约束方能成大事等。收录了《蚂蚁》、《冒雪求学》、《石头与宝石》、《收买公鸡》、《家庭实验室》、《麻雀造窝》、《年少轻狂》、《破旧的航船》等故事。